Skip to content

Ranking MLS goalkeepers: Dallas’ Kevin Hartman at the top

Apr 19, 2012, 5:25 PM EDT

Portland Timbers v FC Dallas Getty Images

By Round 7 of Major League Soccer the sample of matches is substantial enough to get a decent handle on relative, individual form.

We may not know definitively who still has it in 2012, who lost it, who has more of it, etc. – but we’re starting to get a pretty good idea.

Besides, ranking the positions is just plain fun, like snow cones or your favorite song cranked up to 11.

So let’s roll! Here are my Top 10 goalkeepers now in MLS. It’s a relative assessment that heavily weighs the here and now (current form) along with some consideration of long-term upside (future potential), all while allowing some small heed to the critical intangible of leadership. Think of it this way: If you started an MLS team today and needed a good goalkeeper for the 2012 season, which one would it be?

Here’s who I would take:

1. Kevin Hartman, FC Dallas

2. Nick Rimando, Real Salt Lake

3. Jon Busch, San Jose                       

4. Jimmy Nielsen, Sporting Kansas City                    

5. Matt Reis, New England

6. Michael Gspurning, Seattle               

7. Dan Kennedy, Chivas USA                     

8. Joe Cannon, Vancouver

9. Tally Hall, Houston                    

10. Josh Saunders, L.A. Galaxy

Rational, motive and intent: Hartman’s leadership and shot-stopping for FC Dallas have been nearly flawless since his 2010 arrival into Texas. His ability to deal with crosses isn’t the best in the business, but it’s not so bad that it keeps him off the top of my list.

Between Busch and Rimando, it’s more or less a wash in my book in pure ability; Rimando’s leadership puts him in the No. 2 spot. I haven’t seen enough of Gspurning, but I like what I have seen. Ability-wise, Tally Hall might deserve a slightly higher ranking, but this is just his second season in a starting assignment. Experience counts for a lot, but I might expect him to climb in a year or so.  

As for the rest …

There’s a really good crop coming up, and it’s not just two young U.S. internationals, Sean Johnson and Bill Hamid. Chicago’s Paolo Tornaghi, D.C. United’s Joe Willis, Philadelphia’s Zac MacMath and the New York Red Bulls Ryan Meara all show promise.

Toronto’s Stefan Frei would have been Top 5 last year, but a dip in form and a pair of (possibly related) injuries meant that, well, I really didn’t know what to do with Frei for this list.

And Donovan Ricketts, who would definitely have been on the Top 5 at this time last year? He’s had some curiously wobbly moments this year in goal for Montreal.

  1. dreadpirate82 - Apr 19, 2012 at 5:50 PM

    I would move Kennedy up to 4th. That guy is a wall. Every time I see him play, it seems like he’s trying to one-up his last performance. Actually, he could be even higher, if his team supported him a bit more. Other than Reis, he is the least-supported keeper on the list.

    Nielsen has been tough to judge this year, as he could be chasing butterflies around the box most of the time. His performance last night was a nice reminder of his skill, and probably good for him to keep from getting rusty.

    I’m not a big Rimando fan, but his flair for the spectacular makes his ranking tough to argue.

    • Steve Davis - Apr 19, 2012 at 6:17 PM

      Completely agree on Nielsen. Tough. But hard to nick him just because he’s bored back there.

  2. manutebol - Apr 19, 2012 at 6:17 PM

    Not impressed by MEara… poor stats so far back up my draft day opinion of him… he put up good college numbers only because he played in an incredibly weak conference, he is not a good keeper prospect. NY need to make a change there.

    • Steve Davis - Apr 19, 2012 at 6:38 PM

      Fair enough, but you think no potential?

  3. thekingofnorway - Apr 19, 2012 at 7:23 PM

    Interesting to see you rate Kennedy so low, when some are touting him as a fringe MVP candidate early in the season.

    As a Gsounders fan, I immediately jumped to see your agssesment of Gspurnning. And … I think that’s about right. I think he’s probably better than Reis or Busch, but not better than Rimando, Hartman or Nielsen. His tendency to punch makes me really nervous, but thus far it seems to be working well for him and his 8’9″ arms. He hasn’t given up a goal in the run of play over the last three matches.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

PST Extra: Analyzing transfer deadline day