Skip to content

Brek Shea is having a very, very bad week

Jul 19, 2012, 4:44 PM EDT

Real Salt Lake v FC Dallas Getty Images

You know what they say about spiraling times of misfortune like these: If it was raining $20 bills, Brek Shea would surely get conked on the head with a roll of old pennies.

The young U.S. international (at right, in a rare thumbs-up moment of 2012) needs a life timeout or something. He’s having a  very bad week month year.

Yesterday, a story in Dallas’ alternative weekly detailed a conversation that Shea says took place in 2010 between MLS commissioner Don Garber and FC Dallas coach Schellas Hyndman. According to Shea, Garber called Hyndman to deliver a sort of ultimatum: either play the young man or move him elsewhere, via sell or trade.

My first reaction: that certainly doesn’t sound like Garber (nor any right-minded league official). That sounds more like a player’s interpretation of events, possibly (but not certainly) attached to a tangle of informal conversations between players, agents, coaches and power ties in league and team offices.

So I called MLS spokesman Dan Courtemanche, who relayed a message from commissioner Garber.

“Decisions about who plays are made by clubs and their technical staffs, not by the league office,” Courtemanche told me.

He didn’t want to address any specific this or that. Courtemanches didn’t say why, exactly, but I think I get it. Shea is having a crappy week – if I’m guessing, construction workers are busily working in the blazing Texas sun at this very minute, constructing a new wing in Hyndman’s dog house for the young left winger – and the league office didn’t want to pile on by making things worse on Shea.

Did I say “crappy week?” Maybe that’s underselling the point. Dallas’ young star is not performing well, he’s being asked to play out of position, he’s not scoring, he’s lost his mojo with the national team and that U.S. Olympic dream went kablooey, his battered MLS team is struggling mightily just to tread water and now the man seems to have gotten sideways with a no-nonsense coach.

Things could only be worse if someone kidnapped Shea’s dog.

So that’s why the league passed on addressing this specific situation. Besides, I get the feeling that I could have ticked off a long list of similar scenarios and I would have gotten the ditto answer: “The league office does not decide who plays,” Courtemanche reiterated. “Those decisions about who plays are made by the clubs’ technical staffs.”

Not long after that story came out Wednesday, national TV cameras saw a pouting Shea subbed out in Dallas’ loss to San Jose. He had what looked like a brief, terse sideline exchange with Hyndman. Here’s what FCD veteran midfielder Daniel Hernandez told ESPN’s Jeff Carlisle afterward:

Nobody likes to come out of a game. I don’t like to come out of a game. I’m pissed off when I come out of a game, or when I don’t play. But when things are not going well for you, or you’re not having a good game, and coach needs to make a change, you have to respect it. At this point in the season, we can’t have those breakdowns right now, because we need everybody. We need him. He’s one of the stars of our team, and we need him to step up with his leadership and his play. He’s obviously one of the best players in the country. In order for us to try to fight to get into the playoffs, we’re going to need him and everyone else, 100 percent.”

She wasn’t made available for comment (for which the team will probably be fined.) Hyndman declined to comment on his young star other than to say, “I think he is in enough hot water already.”

Sounds like Shea is in for a “talking-to.” From Hyndman and probably from team leaders, too.

So, yes, this is a bad time for Brek Shea. He’s young. He’ll bounce back.

But if we could offer a wee bit of advice: just keep your head down for a while, kid. Because those doggone rolls of old pennies can leave a mark!

Latest Posts
  1. Seattle overtakes Dallas in a starburst of offensive soccer

    May 19, 2013, 12:48 AM EDT

    Eddie Johnson 2

    The Sounders exploit Dallas’ young back line in a meeting of two Western Conference teams in top form. Final score: 4-2 for the Sounders:

  2. Holy turnabout! Now Houston cannot seem to win at home

    May 18, 2013, 11:41 PM EDT

    New England Revolution v Sporting Kansas City Getty Images

    Juan Agudelo makes his New England debut as Jay Heaps posts one of the best wins of his young coaching career:

  3. Jack McInerney nails yet another game-winner for Philly

    May 18, 2013, 10:33 PM EDT

    mcinerney head shot

    Highlights and context as “Jack Mac” scores his league-leading 8th goal:

  4. Talking points on Portland’s 2-2 draw with Vancouver

    May 18, 2013, 9:50 PM EDT

    Will Johnson-Timbers 2

    Cascadia Cup matches are always interesting, and Saturday’s 2-2 draw at BC Place was full of talking points:

  5. VIDEO: Camilo’s wonderful free kick goal for Vancouver

    May 18, 2013, 8:24 PM EDT

    Camilo

    it was a big crowd pleaser on two fronts when the Whitecaps’ forward stroked an unstoppable free kick against Portland:

  6. A real injury concern for Portland as Darlington Nagbe falls

    May 18, 2013, 8:05 PM EDT

    Nagbe

    The young Timbers’ attacker is having an outstanding season for the Jeld-Wen Field bunch:

  7. Federico Higuain steals the show for Columbus in a road win over Toronto

    May 18, 2013, 7:38 PM EDT

    higuain-4

    Higuain created the game’s only goal and was masterful in possession at BMO Field:

  8. PSG president confirms Saturday was likely David Beckham’s farewell match

    May 18, 2013, 6:44 PM EDT

    REUTERS PICTURE HIGHLIGHT Reuters

    An appearance next week in Paris Saint-Germain’s final match 2012-13 season doesn’t seem to be in the plans for the retiring superstar:

  9. Did David Beckham just play his farewell match?

    May 18, 2013, 5:32 PM EDT

    FBL-FRA-LIGUE1-PSG-BREST

    Video: Reports out of England say today was the former England captain’s final match, rather than next week as expected:

  10. As Alex Ferguson says goodbye, Manchester United’s cupboard remains stocked

    May 18, 2013, 3:15 PM EDT

    Manchester United's Kagawa celebrates his goal against Fulham during their English Premier League soccer match in Manchester Reuters

    Depth at United will allow David Moyes to hut big game this offseason.

  11. Wherein MLS expansion becomes the new David Beckham transfer rumor

    May 18, 2013, 2:40 PM EDT

    David Beckham, Don Garber

    David Beckham’s not dropping off your radar anytime soon.

  12. French soccer trying to deal with the coming AS Monaco problem

    May 18, 2013, 2:01 PM EDT

    1198px-Monaco_in_Europe_(-rivers_-mini_map)

    Before Monaco takes on Europe, they have to convince French soccer.

  13. Roberto Mancini takes out full page thank you ad in Manchester Evening News

    May 18, 2013, 1:17 PM EDT

    mancini-ad-3870078

    Manchester City’s former boss reaches out to his supportive fan base – his first public comments since his Monday dismissal.

  14. Bayern Munich finish German season 25 points ahead of Borussia Dortmund

    May 18, 2013, 12:28 PM EDT

    FBL-GER-BUNDESLIGA-MOENCHENGLADBACH-BAYERN-MUNICH Getty Images

    Mercifully, the season’s come to an end for the 17 clubs who tried to keep pace with Bayern Munich.

  15. Ferguson, on Mancini’s Manchester City dismissal: ‘It is quite amazing’

    May 18, 2013, 11:40 AM EDT

    A combination of file pictures created o

    Manchester United’s outgoing boss was amazed but not surprised at his rival’s dismissal.

  16. England’s top four: Games that matter in the English Premier League’s last round

    May 18, 2013, 10:22 AM EDT

    Barclays-Premier-League1

    Relegation’s decided. So’s the title and two of the league’s Europa League spots. All that’s left? The battle for top four.

  17. Radamal Falcao and the specter of AS Monaco

    May 18, 2013, 9:16 AM EDT

    Radamel Falcao AP

    Russian oligarchs, third-party ownership, tax havens, and €60 million moves. This one has everything.

  18. Jamie Carragher set to close out his 16-year career at Anfield

    May 18, 2013, 8:11 AM EDT

    Jamie Carragher AP

    One of the Premier League’s one-club men says goodbye at Anfield.

  19. More goofball MLS scheduling this weekend

    May 17, 2013, 7:32 PM EDT

    MLS logo

    Wait a doggone minute! Didn’t Philadelphia and Chicago just play?

  20. David Beckham and PSG prep for final two stops

    May 17, 2013, 6:45 PM EDT

    Paris Saint-Germain FC v Olympique de Marseille - Ligue 1 Getty Images

    Brest and FC Lorient will be the opposition for retiring midfielder’s final two pro matches:

Top 10 Player Searches
  1. C. Woodson (NFL)
  2. B. Harper (MLB)
  3. T. Young (NFL)
  4. D. Rose (NBA)
  5. D. Wade (NBA)