Skip to content

MLS, David Beckham and referee criticism … we’re about to see if a double-standard exists

May 24, 2012, 11:50 AM EDT

David Beckham

Let’s talk about the elephant in the MLS room:

(And, yes, we’re going to discuss referees. Again.)

It’s David Beckham’s treatment by the men in the middle. And possibly by the league, where the question of “double-standard” may be getting a big test.

For all the good things we can say about the Galaxy, worthy champs in 2011, ambitious club that pushes others to be better, attendance drivers, etc. … they’ve long had a victimization complex. When things go wrong, it’s too often someone else’s fault. They are the victims.

Only, things frequently do go the Galaxy way. They get the benefit of the doubt as much as anyone else. Obviously they don’t believe so – but who ever does?

Now, regarding Beckham:

He gets away with stunts that most players don’t. Bad tackles last year and early in 2012 that went unpunished or under-punished are perfect examples. And we could talk about the times put his hands on an opponents face or neck with impunity … but, in all honesty, Thierry Henry and Dwayne De Rosario often get away with that mess, too.

That’s the star-double standard at work; we see the same in other sports.

Beckham is also allowed wide latitude in the amount of demonstrative carping allowed. That man will get in a referee’s face more than an eye doctor.

But whatever. Those are tricky, in-the-moment decisions by referees who aren’t stupid; everyone knows Beckham’s value to the league, to sponsors and ticket sellers, etc., and the men in the middle do, as well.

But Wednesday … this is different. We’re about to see, for 100 percent sure, if a double standard is at work. Because Beckham went on the record, cameras rolling, with stinging criticism of referee Jair Maruffo.

Here’s what he said:

Unfortunately, we had someone in control of the game tonight that, every time we’ve had him, he wants to be the star, and that’s what happens when you have a referee who wants to be on ‘SportsCenter.’ That was disappointing.”

I’d say the “wants to be on SportsCenter” is going too far. Then again, I’m not on the Disciplinary Committee.

Let’s hit the WABAC machine. There are plenty of examples of players / managers getting suspended or fined for criticizing referees. Let me draw a circle around a couple I can find.

Here’s what RSL manager Jason Kreis said in 2008 to get suspended:

After three successive weeks of game-changing decisions, it’s time we vent a little bit and put things right. I have a team doing their best to reward fans through a frustrating time and a frustrating few years. I feel the players are doing what they need to, the coaching staff is doing what they do, but being wronged by critical referee decisions is unacceptable.

“It’s about time they start first off trying to be right, and then being fair. It’s too many game-breaking calls, all of them against Real Salt Lake.

“Inconsistency is when it goes one way one week and another the next week. (Decisions) are consistently going against us.”

And here’s what Timbers manager John Spencer said last year to earn a one-game suspension: (The referee in question in Abbey Okulaja, whose fitness is being called into question here.)

My 67-year-old mother-in-law can see it from the club deck. There’s an official standing right there, and you’re asking me why I’m having a go at the fourth official?”

“The referee was getting tired. He couldn’t cover the ground. And I said that to the fourth official, ‘He can’t cover the ground. He’s blowing calls from 50 to 60 yards away.’ Poor, poor performance by the referee.”

“You can’t keep brushing this . . . under the carpet . . . and hoping it’s going to go away.”

You’re on the spot, Major League Soccer. Beckham has put you there. What say you?

Latest Posts
  1. First MLS man qualifies for World Cup

    Jun 18, 2013, 5:32 PM EDT

    World Cup list

    Tim Cahill is the first Major League Soccer man to qualify for the World Cup.

  2. ProSoccerTalk’s weekly MLS rankings

    Jun 18, 2013, 3:30 PM EDT

    Houston Dynamo v Philadelphia Union - 1st Leg Getty Images

    Our weekly re-ordering of Major League Soccer teams, following 16 rounds of play:

  3. Can the United States deal with success vs. Honduras?

    Jun 18, 2013, 2:05 PM EDT

    Eddie Johnson, Brad Evans

    Some of the best U.S. success in the past has come when the United States was backed into a corner. Tonight looks much different:

  4. Lineup prediction for U.S.-Honduras qualifier

    Jun 18, 2013, 1:30 PM EDT

    US-Honduras lineup

    There are a few choices to be made ahead of Tuesday’s match in Utah:

  5. About that brilliant atmosphere last week in Seattle: Rio Tinto Stadium in Utah will rock, too

    Jun 18, 2013, 12:30 PM EDT

    U.S. fans

    Unsaid in this narrative is this: most U.S. sites are bright and alive these days.

