Skip to content

Why Major League Soccer got it right on Rafa Marquez’s three-game suspension

Apr 19, 2012, 1:10 PM EST

New York Red Bulls Media Day Getty Images

I know the umbrage and outrage is ricocheting around the internet now, wondering why Major League Soccer didn’t wallop Rafa Marquez a little harder over the head with the frying pan of justice.

Me? I’d say justice was served with Thursday’s announcement of a three-game suspension for the reckless and senseless actions that have put San Jose attacker Shea Salinas out for 6-8 weeks.

(I covered some of the context and consequences in a previous post.)

I do get the reflexive reaction here. In a lot of circles, Rafa Marquez is a shadowy figure with a history of menacing behavior who deserves to have the book thrown at him.  Who could possibly forget Marquez’s flying kung fu combo assault on Cobi Jones back in the 2002 World Cup, where the Mexican international defied the laws of physics by simultaneously head butting and kicking his American opponent?

A bunch of people haven’t forgotten, so that’s fueling some of the extra ire in this case. The Mexico-U.S. rivalry surely simmers, sub-plot style, in the backdrop on this one.

But the disciplinary committee’s job isn’t to administer frontier justice nor to right previous wrongs. And it most certainly shouldn’t consider nationality and international rivalries when dealing with the important business of crime and punishment.

At its core, the Marquez suspension and the ongoing, prickly practice of issuing retroactive suspensions based on video evidence is about player awareness, and about Major League Soccer goosing the enterprise to create the product they want.

I completely understand the call for a longer suspension, something more along the lines of what Salinas will miss (probably somewhere around 6-8 games). But this really isn’t eye-for-an-eye stuff – and anybody suggesting MLS move in that direction really hasn’t thought this through.

If you go there, then perhaps Shalrie Joseph (a very important player for New England) would be out for an equal duration as the injured Ricardo Villar (a backup midfielder for FC Dallas, although he was starting due to other injuries). Fair swap? Not really – especially considering that Joseph’s tackle was pretty low on the scale of menace.

Injuries do happen. They are unfortunate, but they can’t be legislated out of the game. Plenty of injuries have nothing to do with the reckless, careless or violent actions that Major League Soccer is trying so hard to reduce. Some do, and injuries are rightly being considered when the disciplinary committee adjudicates these matters – just not in equal measure of recovery time to punishment length.

The messages are being heard by players. The course correction (so far overdue) is under way and players know they bang and bust at their own risk.

I feel bad for the fallen Earthquakes midfielder, but this isn’t about Rafa Marquez and Shea Salinas per se.

The bigger picture is about creating a better game, enforcing tougher standards, ensuring player safety and delivering a more watchable product. We’re all better served when the soccer  is a little easier on the eyes, a game with more finesse and a little less fouling, obstructing, colliding and crunching – the tactics that mitigate and marginalize skill in this sport.

Latest Posts
  1. Manchester United’s two-goal hero Wayne Rooney hails “deserved win.” Should he stay up front?

    Feb 28, 2015, 12:33 PM EST

    With RVP out injured and Falcao firing blanks, surely Rooney should remain up front…

  2. Stoke City 1-0 Hull City: Super sub Crouch stays hot, nabs Potters point

    Feb 28, 2015, 12:10 PM EST

    b0f8e07f8546f054f178b35c8325c107 Getty Images

    The giant Englishman scored less than a minute after subbing on for Mame Diouf, and Stoke stayed in the top half.

  3. Burnley 0-1 Swansea City: Own goal, Fabianski foil Clarets at Turf Moor

    Feb 28, 2015, 12:03 PM EST

    Burnley v Swansea City - Premier League Getty Images

    The three points moved Swansea ahead of West Ham for eight in the Premier League table.

  4. Manchester United 2-0 Sunderland: Rooney nets double to seal easy win

    Feb 28, 2015, 11:57 AM EST

    Manchester United v Sunderland - Premier League Manchester United v Sunderland - Premier League

    Rooney’s double sees off a stubborn Sunderland side to cement United’s spot in the top four.

  5. Newcastle United 1-0 Aston Villa: Cisse’s goal keeps Sherwood’s Villans in the drop zone

    Feb 28, 2015, 11:55 AM EST

    cd5e63930af01b2ae5ebb9355e08734b Getty Images

    Villa’s 22 points are even with Burnley and QPR, but their goal differential is the worst of the three.

