Skip to content

MLS All-Star format works, but still requires some tweaking

Jul 23, 2012, 4:17 PM EDT

MLS All-Star 2012 logo

PHILADELPHIA – What’s worse than a 5-2 beat-down, like the one Major League Soccer’s overmatched All-Stars took two years ago?

A 4-0 beat-down, like the one Major League Soccer’s overmatched All-Stars took last year.

So here we area again, and the level of competition is not a bit diminished, even if the jersey color has morphed this year from Manchester United red to Chelsea blue.

The MLS All-Star game serves its purpose of attracting a short burst of attention from fans, networks, sponsors, advertisers, etc.  It’s like one of those big banners pulled along by a single-engine plane: it creates awareness among set of people who might not otherwise notice, who see it and consider it, if only briefly, while it flashes across the sky.

And I do love the format. In a wasteland of pointless all-star gray screens – baseball is the exception, whereas the rest are mostly empty calorie events for the sake of having an event – Major League Soccer’s unique format does manage to add a splash of color.

But one thing surely needs tweaking: either the level of competition needs re-assessing, or the methodology for MLS All-Star selection needs revision.

On the one hand, nobody who understands these things believes a collection of players with two brief practices – even a selection of abundant talent – can compete with the moneyed likes of Manchester United or Chelsea. Or with Real Madrid, Barcelona, Bayern Munich or any other teams that have danced on the edge of MLS deciders’ dreams, some closer to fruition than others.

Those are real teams in the truest sense, assembled with an eye to roster balance, chemistry and placement of round pegs into round holes in terms of personnel that fit a manager’s idea of how the game is played. Plus, these are “All-Star” teams, too; most of Chelsea’s men are internationals who would take a DP tag here.

Meanwhile, the MLS All-Stars are a hodgepodge of mostly worthy talent assembled through the flawed vagaries of traditional all-star selection processes. Fan input is always part of this, and it probably should be – but let’s don’t pretend it will ever represent a best 11 or best 18. Nor that it will ever deliver the All-Stars their maximum competitive chance.

source: Getty Images

Which means this: the opportunity will always exist for Major League’s Soccer’s best and brightest to get clobbered – this year to be figuratively whacked and then dumped right into the Delaware River outside PPL Park (pictured, right).

Which wouldn’t be a big deal except for this: every time it happens, it validates the soccer snobs who don’t see MLS as worthy. And that’s an issue.

It shouldn’t be, but it is. There should be room for fans to love their La Liga, Serie A, Mexican league, English Premier League, etc., and still have a place in their soccer hearts for their local MLS outfit.  But plenty don’t, for whatever reason – and quality or the perception of un-worthiness becomes a convenient excuse.

As one MLS executive told me here in Philadelphia: “Every time we get beat badly in one of these games, the very fan we need to go get says, ‘See there. That’s why I don’t watch MLS.’ And it kills us.”

Major League Soccer needs those fans. It may not always be that way, but in 2012 it is.

Latest Posts
  1. Sporting K.C. makes it clear after blown call – “I scored the goal”

    May 19, 2013, 10:00 PM EDT

    Sporting Kansas City v Montreal Impact Getty Images

    Sporting K.C. manager Peter Vermes and defender Ike Opera didn’t appreciate the pivotal offsides call that disallowed a possible winning goal against D.C. United, and they made that very obvious.

  2. Premier League managerial pair blast squad and referee following final match

    May 19, 2013, 8:58 PM EDT

    FBL-ENG-PR-TOTTENHAM-SUNDERLAND Getty Images

    Paolo Di Canio and Andre Villas-Boas took to the media following their teams’ Premier League finale to voice displeasure with how their final fixture played out.

  3. D.C. United rue own goal but end losing streak against Sporting KC

    May 19, 2013, 7:51 PM EDT

    kyleporter_1993-430x298 Getty Images

    A dull, scoreless first half picked up in the second term as D.C. United grabbed a point against the league’s second-best team and ended their club-record losing streak at 7 matches.

  4. Carlo Ancelotti denied release from PSG as he looks to Real Madrid job

    May 19, 2013, 5:50 PM EDT

    Paris Saint-Germain's coach Ancelotti reacts during his team's French Ligue 1 soccer match against Brest at the Parc des Princes stadium in Paris Reuters

    With his eye on the imminent vacancy at Real Madrid left by Jose Mourinho’s almost certain departure, Paris Saint-Germain’s mastermind Carlo Ancelotti may now have a large hurdle to get past if he is to land his ideal job in Spain’s capital.

  5. Fernando Torres scores first Premier League goal in 2013 as Chelsea secures third place

    May 19, 2013, 5:34 PM EDT

    Britain Soccer Premier League

    Fernando Torres broke his Premier League scoring drought by banging home the game-winner to secure Chelsea a third place finish.

