Skip to content

Blowing it big-time: video of a weighty referee mistake

May 24, 2012, 10:57 AM EDT

Matt Hedges, Orr Barouch

There’s going to be a lot of referee talk today … so let’s just get started.

And let’s not waste time by going namby-pamby and wading in slowly; let’s dive right into the pit and get muddy:

Hilario Grajeda blew it last night, big.

Referees have a tough job, and some decisions are tougher than others. Dive or foul inside the penalty area? Intent on handball? Red or yellow on a dangerous challenge? Collision of malice or benign intent?

These can be weighty choices attached to nuance and situation, complicated by the vagaries of purpose, history or angle of the view.

Then again, some choices are black and white. Sometimes it comes down to “them’s the rules.” And that’s the situation Grajeda faced last night as Chicago’s Marco Pappa took about four steps inside the 18 on a penalty kick against FC Dallas. It was a critical decision as Pappa’s goal was the game-winner in a 2-1 Fire victory. Watch it here:

.

.

(Update, via the Washington Post’s Steven Goff: On his Facebook page, Kevin Hartman wrote: “Man, that guy was so far inside the box, I wasn’t sure which player was going to take the penalty kick.” Brilliant!)

When Pappa got into the penalty area by 3-4 steps and then converted the rebound off Hartman’s save, that became an easy call. It’s one that nobody around Chicago would even protest, in all likelihood.

It’s the rule. And yet, Grajeda inexplicably, reprehensibly ignored the laws of the game.

These things are frequently ignored on a successful spot-shot conversion, but only when the referee typically adjudges that a technical violation didn’t influence the play, and therefore doesn’t warrant a re-kick. Even then, egregious violations sometimes do compel a PK retake. For instance, referee Mark Geiger ordered a retake just last weekend, adjudging that Chivas USA players got into the penalty area too quickly on Jose Correa’s second-half penalty kick (also a game-winner). Jorge Villafaña encroached by 3-4 steps. So Geiger was correct in requiring the re-kick. That’s too far.

Watch it here:

.

Latest Posts
  1. Euro qualifying at its midpoint: Predicting the 19 automatic qualifiers

    Mar 31, 2015, 11:05 PM EDT

    David Alaba AP

    The top two teams in each group will advance, while the best third-place side will also advance.

  2. On Jurgen Klinsmann and Michael Bradley and “playing out of position”

    Mar 31, 2015, 9:26 PM EDT

    Switzerland v USA - International Friendly Getty Images

    As bizarre as this is to read, Michael Bradley didn’t register a single helper for the States until 2011. In the Klinsmann era, he has 12.

  3. Altidore apologizes for red card woes: “Not the type of role model I want to be”

    Mar 31, 2015, 8:07 PM EDT

    FBL-SUI-USA-FRIENDLY Getty Images

    It was out of character for Altidore, who hadn’t received a red card for club or country since he was with AZ Alkmaar in 2012.

  4. Real Madrid lands $34 million Brazilian defender Danilo from Porto

    Mar 31, 2015, 7:17 PM EDT

    9c2fc3c2d0036f128d8501497dffd0ce Getty Images

    With the deal Porto have turned another big profit. See this incredible list below, as the Portuguese club giants have made close to $423 million.

  5. International roundup: No. 1 MLS pick posts first senior goal, Cape Verde upsets Portugal

    Mar 31, 2015, 6:20 PM EDT

    Cyle Larin Canada

    It was a busy couple days for friendlies outside of the draw between Switzerland and the USMNT, with some MLSers doing work in the mix.

  6. Spurs reach deal to buy disputed land for 56,000 seat stadium

    Mar 31, 2015, 5:27 PM EDT

    Tottenham Hotspur v Swansea City - Premier League Getty Images

    Tottenham Hotspur could have new, improved digs as soon as the 2018-19 season, according to the BBC.

  7. Andros Townsend nets late equalizer as England draws Italy in Turin (video)

    Mar 31, 2015, 4:38 PM EDT

    FBL-EURO-2016-ITA-ENG-FRIENDLY Getty Images

    Though Wayne Rooney had a series of good chances including a struck crossbar, it was the Tottenham man who beat Gianluigi Buffon to tie things up.

  8. Mats Hummels: Leaving Dortmund “would only be to Manchester United”

    Mar 31, 2015, 3:47 PM EDT

    FBL-EURO-2016-GEORGIA-GERMANY Getty Images

    What would the price tag be for the German star if he skipped Dortmund for Old Trafford?

  9. Three things we learned from the USMNT’s late 1-1 draw in Switzerland

    Mar 31, 2015, 2:50 PM EDT

    FBL-SUI-USA-FRIENDLY Getty Images

    Here are three points and a bonus reminder from the Yanks’ final match until April 15 in Texas against Mexico.

  10. Player ratings: Stars and flops for the USMNT in 1-1 draw at Switzerland

    Mar 31, 2015, 2:11 PM EDT

    Switzerland v USA - International Friendly Getty Images

    Jurgen Klinsmann’s States again allowed a second-half goal, though this one feels much different than the previous friendly failures.

  11. Lineups out for USMNT vs. Switzerland: Williams, Morales, Shea come in; diamond in midfield

    Mar 31, 2015, 11:16 AM EDT

    Danny Williams 2

    Klinsmann makes changes to team who lost to Denmark, switches up formation.

  12. Three things to look out for as USA take on Switzerland

    Mar 31, 2015, 10:02 AM EDT

    Denmark Soccer USA

    Plenty of intriguing questions surrounding the USMNT picture ahead of Tuesday’s game against the Swiss.

  13. European clubs to share record $2.4 billion pot dished out by UEFA in new deal

    Mar 31, 2015, 9:40 AM EDT

    French UEFA president Michel Platini spe Getty Images

    Top European teams will get extra revenue from Champions League, Europa League from next season.

  14. USMNT vs Switzerland preview: Last time they met, Michael Bradley scored the winner with a full head of hair

    Mar 30, 2015, 11:07 PM EDT

    Switzerland v USA - International Friendly Getty Images

    Maurice Edu and Danny Szetela helped the goal get going, and Bradley was barely more than 20 years old.

Featured video

Week 30: Headline PL moment