  6. Stuart Pearce loses job as England’s U-21 manager

    Jun 18, 2013, 11:06 AM EDT

    Pearce

    Stuart Pearce has been relieved of his duties as manager of England’s U-21 squad.

  7. Australia are heading to the 2014 World Cup in Brazil

    Jun 18, 2013, 9:34 AM EDT

    kennedy

    Australia join Brazil and Japan as nations that already have booked their place in next summer’s World Cup.

  8. U.S. notes for tonight’s World Cup qualifier vs. Honduras

    Jun 18, 2013, 9:15 AM EDT

    Rio Tinto Stadium

    Talking about what’s ahead, plus more on tonight’s match at Rio Tinto Stadium outside Salt Lake City:

  9. Scottish football takes another hit as Hearts prepare for administration

    Jun 18, 2013, 7:56 AM EDT

    Hearts

    Hearts have put the entire squad up for sale to raise the reported £500,000 needed to get the club to the start of the season.

  10. Big opportunity ahead as United States faces Honduras in World Cup qualifying action

    Jun 18, 2013, 6:00 AM EDT

    US standings

    The teams meet tonight outside Salt Lake City as the drive for Brazil 2014 moves forward:

  11. Huge cost of World Cups: Did we need a protest like Brazil’s to point out the obvious?

    Jun 18, 2013, 12:10 AM EDT

    Demonstrators yell anti-government slogans during one of the many protests around Brazil's major cities in Belem Reuters

    Brazil has infrastructure concerns. They’ve also spent $3.3 billion on soccer stadia. No surprise, people aren’t happy.

  12. Christian Eriksen’s potential for Borussia Dortmund a particularly cloudy picture

    Jun 17, 2013, 10:43 PM EDT

    Ajax Amsterdam v SC Heerenveen - Eredivisie Getty Images

    The mythology of Ajax, Dutch soccer and one stars’ struggles outside the Dutch league make this potential transfer difficult to evaluate.

  13. Ancelotti may be impatient, but Real Madrid wait should prove inconsequential

    Jun 17, 2013, 8:23 PM EDT

    FBL-EUR-C1-PSG-PRESSER

    It’s only a matter of time before Ancelotti’s holding pattern’s resolved.

  14. Early returns from England’s offseason tell a tale of two Manchesters

    Jun 17, 2013, 7:39 PM EDT

    FC Barcelona v Malaga CF - La Liga Getty Images

    It’s early days, but while City close the gap, Manchester United have yet to act.

  15. This André Villas-Boas to Paris Saint-Germain link makes more sense by the day

    Jun 17, 2013, 6:51 PM EDT

    F1 Grand Prix of Monaco - Race Getty Images

    With a buy-out in his contract, Villas-Boas likely will be given a choice between Paris and London.

  16. Honduran international Maynor Figueroa completes move to Hull City

    Jun 17, 2013, 5:59 PM EDT

    Wigan Athletic's Figueroa challenges Tottenham Hotspur's Defoe during their English Premier League soccer match at The DW Stadium in Wigan Reuters

    Steve Bruce reunites with a player he brought to Wigan Athletic.

  17. It’s time FIFA reconsiders the Confederations Cup bid to the Oceania region

    Jun 17, 2013, 5:19 PM EDT

    FBL-WC2014-CONFED-TAH-NGR Getty Images

    Tahiti are a great story, but nobody wins when small countries get slaughtered by the world’s top teams.

  18. Vacation up soon for U.S. national team men – but not yet!

    Jun 17, 2013, 4:45 PM EDT

    FBL-WC2014-QUALIFIERS-USA-TRAINING

    A big theme is finishing strong so there’s more enjoyment in those vacations ahead:

  19. Jermaine Jones available for Tuesday’s match with Honduras

    Jun 17, 2013, 3:55 PM EDT

    Germany Soccer Bundesliga

    The U.S. midfielder has successfully completed the concussion recovery protocol:

  20. Monday’s Transfer Rumor Roundup: Bale to PSG and Koscileny wanted by Bayern and Barcelona

    Jun 17, 2013, 3:38 PM EDT

    Arsenal v Bolton Wanderers - Premier League Getty Images

    So just how serious are PSG? Word has it they’re ready to break the Premier League transfer record.

Top 10 Player Searches
  1. L. James (NBA)
  2. T. Parker (NBA)
  3. Y. Puig (MLB)
  4. D. Bishop (NFL)
  5. T. Cingrani (MLB)
  1. C. Andersen (NBA)
  2. D. Green (NBA)
  3. D. Wade (NBA)
  4. W. McGahee (NFL)
  5. T. Tebow (NFL)