Jul 30, 2012, 12:18 PM EDT
England’s Football Association is no moral authority, but their desire to be one has put them in a terrible situation, as illustrated by today’s charge against Rio Ferdinand.
The Manchester United defender is facing FA sanction for a Twitter comment that labels Chelsea defender Ashley Cole as “Choc Ice”. Ferdinand didn’t say it (another user did), but he signed off on it when asked to confirm the label (if you want a U.S.-equivalent of the term, think “oreo”).
Let’s for a moment put aside the allegation, charge, and facts of the incident. Let’s instead look at what the FA had created. England’s governing body is trying to control how English soccer is presented, admonishing players when their public statements place the game in a bad light. The intent is good, but it has the unfortunate side effect of making themselves into arbiters of what constitutes bad language.
John Terry’s alleged words were pretty clear cut. They were horrible. Luis Suarez’s, far less so, but the intent (and number of times he said it) was still there. Rio Ferdinand’s mistake has The FA interpreting pop culture slang. It’s far less cut and dry.
It’s also unclear Ferdinand is saying anything racist as much as it is uncomfortable. If “Choc Ice” is meant to be used like “oreo,” it’s not saying one race is this and another is that. It’s implying people of the same race should share allegiances. Cole siding with Terry over Anton Ferdinand in a racially-charged dispute means, on the inside, he’s more like Terry. It’s more tribal than racial. Tribalism’s nothing to be proud of, either, but it’s also not what The FA’s trying to police.
The most disturbing part of this is the FA unintentionally appropriating language from a minority group. The Football Association, in charging Ferdinand, are setting their own definition of “Choc Ice” and using its power to enforce it. They, as the enfranchised group, are taking the language of a minority – of somebody or a group that has less power in society – and saying how it can and can’t be used.
This is the dangerous situation. By trying to clean up speech, the FA have created a textbook scenario illustration of why we need a very liberal interpretation of free speech. Is all speech good? Of course not. But who can enforce the standards? Those in power can’t be allowed to move the goalposts on free speech as it serves their momentary wants, no matter the altruism behind those wants.
And the FA does seem to be trying to do the right thing here. They charged Suarez. They charged Terry. They have to charge Ferdinand, right? It’s only fair, and least in terms of perception.
I don’t think so. There is something very unsettling about the FA jumping into this one. The confluence of power, interpretation and the tweeter’s vague intent make this very murky water. And you won’t want murky water when an empowered group is trying to enforce new standards, especially where race is in play.
May 20, 2013, 9:45 PM EDT
Four players were on the original list. None of them may end up at Stamford Bridge.
May 20, 2013, 8:13 PM EDT
Our sympathy continues to grow for a man in a bad spot.
May 20, 2013, 7:21 PM EDT
MLS will not have arrived until it has a high-profile feces incident.
May 20, 2013, 6:40 PM EDT
It probably won’t happen this summer, and if it does … I’m sure we’ll run that into the ground, too.
May 20, 2013, 5:45 PM EDT
For a moment, it looked like Milan had fired their coaching staff … via an open letter from a television show.
May 20, 2013, 4:55 PM EDT
Real Madrid would have been in line for an eight-digit payday had they sold Mourinho to Chelsea.
May 20, 2013, 4:00 PM EDT
Odds on current U.S. Men’s National Team boss Jurgen Klinsmann to become Everton’s next permanent manager have dropped heavily today.
May 20, 2013, 3:45 PM EDT
Wherein we justify the selection of a center back, which always seems to be a requirement in these things:
May 20, 2013, 3:30 PM EDT
Sky Blue FC validates, Ali Krieger resonates, and four teams start to feel the toll of the new season.
May 20, 2013, 2:58 PM EDT
What’s been coming for a long time is now official. Jose Mourinho’s three-year tenure at Real Madrid has a finish line.
May 20, 2013, 2:39 PM EDT
Ben Olsen? Frank Klopas? … Someone else?
May 20, 2013, 1:47 PM EDT
The big, soon-to-be out of contract Galaxy center backs says talks with MLS commenced:
May 20, 2013, 12:35 PM EDT
That’s sarcasm. Ruiz was always bound to cause headaches, one way or the other:
May 20, 2013, 11:57 AM EDT
The first-year Red Bulls center back made a huge imprint on New York’s win over Los Angeles:
May 20, 2013, 11:32 AM EDT
There is still plenty of star appeal as the Europa League champs’ roster for a quick two-game tour of the United States:
May 20, 2013, 11:09 AM EDT
Kljestan becomes the fifth American to defend a title in a top league:
May 20, 2013, 10:18 AM EDT
The Scottish striker will hardly be missed around Vancouver:
May 19, 2013, 10:00 PM EDT
Sporting K.C. manager Peter Vermes and defender Ike Opera didn’t appreciate the pivotal offsides call that disallowed a possible winning goal against D.C. United, and they made that very obvious.
May 19, 2013, 8:58 PM EDT
Paolo Di Canio and Andre Villas-Boas took to the media following their teams’ Premier League finale to voice displeasure with how their final fixture played out.
May 19, 2013, 7:51 PM EDT
A dull, scoreless first half picked up in the second term as D.C. United grabbed a point against the league’s second-best team and ended their club-record losing streak at 7 matches.
- Looking back at Week 6 of the NWSL season 0
- Movement in the LA Galaxy-Omar Gonzalez situation 5
- Premier League managerial pair blast squad and referee following final match 0
- VIDEOS: A brief history of recent “Olimpico” goals in MLS 3
- Where Landon Donovan’s afternoon takes us in the ongoing U.S. national team debate 7
- Wings stun Hawks again, take 2-1 series lead
- Live Extra: Watch Blackhawks-Red Wings Game 3
- Posnanski: Once the best, Pujols now irrelevant
- PFT: Gronk's arm infection clear after surgery
- HBT: Dodgers have 'no plans' to fire Mattingly
- PBT: Brothers assaulted for taking Lillard's photo?
- PBT: Nets reportedly 'hone in' on Grizzlies' Hollins
- Play Video: Highlights: Union outlast Fire
- Play Video: Sir Alex says goodbye
- Play Video: Morgan committed to growth of new women's league
- Play Video: Boy with cancer, 8, scores against major league soccer team
- Play Video: Red Bulls pull off win on the road
- Play Video: Highlights: Montreal extinguish Chicago