Skip to content

Brendan Rodgers to Liverpool: So this is what it has come to

May 30, 2012, 4:44 PM EDT

Swansea City v Wolverhampton Wanderers - Premier League Getty Images

BBC is reporting Liverpool’s search for a manager is over. Now there’s only one big club in England without a permanent coach.

That’s because Swansea City’s Brendan Rodgers is set to take the helm at Anfield. He’ll get a three year deal. Swans will get $6-$7 million in compensation and the task of finding a new coach.

Seems Roberto Martínez would be a good fit, but would the booing stop at the Liberty Stadium should their prodigal son return? We’ll likely never know.

There was a number of reasons Martínez was a bad choice for Liverpool, all of which apply to Rodgers. Where Liverpool’s biggest concern is getting back into UEFA Champions League, Rodgers has no experience. He’s proven he can win at lower levels. He’s proven he can keep a team up. Neither of those skills are pertinent to success at Anfield.

More on Rodgers: A brief history of Liverpool’s new boss

But this line of thought begs a question: What if a manager at a lower-table club had no experience competing for Europe yet was truly – in an absolute, cosmic, indefatigable way – capable of success at Liverpool. How would we know?

We wouldn’t. That’s the unfair, double-edged sword that’s dividing this conversation. Rodgers hasn’t shown the skills to run Liverpool, the main reason being he hasn’t had the chance. Thus, any hire like this is going to be a leap of faith. The bosses with Fenway Sports Group must feel they have a view into Rodgers’ cosmic truth, because they’re set to push on.

There was a time when Liverpool didn’t have to make hires like this. They were capable of luring La Liga-winner bosses from Spain. They were capable of bringing in managers who took small West London clubs to within 90 minutes of a European title. Now, they’re hiring from below, even after an eighth place finish.

I still think Liverpool’s capable of hunting bigger game. Even the biggest cynic of Anfield’s lore would concede Liverpool’s managerial post is one of the 10-20 most prestigious in the world (excuse the large range). Is Brendan Rodgers one of the 10-20 best managers in the world? If he is, we have no proof.

Ideally, the Rodgers and Martínez’s of the world would have a spell at an Aston Villa-esque club – a place where you can build a team that could compete on the fringes of Europe and give people reason to think “if he can do it there …”

In fairness, that’s the same logic that led Roy Hodgson to Anfield, and we all know how that turned out.

There were other options, though they’re mostly names I’m pulling out of a hat. Luciano Spalletti’s done as much as he can in Russia. Manuel Pellegrini’s now linked with Roma; he seems willing to move from Malaga. Then there’s former boss Luis Enrique, or other Roma-linkee André Villas-Boas (who Liverpool interviewed). Dick Advocaat’s done will with Russia, Slaven Bilic’s in his last tournament with Croatia. Rudi Garcia’s seen his Lille team gutted, and who knows. If Liverpool was as persistent with Ajax’s Frank de Boar as they were with Rodgers, he may have come available.

All of these men have a pedigree that’s more consistent with the Anfield job than Rodgers’. But who knows. Maybe Rodgers’s interview gave FSG a glimpse into his cosmic awesomeness. Maybe there’s something specific to where FSG’s taking Liverpool that may preclude bringing in a man whose ideas are too firmly entrenched.

Or maybe, as we saw with de Boar and (originally) Rodgers, Liverpool just isn’t that glamourous a destination anymore? Unfortunately, that seems to be the message.

Latest Posts
  1. Benoit Assou-Ekotto suspended for comments on Anelka quenelle gesture

    Sep 19, 2014, 9:25 AM EDT

    Benoit-Assou-Ekotto-tweet-2932591

    Perhaps the investigation took a bit too long, but it seems many athletes did not understand the depths of their joke usage.

  2. Bastia’s Brandao gets six-month ban for headbutting PSG’s Thiago Motta

    Sep 19, 2014, 8:40 AM EDT

    _77681154_0aa4ee3d-419f-443e-9b75-25145bc61f73 Getty Images

    You can watch the video of the ‘premeditated’ act inside. Six months is fairly understandable, no?

  3. Euro 2020 semis, final to be played at Wembley Stadium

    Sep 19, 2014, 7:48 AM EDT

    Montenegro players Jovetic and Pavicevic train ahead of their 2014 World Cup qualifying soccer match against England, at Wembley Stadium in west London Reuters

    The required capacity for the final was a minimum of 70,000 seats, which certainly helped England near the front of the pack.

  4. Mic check: Clint Dempsey takes the stage at FIFA15 event

    Sep 19, 2014, 12:06 AM EDT

    Screen Shot 2014-09-18 at 9.00.37 PM

    Win U.S. Open Cup on Tuesday. Drop a few bars in New York on Thursday. You know: #JustClintDempseyThings.