  6. AC Milan steal final Champions League spot with late goal

    May 19, 2013, 5:22 PM EDT

    AC Siena v AC Milan - Serie A Getty Images

    Heartbreak in Serie A this year belongs to Fiorentina. Mario Balotelli converted a penalty in the 84th minute to draw level and two minutes later Philippe Mexes slotted home a cross to secure Europe’s top competition for AC Milan.

  7. VIDEOS: A brief history of recent “Olimpico” goals in MLS

    May 19, 2013, 5:01 PM EDT

    Michael Gspurning

    Rare as they are, we’ve seen more than our share of “Olimpico” goals in MLS over the last pair of seasons, including one last night:

  8. Despite little to play for, Premier League final day provides prize money shifts

    May 19, 2013, 4:47 PM EDT

    Swansea City's Nathan Dyer is challenged by Fulham's Dimitar Berbatov  (R) during their English Premier League soccer match at the Liberty Stadium in Swansea Reuters

    With Arsenal and Tottenham the only teams battling for any meaningful positioning in the Premier League table, the final day still had implications for many teams in the form of placement prize money.

  9. Sir Alex Ferguson era ends with wacky draw

    May 19, 2013, 4:28 PM EDT

    FBL-ENG-PR-WEST BROM-MAN UTD Getty Images

    Sir Alex Ferguson managed the final match of his career away from Old Trafford, and it looked set to complete on a high note, until the opposition had other ideas late.

  10. (Video) Gareth Bale’s wonder strike not enough for Tottenham to capture Champions League dreams

    May 19, 2013, 4:25 PM EDT

    FBL-ENG-PR-TOTTENHAM-SUNDERLAND

    Another game-winning strike from Gareth Bale wasn’t enough to save Tottenham from more Champions League heartache.

  11. Three points to make on a huge goal at Red Bull Arena

    May 19, 2013, 3:50 PM EDT

    JW Marriott Essex House New York Grand Opening Getty Images

    New York took all the points from the L.A. Galaxy on Tim Cahill’s late goal. So let’s talk about that goal.

  12. Where Landon Donovan’s afternoon takes us in the ongoing U.S. national team debate

    May 19, 2013, 3:17 PM EDT

    Landon Donovan

    This Landon Donovan debate regarding his place on the national team is not going anywhere. So, did Sunday’s performance move the needle either way?

  13. Arsenal grabs Champions League spot with victory over Newcastle

    May 19, 2013, 2:42 PM EDT

    FBL-ENG-PR-NEWCASTLE-ARSENAL

    Arsenal secured its 16th consecutive spot on the Champions League with a hard-fought 1-0 win over Newcastle at St. James’ Park on Sunday.

  14. Danny Koevermans gets into Toronto reserve match

    May 19, 2013, 1:43 PM EDT

    Toronto FC's Danny Koevermans reacts after missing an open net in the first half of their MLS soccer game against the New York Red Bulls in Toronto

    Sensational news for fans around BMO Field:

  15. Story-lines: What to watch for on the final day of the Premier League

    May 19, 2013, 11:30 AM EDT

    Stoke City v Tottenham Hotspur - Premier League Getty Images

    With David Beckham-esque tears streaming down my cheeks, we’re finally here: The final day of the 2012-13 Barclay’s Premier League.

  16. All eyes on Newcastle v. Arsenal for final Champions League spot

    May 19, 2013, 10:19 AM EDT

    Arsenal v Wigan Athletic - Premier League Getty Images

    Newcastle have nothing to play for and have been a disaster at home of late, losing their last two matches at St. James’ Park by a combined 9-0.

  17. Seattle awaiting word on Osvaldo Alonso’s injury

    May 19, 2013, 10:13 AM EDT

    alonso head shot

    The timing on this thing in two words: pretty bad:

  18. Philadelphia’s Jack McInerney would be league’s youngest Golden Boot winner

    May 19, 2013, 9:32 AM EDT

    Jack McInerney head shot

    Not to get too far ahead of ourselves on the 20-year-old goal-scoring sensation … :

  19. Seattle overtakes Dallas in a starburst of offensive soccer

    May 19, 2013, 12:48 AM EDT

    Eddie Johnson 2

    The Sounders exploit Dallas’ young back line in a meeting of two Western Conference teams in top form. Final score: 4-2 for the Sounders:

  20. Holy turnabout! Now Houston cannot seem to win at home

    May 18, 2013, 11:41 PM EDT

    New England Revolution v Sporting Kansas City Getty Images

    Juan Agudelo makes his New England debut as Jay Heaps posts one of the best wins of his young coaching career:

Top 10 Player Searches
  1. B. Beachy (MLB)
  2. T. Young (NFL)
  3. M. Goodson (NFL)
  4. T. Tebow (NFL)
  5. D. Rose (NBA)