Skip to content

Props to Everton, but Manchester United has some issues

Aug 20, 2012, 8:47 PM EDT

Everton v Manchester United - Premier League Getty Images

Before we start breaking down Manchester United, let’s give credit where it’s due. Everton were very good on Monday. Ever since (in the middle of last season) David Moyes shifted Marouane Fellaini into a supporting striker/attacking midfielder’s role, the Toffees have been one of the league’s better teams. That Monday’s performance fits firmly in that trend gives us reason to believe Everton will compete for a Europa League spot.

Other than Fellaini’s performance, the most encouraging sign for the Toffees may have actually been their bench. John Heitenga, Seamus Coleman, and Victor Anichebe provide valuable depth, whereas in previous seasons they were counted on to play bigger roles. Ross Barkley was being touted for a breakthrough last season. Now, Everton’s squad is strong enough to ensure his apprenticeship won’t be accelerated. Add in Steven Naismith, the former Rangers midfielder who made his debut on Monday, and the just-signed Kevin Mirallas and Moyes, used to entering seasons with a threadbare squads, has a relative embarrassment of riches.

Everton’s no longer in survival mode. They’re consolidating. Like Fulham (mentioned yesterday), they’ve probably been underestimated in the lead up to the season.

Still, Everton don’t have Manchester United’s talent. It’s not even close. After the offseason acquisitions of Shinji Kagawa and Robin van Persie (along with Nemanja Vidic and Tom Cleverley’s returns to health), the Red Devils have as much quality and depth as anybody in the world. Against a team of Everton’s resources, they should be expected to win, and while it’s far from a shock when they don’t, losing in Liverpool still raises eyebrows. Why was Manchester United shown out of Goodison without a point?

The obvious answer is Michael Carrick. He was beaten by Fellaini on the game’s only goal, the Everton target man leaping over the makeshift central defender on a second half corner. Carrick could have done better (he didn’t even get off the ground), but if you go into a match matching Michael Carrick against a team’s biggest threat on set pieces, you’ve got a bigger problem than that one-on-one matchup. You’ve given the other team an easy way to win the match.

Why was Carrick marking Fellaini? Why wasn’t Nemanja Vidic given the assignment? It was a obvious moment on non-genius from Alex Ferguson.

Another obvious problem: Wayne Rooney had a terrible night. Apparently Manchester United’s star is saving his first touch for the second week, because it completely abandoned him on Monday. He didn’t create any meaningful chances, be they for himself or others, a problem magnified by Ferguson putting Rooney in the middle of attack while pushing Danny Welbeck wide left (and leaving Robin van Persie on the bench for an hour). If Wayne Rooney’s going to continue to be the focal point of this team (which he will), he’s not only going to have to be better than he was on Monday, he’s going to have to be more consistent than he was last year, when nights like Monday’s were too frequent. While he was still one of the league’s best players, his inconsistency was one reason United failed to retain their title.

Then there’s the midfield. Oh, United’s midfield, the immense, rusted chink in the Devils’ armor, the weakness that keeps them from being considered one of the world’s best teams.

It’s more than a mere torn in their side. The void is a missing rib, an absence a titan’s too embarrassed to concede exists. Yet every time he extends his arm, reaches for some enticement he used to snare with ease, United winces and recoils, reaching with reflex from his one good side, hoping to soothe the weakness his ambition continues to expose.

For United to have such an inexplicable void while the world’s game continues to shift to more midfield dominant tactics calls into question every proclamation of genius Alex Ferguson’s ever received. To try to buck the trend is one thing, but to continue bucking in the face of diminished results is stubbornness. How can a genius continue to ignore the obvious?

On Monday, one United midfielder was rendered irrelevant by the other. Despite superficially spectacular numbers, Tom Cleverley had one of his least influential games in red, the 23-year-old clearly not used to playing beside Paul Scholes. At the beginning of last season, when Cleverley broke into United’s senior team, Scholes was retired. When Scholes returned mid-season, Cleverley was injured.

The two have never meaningful played with each other, and their first chance to do so hinted they may be too similar, Cleverley left uncertain what to do as Scholes’ movements mirrored his intent (while Kagawa dropped back into the space he’s otherwise occupy). The attack constantly deferred to the veteran Scholes, with Cleverley’s creativity left to survive on crumbs. Without consistent contributions from both midfielders, United were never able to convert their large possession advantage into meaningful threats.

Not surprisingly, the numbers tell a different story. That’s what happens when one team’s allowed to dominate the ball to the extent United did on Monday (Everton were out-passed 276 to 646). Cleverley completed 85 passes at a 92 percent clip, but his distribution failed to generate a chance. Rooney had two of United’s four shots on goal but none after the 27th minute.

Latest Posts
  1. USA Today reports LA Galaxy trade Mike Magee for rights to Robbie Rogers

    May 24, 2013, 9:29 PM EDT

    021513-USA-Robbie-Rogers-PI_20130215160452343_660_320

    In a mind-blowing move, USA Today have reported the LA Galaxy have sent a player to the Chicago Fire in exchange for the rights to Robbie Rogers.

  2. If Bayern triumph in Champions League, could we have a dynasty on our hands?

    May 24, 2013, 7:00 PM EDT

    A statue of former England player Bobby Moore stands outside Wembley Stadium before the training sessions of Bayern Munich and Borussia Dortmund ahead of their Champions League Final soccer match in London Reuters

    With a victory in the Champions League final to complete Bayern Munich’s domination domestically and abroad plus their offseason acquisitions, would they be a force for years to come?

