Skip to content

Quality backup goalkeepers: extravagance or necessity?

Apr 12, 2012, 5:10 PM EDT

Paolo Tornaghi

Is a high-quality backup goalkeeper an extravagance in Major League Soccer?

Most of us may discuss and debate this leisurely, over cold ones with friends while trying desperately to remember that adorable server’s name. It’s just a hypothetical for us.

But for MLS decision makers this is a significant, real-world choice – with possible employment consequences. And them’s big consequences.

Toronto FC has a choice to make once Stefan Frei returns from a broken leg. Word comes that the choice may already have been made, as The Sun out of Canada says Aron Winter and crew were looking to move Frei, who was expendable because Milos Kocic developed apace and held steady in starting assignments.

Toronto, like so many other sides, has real needs around the field. So, can they afford to keep a potential starter on the bench when other needs are pressing? Making the right call could mean the difference in playoffs or no playoffs – and job or no job.

The five teams that may have such a “luxury,” if you consider it so:

Toronto FC – Kocic was in goal for the side’s one shining moment in 2012, the massive march win at Los Angeles. He’s been strong enough since then, which is why Frei may be on the outs.

Columbus – It’s getting harder to remember a time when William Hesmer wasn’t the No. 1 around Crew Stadium. But Andy Gruenebaum has never disappointed when forced by injury into duty. Gruenebaum is 29, hardly old for a goalkeeper. Kevin Hartman, 37, remains one of the league’s best, and Kasey Keller just hung ‘em up at 41. So Gruenebaum has time to latch onto a starting assignment somewhere.

D.C. United – This is a little out of nowhere, because the sample for second-year man Joe Willis remains tiny (just four matches this year, after three last year). But the 23-year-old sure looks up for a starting job somewhere. Would United consider making a move considering they have two promising ‘keeper prospects in Willis and U.S. under-23 Bill Hamid? (Not to mention young Andrew Dykstra, formerly a starter in Chicago.)

Chicago Fire – Everyone assumed the No. 1 shirt at Toyota Park was solid property of Sean Johnson, a quality up-and-comer who already has time with the U.S. national team, plus 41 career starts for the Fire. But along comes Paolo Tornaghi (pictured) – and the young Italian isn’t bad at all. Johnson is back from his time with the Olympic team, but it looks like Tornaghi is Frank Klopas’ man for now.

New England – Matt Reis has been the trusty incumbent for so long around Gillette Stadium, there has never been much need to discuss importing a young buck to push competition. For the last couple of years Bobby Shuttleworth has been backup, and a Shuttleworth appearance has generally not meant any significant dropoff in goal guarding quality. You wonder how many teams might be happy with Shuttleworth, 24, as a starter?

Latest Posts
  1. Paderborn keeps scoring ridiculous goals, keeps winning

    Oct 21, 2014, 12:10 AM EDT

    Paderborn Getty Images

    Paderborn hasn’t stopped winning or scoring insane goals, if you haven’t noticed.

  2. VIDEO: Men In Blazer – Balotelli, own goals, and Mark Consuelos

    Oct 20, 2014, 11:29 PM EDT

    Men In Blazers

    Actor Mark Consuelos made his way to the Crap Part of Soho while the Men In Blazers tried to keep the ball out of their own net.

  3. Champions League Tuesday preview: City in Russia, Roma hosts Bayern

    Oct 20, 2014, 10:47 PM EDT

    Bayern AP

    Bayern Munich have a very difficult match on the road in Italy, while other matchups in Spain, Russia, and Germany will all prove enjoyable.

  4. USWNT 6-0 Haiti: Wambach braces US in 90 minute demolition of Haiti

    Oct 20, 2014, 9:28 PM EDT

    Lloyd AP

    Meghan Klingenberg bagged a laser beam for her first US goal and Abby Wambach grabbed two as the Americans will move on to the semifinals.

  5. Manchester Police arrest man for flying drone over City vs Spurs match

    Oct 20, 2014, 8:42 PM EDT

    Photo credit: Greater Manchester Police Photo credit: Greater Manchester Police

    Manchester Police confirmed a man was arrested after flying a drone over the match that entertained 45,000 people.