  5. CCL: Two goals from Toni push Sporting Kansas City past Saprissa

    Sep 18, 2014, 11:32 PM EDT

    Sporting Kansas City logo

    Sporting took a big step toward getting out of Group 2 thanks to its Spanish winger.

  6. Sloppy USWNT 4-0 win over Mexico adds fuel to turf conversation fire

    Sep 18, 2014, 10:50 PM EDT

    photo (1)

    Awkward bounces made a disorganized El Tri look awful and the high-powered USWNT look pedestrian in a 4-0 decision on Thursday night.

  7. MLS’s new logo: Reddit (yes, Reddit) may have a way to solve the league’s new problem

    Sep 18, 2014, 9:22 PM EDT

    MLS_crest_club_colors

    Users decided to make the new art’s white space into a plus, ditching the high brow concept in favor of more appealing products.

  8. MLS Preview: Real Salt Lake vs. Colorado Rapids

    Sep 18, 2014, 8:20 PM EDT

    Portland Timbers v Real Salt Lake Getty Images

    NBCSN’s first of three weekend broadcasts takes place tomorrow night at Rio Tinto Stadium.

  9. FA chairman: England “might well bid for” Euro 2028

    Sep 18, 2014, 7:41 PM EDT

    greg_dyke Getty Images

    It’s 14 years off, but The FA is still planning to make a push.

  10. Europe League roundup: Everton big winners at home; Spurs left with draw on the road

    Sep 18, 2014, 6:15 PM EDT

    seamus_coleman AP

    Roberto Martinez makes an impressive European debut, while Mauricio Pochettino sees him team go without a shot on target.

  11. It’s not too late for Major League Soccer to turn away from its new logo

    Sep 18, 2014, 4:25 PM EDT

    don_garber_mls_logo AP

    MLS has admitted failure before. Today’s new art may prove to be another idea the league should cast off.

  12. Premier League Power Rankings: Red Devils and Villans on the up

    Sep 18, 2014, 3:09 PM EDT

    Manchester United v Queens Park Rangers - Premier League Getty Images

    With Week four in the books, here’s how the PL teams stack up in our rankings of power.

  13. Reactions to “MLS Next” as North America’s top-flight launches rebrand

    Sep 18, 2014, 2:27 PM EDT

    MLS_crest_club_colors

    What are people saying about Major League Soccer’s new look?

  14. Arsene Wenger’s biggest regret is missing out on Cristiano Ronaldo

    Sep 18, 2014, 1:45 PM EDT

    Everton v Arsenal - Premier League Getty Images

    Wenger: “I was so close to signing Cristiano Ronaldo.”

  15. Auf Wiedersehen! Felix Magath out as Fulham boss after terrible tenure

    Sep 18, 2014, 1:09 PM EDT

    STOKE ON TRENT, ENGLAND - MAY 03: Fulham manager Felix Magath reacts as his side are relegated following their defeat in the Barclays Premier League match between Stoke City and Fulham at the Britannia Stadium on May 3, 2014 in Stoke on Trent, England. Getty Images

    After just four wins from 20 games, Fulham’s owner has seen enough from Magath.

  16. Brendan Rodgers on Liverpool’s growing pains: “There’s no magic formula”

    Sep 18, 2014, 12:37 PM EDT

    There's nothing nice about watching your side squander a three goal lead to end up with a draw. Getty Images

    Rodgers’ side have had an up and down start to the season. Is it the sign of things to come?

  17. Europa League preview: Will Everton, Tottenham reach knockout stages?

    Sep 18, 2014, 11:33 AM EDT

    tim_howard Getty Images

    Here’s what lies in store for Everton and Tottenham as Thursday night soccer begins.

  18. Taking back time: FIFA says officials must return expensive watches

    Sep 18, 2014, 11:00 AM EDT

    Brazil v Germany: Semi Final - 2014 FIFA World Cup Brazil Getty Images

    Parmigiani watches worth over $25,000 dished out by Brazilian federation to FIFA’s exec. members must be returned.

  19. Arsenal linked with three free agents, as defensive woes continue

    Sep 18, 2014, 10:18 AM EDT

    FC Lokomotiv Moscow v FC Zenit St. Petersburg - Premier League Getty Images

    Gunners need reinforcements in defense, so who are they making a move for?

  20. Ole Gunnar is gone: Solksjaer out as Cardiff City manager

    Sep 18, 2014, 9:35 AM EDT

    Blackburn Rovers v Cardiff City - Sky Bet Championship Getty Images

    Norwegian boss let go after just 9 wins in 30 games in charge of the Bluebirds.

Featured video

Breaking down Man City vs. Chelsea