  3. With Corey Ashe now added, what the U.S. fullback depth chart looks like for this camp

    May 24, 2013, 5:32 PM EDT

    Jamaica v United States - World Cup Qualifer Getty Images

    Ashe’s late addition to Jurgen Klinsmann’s roster for the U.S. camp forms a more complete picture of what the depth chart looks like at right and left back:

  4. Inter officially announced managerial change

    May 24, 2013, 4:25 PM EDT

    FBL-ITA-SERIEA-NAPOLI-SIENA Getty Images

    Internazionale officially announced they have sacked Andrea Stramaccioni and hired the former Napoli boss.

  5. MLS Preview: Philadelphia Union at Montreal Impact

    May 24, 2013, 4:05 PM EDT

    Montreal Impact's Martins celebrates a goal by Arnaud during the second half of their MLS soccer match against Chicago Fire in Montreal

    No question that two of the league’s most interesting teams will be at Stade Saputo on Saturday:

  6. Tony Fernandes finally admits he screwed up with QPR

    May 24, 2013, 3:37 PM EDT

    _65535458_hi017044631 AP

    Tony Fernandes has finally taken some blame for the relegation of QPR instead of shedding it left and right.

  7. Rafa Benitez to manage Napoli on a 2-year deal

    May 24, 2013, 3:15 PM EDT

    FBL-ENG-PR-CHELSEA-EVERTON Getty Images

    Napoli president Aurelio De Laurentiis has confirmed Chelsea interm manager Rafa Benitez is set to move to Serie A on a 2-year deal with Napoli.

  8. USMNT forward Terrence Boyd on ex-club Borussia Dortmund’s UCL charge

    May 24, 2013, 3:00 PM EDT

    Borussia Dortmund II v Borussia Moenchengladbach II - Regionalliga West Getty Images

    Boyd left Dortmund last season, so is a USMNT player destined to never play in a Champions League final?

  9. Sporting KC goalkeeper Jimmy Nielsen’s new book reveals past life as gambling addict

    May 24, 2013, 2:50 PM EDT

    Nielsen book

    Who knew that Jimmy Nielsen’s burst of white hair wasn’t the craziest thing about Sporting Kansas City’s talented goalkeeper?

  10. Further MLS attachment to the English Premier League is a good thing … right?

    May 24, 2013, 2:45 PM EDT

    Chelsea Manchester City Soccer

    A blog post in the New Yorker looks at another side to this week’s huge expansion news:

  11. Stoke City look to Mark Hughes as new manager?

    May 24, 2013, 2:31 PM EDT

    Mark Hughes

    Does Hughes deserve another shot at managing an EPL club after past failures?

  12. MLS Preview: Portland Timbers at D.C. United

    May 24, 2013, 2:25 PM EDT

    New York Red Bulls v DC United Getty Images

    Both teams are on streaks of success – even if “success” look so radically different in the two camps:

  13. German invasion of London begins as fans of Munich, Dortmund descend on Wembley

    May 24, 2013, 1:56 PM EDT

    Britain Soccer Champions League Final AP

    See the sights around London, as Wembley Stadium welcomes German fans in abundance.

  14. Champions League final preview: A bitter rivalry with much higher stakes

    May 24, 2013, 1:30 PM EDT

    Souvenir Champions League final scarves are seen on sale at a stall near Trafalgar Square in central London Reuters

    When Bayern Munich face Borussia Dortmund tomorrow at 2:45 ET at Wembley, they won’t be playing for the right to be recognized as permanent contenders. They’ve already done that.

  15. Are AS Monaco the real deal after signing Joao Moutinho and James Rodriguez?

    May 24, 2013, 1:13 PM EDT

    Porto's Moutinho and team mate Rodriguez hold the trophy while they celebrate winning the Portuguese Premier League title after their soccer match against Pacos Ferreira at the Mata Real stadium in Pacos de Ferreira Reuters

    Monaco’s Russian oligarch owner is splashing the cash to bring Champions League success, can they do it?

  16. With MLS expansion done for now, where the league priorities should land

    May 24, 2013, 1:00 PM EDT

    RFK

    We have five suggestions as MLS pivots its enhancement efforts away from expansion:

  17. Minnows Gibraltar officially join UEFA… but why are Spain mad?

    May 24, 2013, 12:32 PM EDT

    Britain's Prince Edward and his wife Sophie Rhys-Jones wave before boarding their plane to leave the airport in front of the Rock in Gibraltar Reuters

    Looking behind the incredible story of the tiny rock in the Mediterranean, that can now take on the giants of European soccer

  18. Champions League Final: Key battles for Borussia Dortmund vs. Bayern Munich

    May 24, 2013, 11:38 AM EDT

    Germany Soccer Bundesliga

    Which individual battles will determine which side lifts the UEFA Champions League trophy at Wembley on Saturday?

  19. Which US cities are next for MLS expansion?

    May 24, 2013, 11:04 AM EDT

    Courtesy of MySanAntonio.com Courtesy of MySanAntonio.com

    We take a look at which US cities deserve an MLS expansion franchise and how close they are to getting it. Thoughts?

  20. Three MLS sides chasing Carlton Cole?

    May 24, 2013, 10:07 AM EDT

    FBL-ENG-PR-WEST HAM-EVERTON Getty Images

    Would Cole be a good pickup for Major League Soccer sides looking to cement their playoff aspirations?

Top 10 Player Searches