  6. Americans Abroad: Johannsson, Cameron, Boyd all return

    Oct 20, 2014, 8:00 PM EDT

    Cameron AP

    Aron Johannsson bagged a penalty in his return from groin surgery, while Juan Agudelo continues to search for a new club.

  7. Adel Taarabt jabs back after Redknapp’s scathing comments

    Oct 20, 2014, 6:55 PM EDT

    Taarabt Getty Images

    Adel Taarabt says the harsh words from manager Harry Redknapp are not only untrue but damaging as a professional.

  8. New York Cosmos reportedly sign Spanish legend Raul, will play and coach

    Oct 20, 2014, 6:16 PM EDT

    Raul Getty Images

    The New York Cosmos completed a massive signing, beating out a few of his former clubs to nab the Spanish legend as a player and coach.

  9. Report: It will be Colombia – not Croatia – for USMNT in November

    Oct 20, 2014, 5:36 PM EDT

    Jurgen Klinsmann

    Despite a solid confirmation from Croatia, the friendly will reportedly not be happening.

  10. WATCH: West Brom 2-2 Manchester United: Blind earns draw for Red Devils on road

    Oct 20, 2014, 4:56 PM EDT

    WestBromUnited Getty Images

    Manchester United came from behind twice but still must settle for a disappointing result away from home.

  11. Teen Lazio striker totals his Lamborghini in Rome

    Oct 20, 2014, 4:35 PM EDT

    Lambo

    19-year-old Lazio striker Keita Balde Diao somehow walked away from what looks to be a major accident. His Lamborghini, however, didn’t.

  12. UEFA fines Wales and Galatasary, spare Arsenal

    Oct 20, 2014, 3:20 PM EDT

    Arsenal FC v Galatasaray AS - UEFA Champions League Getty Images

    Unruly fans will cost Wales and Galatasary as UEFA continues to crack down on off-the-pitch incidents.

  13. 2014 Homeless World Cup kicks off in Chile

    Oct 20, 2014, 2:35 PM EDT

    FBL-CHILE-HOMELESS WORLD CUP Getty Images

    The yearly tournament organizes five-a-side matches for people that are homeless or living in extreme poverty.

  14. Transfer talk: Multiple PL clubs interested in Andre Ayew

    Oct 20, 2014, 1:30 PM EDT

    FBL-FRA-LIGUE1-GUINGAMP-MARSEILLE Getty Images

    Liverpool, Everton and Swansea City are just a few of the Premier League clubs reportedly looking to sign the Marseille winger.

  15. Lukas Podolski: ‘Hell will freeze over’ before playing for Spurs

    Oct 20, 2014, 12:37 PM EDT

    FBL-ENG-FACUP-ARSENAL-HULL Getty Images

    With transfer rumors swirling, the Arsenal forward made it clear that he is #AlwaysAGunner.

  16. South Africa rules out hosting Africa Cup of Nations

    Oct 20, 2014, 11:51 AM EDT

    FBL-AFR2015-SUD-RSA Getty Images

    Amidst the Ebola outbreak, South Africa has ruled out hosting the continent’s premier tournament should Morocco back out.

  17. Indian player dies after goal celebration

    Oct 20, 2014, 11:00 AM EDT

    Sad news out of India as a young player died after injuring his spinal cord during a celebration.

  18. CSKA Moscow striker says Manchester City are ‘very weak’

    Oct 20, 2014, 10:15 AM EDT

    FBL-EUR-C1-CSKA-BAYERN Getty Images

    Ahmed Musa stirred the pot ahead of his club’s Champions League clash this week, calling out City’s form.

  19. Premier League Preview: West Brom vs. Manchester United

    Oct 20, 2014, 9:30 AM EDT

    FBL-ENG-PR-MAN UTD-WEST BROM Getty Images

    Watch the Baggies take on Manchester United today, live at 3:00 p.m. ET on NBCSN.

  20. Petr Cech is giving Thibaut Courtois safety tips

    Oct 20, 2014, 8:40 AM EDT

    Chelsea v Arsenal - Premier League Getty Images

    The Chelsea backup is teaching his replacement how to stay safe from head injuries, which have affected both keepers.

Featured video

Week 8: Saturday PL recap