  6. VIDEO: Allardyce “shocked” by West Ham’s two-goal loss to Crystal Palace

    Feb 28, 2015, 11:40 AM EST

    FBL-ENG-PR-WEST HAM-CRYSTAL PALACE Getty Images

    Mark the date as the moment Sam Allardyce’s long shot dreams of European football for West Ham all but died.

  7. WATCH: Aubameyang/Reus pull Batman/Robin celebration, then Reus makes a GK look silly

    Feb 28, 2015, 11:34 AM EST

    @Bundesliga @Bundesliga

    TheRevierderby was all Borussia Dortmund, which keeps climbing the Bundesliga table after a horrible start to the season.

  8. VIDEO: Alan Pardew delighted with two-goal hero Murray despite red card

    Feb 28, 2015, 11:15 AM EST

    Murray scores twice, gets red card in eventful outing at Upton Park.

  9. LIVE – Premier League, at the half: West Brom, Newcastle ahead; goalless elsewhere

    Feb 28, 2015, 10:55 AM EST

    Newcastle United v Aston Villa - Premier League Getty Images

    Goals are in short supply. See if they arrive in the second half by watching live, here.

  10. Watch Live: Stoke City vs. Hull City (Lineups and Live Stream)

    Feb 28, 2015, 9:44 AM EST

    Hull City v Stoke City - Premier League Getty Images

    Sone Aluko and Gaston Ramirez move last week’s hero Dame N’Doye to the bench, as the Tigers look to put together a three-match winning streak.

  11. Watch Live: Burnley vs. Swansea City (Lineups and Live Stream)

    Feb 28, 2015, 9:39 AM EST

    Britain Soccer Premier League AP

    Danny Ings will lead the charge for Burnley, which has controversially non-suspended Ashley Barnes in the Starting XI.

  12. West Ham United 1-3 Crystal Palace: Eagles win fiery London derby

    Feb 28, 2015, 9:39 AM EST

    Eagles soar past Hammers a Murray scores twice, gets red card.

  13. Watch Live: Newcastle United vs. Aston Villa (Lineups and Live Stream)

    Feb 28, 2015, 9:35 AM EST

    Aston Villa v Newcastle United - Premier League Getty Images

    Emmanuel Riviere gets a start for Newcastle, with Ayoze Perez heading for the bench. Cancer-battler Jonas Gutierrez is back in the 18 as well.

  14. Watch Live: West Bromwich Albion vs. Southampton (Lineups and Live Stream)

    Feb 28, 2015, 9:27 AM EST

    Koeman's arrival as boss has been key in steadying Saints. Getty Images

    Can the Baggies beat high-flying Saints? Watch live online, right here.

  15. Watch Live: Manchester United vs. Sunderland (Lineups and Live Stream)

    Feb 28, 2015, 9:08 AM EST

    Swansea City v Manchester United - Premier League Getty Images

    Can the Red Devils stay in the top four with a win? Watch live online, right here.

  16. WATCH: Premier League live online via NBC Sports Live Extra – Week 27

    Feb 28, 2015, 8:20 AM EST

    Live Extra

    How to watch every single PL game during Week 27 live online or via the app.

  17. Watch Live: West Ham United vs. Crystal Palace (Lineups and Live Stream)

    Feb 28, 2015, 7:33 AM EST

    Alan Pardew, Crystal Palace FC Alan Pardew, Crystal Palace FC

    How will Pardew get on as he returns to Upton Park? Watch live online, here.

  18. Odell Beckham Jr. appears on TV show in England, reveals former dream was to be a pro soccer player

    Feb 28, 2015, 7:20 AM EST

    Washington Redskins v New York Giants Getty Images

    Beckham chats with Sky Sports in the UK about his dream to play soccer, ‘that’ catch and much more.

  19. WATCH: Van Gaal remains coy over Manchester United’s league standing

    Feb 27, 2015, 11:46 PM EST

    Manchester United v Cambridge United - FA Cup Fourth Round Replay Getty Images

    Louis van Gaal speaks of Manchester United’s mindset at this stage of the season.