Skip to content

While Major League Soccer green lights retroactive suspensions, critics are missing the point

Apr 11, 2012, 10:35 AM EDT

Ricardo Salazar, Marvin Chavez, Tim Ream

Each time Major League Soccer announces a retroactive suspension, cries of injustice rise, claims of inconsistency reverberate through the internet and inchoate fears of bad precedent or undermining match officials clap like ominous thunder.

But people are missing the point.

All of this isn’t about making Shalrie Joseph sit out a match. It’s not about making Danny Cruz feel bad for unbecoming gamesmanship, and not about teaching Jair Benitez a lesson. Not exactly, anyway.

This is about making MLS players more aware and more responsible. It’s about player safety. And in the bigger picture, still, it’s an overdue course correction that will create better curb appeal through more watchable matches.

This is about restoring some balance to the place Major League Soccer falls along the continuum of restrain and self-control. On one end is a very technical league, where contact is minimal and “touch fouls” are whistled like Friday night social soccer; on the other end is a league that looks more like mud wrestling than soccer.

Most reasonable people would agree that MLS should land somewhere in the middle, not especially close to either end. What league owners have asked of the disciplinary committee and of its players and clubs is to adjust it toward the technical end.

There’s no question it had long ago migrated to far the other way, walking too frequently through the rough neighborhoods of the game.

As for the recent, retroactive suspensions: I understand the cry for consistency and public pressure to create it serves everyone well. But do know this: MLS won’t get it right 100 percent of the time. It’s a tough mark to hit, with lots of interpretation and situational context involved.

Still, trying to get there is the proper thing, a righteous stab at a course correction that was desperately needed. It’s worth getting it wrong here and there.

Get it wrong this way and someone sits out a match unfairly. Keep it the other way and more legs get broken, more players lose their careers to concussions.

By the way, does anybody think there wasn’t inconsistency before? Of course there was, outrageous degrees of it. But the previous inconsistency was the sole province of the man in the middle on match days.

Now, with time and license provided to the disciplinary committee to consider the evidence, the chances of creating consistency has risen dramatically.

In the end, the games will be better. The league will be better. The process won’t be perfect – but the status quo was maddeningly far from perfect, too.

Latest Posts
  1. MLS Snapshot: Chicago Fire 2-0 FC Dallas (video)

    Aug 2, 2015, 9:15 PM EDT

    Accam Getty Images

    David Accam helped lead Chicago Fire over FC Dallas to end the visitors five-game winning streak.

  2. WATCH: Ex-Barcelona midfielder Xavi scores a wonderful free-kick on debut for Qatari club

    Aug 2, 2015, 8:06 PM EDT

    Xavi Getty Images

    Xavi gets up for preseason friendlies, and in his first match for his new club, the 35-year-old rips a classic free kick.

  3. MLS Snapshot: San Jose Earthquakes 0-0 Portland Timbers (video)

    Aug 2, 2015, 7:03 PM EDT

    Valeri Getty Images

    Diego Valeri missed a penalty as neither side could take advantage of its few big chances.

  4. Premier League friendly roundup: Southampton draws, Stoke swallowed

    Aug 2, 2015, 6:36 PM EDT

    Hughes Getty Images

    It was a tough day for a number of Premier League teams who suffered losses and setbacks, most notably Mark Hughes and Stoke City.

  5. Jack Wilshere to miss the start of the season with another ankle problem

    Aug 2, 2015, 5:25 PM EDT

    Wilshere Getty Images

    The 23-year-old midfielder has struggled with ankle problems in the past, and another has cropped up.

  6. Premier League 2015-16 season preview: West Ham United

    Aug 2, 2015, 5:00 PM EDT

    WestHamLogo

    Some big signings this summer and a new manager has fans excited for what could be this coming year.

  7. Premier League 2015-16 season preview: West Bromwich Albion

    Aug 2, 2015, 3:14 PM EDT

    WestBromLogo

    Tony Pulis is a hard-nosed leader, but unless Saido Berahino can repeat his goal-scoring year from last season, it will be a tough go for the Baggies.

  8. Arsene Wenger, Jose Mourinho fail to shake hands, as Gunners boss finally prevails

    Aug 2, 2015, 1:07 PM EDT

    The long-time spat between the managers of Arsenal and Chelsea rumbles on.

  9. Sunday’s Transfer Rumor Roundup: Liverpool wants Cheryshev, Pato to Sunderland

    Aug 2, 2015, 12:45 PM EDT

    FC Internazionale v Real Madrid- International Champions Cup Getty Images

    Catch up on all the latest transfer rumors and gossip, right here.

  10. Three things we learned from Arsenal’s Community Shield win vs. Chelsea

    Aug 2, 2015, 11:57 AM EDT

    Wenger finally beats Mourinho, while the Blues have some issues up front.

  11. Arsenal 1-0 Chelsea: Oxlade-Chamberlain strike wins Gunners FA Community Shield

    Aug 2, 2015, 11:55 AM EDT

    cd0ymzcznguwzdbhnduynddiytjhm2yyzthlmtjjotqwyyznptq2mtvlzdlkyzrjzwnhzdg3ywvhyzy2m2qznzzkmwu11 AP

    Arsenal takes claim to the Community Shield as Arsene Wenger has finally defeated Jose Mourinho.

  12. VIDEO: Brilliant finish from Oxlade-Chamberlain puts Arsenal ahead in Community Shield

    Aug 2, 2015, 10:49 AM EDT

    Arsenal celebrate their opening goal vs. Chelsea. AP

    The Gunners took a 1-0 first half lead over Chelsea in the FA Community Shield thanks to a classy finish from Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain.

  13. VIDEO: Watch the Wright-Phillips brothers combine for slick goal in Red Bulls’ win

    Aug 2, 2015, 10:04 AM EDT

    Bradley Wright-Phillips, Bill Hamid AP

    In the City of Brotherly Love, it was only fitting that the Wright-Phillips boys led New York to a victory.

  14. Premier League 2015-16 season preview: Watford

    Aug 2, 2015, 9:10 AM EDT

    watford.crest

    In both of Watford’s two seasons in the Premier League, the club finished in last place. Can the newly promoted Hornets avoid relegation the third time around?

  15. Roy Keane thinks Arsenal players too focused on “selfies and six-packs”

    Aug 2, 2015, 9:07 AM EDT

    Arsenal v Everton: Barclays Asia Trophy Getty Images

    There’s a legitimate chance that Roy Keane has never taken a picture with his cell phone.

  16. Report: Manchester United, PSG agree to $70 million fee for Angel di Maria

    Aug 2, 2015, 8:12 AM EDT

    Everton v Manchester United - Premier League Getty Images

    Manchester United’s Di Maria experiment is all but over, and it’s going to cost them $20 million.

Featured video

What can we expect from PL new boys?