Skip to content

Wherein we consider the Jozy Altidore-Eddie Johnson “swap”

Nov 13, 2012, 10:08 AM EST

MLS All-Stars Eddie Johnson celebrates h

The interesting thing about Jozy Altidore’s re-introduction into Jurgen Klinsmann’s national team is the fluid circumstance in this restoration of good-favor.

Specifically, we can all rightly wonder about this: would Altidore even be in the U.S. manager’s current crop had the MLS playoffs gone a little differently?

When Seattle eliminated Real Salt Lake on Thursday, Sounders striker Eddie Johnson (pictured) was off the board for selection. He may have been anyway, based on a recent injury and his iffy status for the club’s second-leg playoff against RSL. Either way, the Sounders’ victory meant Johnson would certainly not be an option for selection.

Previously, when Johnson was selected in October for the USMNT’s final two semifinal round World Cup qualifiers, it looked like a this-for-that swap: Johnson was in, Altidore was out.

Yes, Altidore was scoring by the relative bundles in Holland’s Eredivisie. But Johnson was scoring by the relative bundles in Major League Soccer. It may not have been a 100 percent wash – the top Dutch league is held in higher regard than MLS, especially at a technical level – but given the scrappy nature of the qualifiers afoot, which more closely resemble scrappy MLS matches, we could call it “wash-ish.”

At any rate, these things will always be fluid choices. That’s why one roster should never a narrative make. Klinsmann knows so … and Altidore, too, apparently.

(MORE: Altidore kept his cool after the recent omission)

There will always be some forward hurt, or some forward out of form. Or maybe a midfielder’s form or availability is slipping, and Klinsmann goes with one additional striker and one fewer linking men. So, this roster is never necessarily a portend for that one.

Johnson, by the way, is a streaky striker, too. His form tends to rise and fall, but does so over months and years rather than over mere weeks, as we might see with others.

Here’s what Klinsmann had to say specifically about Altidore’s re-introduction into national team good-favor:

“We are happy having Jozy back in the group. Obviously, he was left out of the last games against Antigua & Barbuda and Guatemala because of the way he played in Jamaica and maybe a couple other things from the previous months that I wasn’t so happy about. I mentioned it to him, and now having him back in the group gives us an opportunity to talk through that stuff and also to see his total commitment on the field. He’s an important player for us. He’s fighting his way through the Dutch league and doing well there, and we hope he brings the same energy into our group.

We often forget that Jozy is not a 30-year-old player that you already expect to be kind of perfect and mature. He’s still going through ups and downs, which is totally normal. So when a down period comes and I leave him out of the roster, that’s not the end of the world. But it’s also a little signal to say ‘Hey Jozy, maybe there were things we didn’t like before.’ Now we can catch up and see how it goes.”

Latest Posts
  1. Report: Dani Osvaldo elects for Juventus return, making early Giovinvo exit possible

    Jan 29, 2015, 10:30 PM EST

    Dani Osvaldo, Inter Milan Dani Osvaldo, Inter Milan

    Osvaldo-to-Juventus could mean Giovinco-to-Toronto happens six months early.

  2. David Beckham says progress still being made toward MLS stadium in Miami

    Jan 29, 2015, 9:30 PM EST

    David Beckham David Beckham

    The latest update from Beckham on building a stadium, bringing an MLS team to Miami.

  3. DONE DEAL: Mattia Destro, Juan Agudelo sign with new clubs AC Milan, New England Revolution

    Jan 29, 2015, 7:10 PM EST

    Mattia Destro, AS Roma Mattia Destro, AS Roma

    What went down on Thursday, the 29th day of this January transfer window? A full recap, inside.

  4. Juan Agudelo signs with New England Revolution, completes return to MLS

    Jan 29, 2015, 5:36 PM EST

    Juan Agudelo, FC Utrecht Juan Agudelo, FC Utrecht

    Agudelo is back in MLS, where he probably should have been all along.

  5. Russia to cut budget for 2018 World Cup, as economy continues to struggle

    Jan 29, 2015, 3:18 PM EST

    FIFA FIFA

    Putin and Russia have already had to cut costs for the 2018 World Cup.

  6. Alexis Sanchez an injury concern for Arsenal

    Jan 29, 2015, 2:43 PM EST

    Arsenal v Southampton - Premier League

    Arsenal’s main man is touch and go for this weekend’s game against Aston Villa.

  7. Daniel Sturridge could return from injury for Liverpool this weekend against West Ham

    Jan 29, 2015, 2:00 PM EST

    Liverpool FC Training Session Liverpool FC Training Session

    Liverpool’s leading striker could return to action this Saturday after five months out.

  8. How will Chelsea, Manchester City line up in huge Premier League clash?

    Jan 29, 2015, 1:02 PM EST

    Manchester City v Chelsea - Premier League Getty Images

    With players out and title dreams on the line, how will Chelsea and City line up on Saturday?

  9. VIDEO: Jurgen Klinsmann’s a stud, backheels TWO balls at the same time

    Jan 29, 2015, 11:43 AM EST

    jurgen_klinsmann Getty Images

    Watch Klinsmann’s insane piece of skill from the friendly vs. Chile on Wednesday. My word.

  10. Lots drawn: Guinea in, Mali out as Africa Cup of Nations quarterfinals set

    Jan 29, 2015, 11:08 AM EST

    FBL-AFR-2015-MATCH24-GUI-MLI FBL-AFR-2015-MATCH24-GUI-MLI

    Guinea won the lottery and are through to the last eight. Here’s the quarterfinal field for AFCON.

  11. Freddy Adu heading back to MLS? Reports claim two teams interested

    Jan 29, 2015, 9:45 AM EST

    Fredy Adu made his first start for Bahia in Brazil. Getty Images

    Former D.C. United, RSL and Union player heading back home?

  12. DONE DEAL: Arsenal, West Brom and Villarreal all got new players Wednesday

    Jan 28, 2015, 11:10 PM EST

    arsenal.com arsenal.com

    So what went down on Wednesday, as the transfer window took another step toward slamming shut?

  13. VIDEO: Christian Eriksen scores a free kick for the ages in League Cup semi

    Jan 28, 2015, 10:20 PM EST

    Sheffield United v Tottenham Hotspur - Capital One Cup Semi-Final: Second Leg Getty Images

    Set up for a free kick outside the 18, Eriksen not only sent an arrow whizzing over the goal, but he managed to spin it into the far upper 90.

  14. Real Madrid will change the name of the Santiago Bernabeu

    Jan 28, 2015, 9:58 PM EST

    Bernabeu Getty Images

    The La Liga giant has woked out a sponsorship deal with United Arab Emirates-based International Petroleum Investment Company (IPIC).

  15. USMNT postgame reaction: Jozy unsure of 3-5-2, Klinsmann explains changes

    Jan 28, 2015, 9:17 PM EST

    Klinsmann AP

    Jurgen Klinsmann remained upbeat, while Jozy Altidore was obviously disappointed.

Featured video

Top five Premier League goals: Week 22