Skip to content

MLS Cup referee assignment announced; why it’s bad news

Nov 20, 2012, 6:44 PM EST

Petrescu

Unfortunate news for MLS Cup – and for our best chances to see an attractive match on Dec. 1 at the Home Depot Center: Silviu Petrescu has been assigned officiate the MLS Cup final: Here’s why that checks the box under “bad news” in my book:

Petrescu is probably the worst in MLS when it comes to lenient enforcement of the laws, therefore tacitly endorsing overly aggressive and physical play. He prefers to not call fouls, so games under his watch tend to get extra physical. (Probably good news for Dynamo fans, although the Galaxy have smart players who understand when matches demand a more combative approach.)

I know that not calling fouls can sound like a decent enough idea, but it’s all about judicious application.

While it’s certainly true that a wise referee understands prudently employment of his advantage clause, that’s a long way from more or less deciding that only the most flagrant kicks, trips, hacks, elbows and body blows will actually draw a whistle. And that’s Petrescu.

(And never mind that Petruscu was just named MLS Referee of the Year; that’s more or less meaningless in my book, more akin to a politically weighted “industry” award than meaningful achievement. Just my opinion.)

So games overseen by Petrescu have a higher chance of devolving into orgies of turnovers, that kind that sometimes make MLS contests so hard on the eyes (and the kind the league is working so hard to tame this year – which is why Petrsescu’s appointment here is such a head-scratcher.)

When it comes to leniency, in the wrongheaded effort to “let a game flow,” the very opposite happens. I suppose it does “flow” if your idea of flow is a helter-skelter, unrelenting series of turnovers, abetted by a referee who green lights the doctrine of tackle by collision.

I know not everyone agrees, at least not officially. MLS Director of Communications Will Kuhns, someone I highly respect, pointed out to me via Twitter than Petrescu called 26.6 fouls per game this year, above the league average of 24.6.

But stats here are meaningless minus context. When referees call fouls early, players adjust to a match where they have to actually defend rather than simply hack and head hunt.  At that point, we tend to get what many of us like to call “soccer.”  On the other hand, when matches get physical, the high-speed foul-fest is on … and referees eventually have to call fouls. Thus, the stats tend to even out.

Plus, it’s not just the fouls. It’s the thuggish violations or cynical acts of obstruction that are whistled, but really should also be booked. And it’s bookings that really should be red cards.

In fairness, Petrescu is one of the better MLS referees in his tone of communication with the players. You do generally get the feeling that he’s in control out there when blood begins boiling (which is often does … because he doesn’t call fouls and things tend to escalate). On the other hand, what good is looking the part if you let players get away with something like this?

.

Latest Posts
  1. New England Revolution, 90 minutes from MLS Cup, must simply avoid second-leg disaster vs. Red Bulls

    Nov 27, 2014, 11:15 PM EST

    Steve Clark, Lee Nguyen, Charlie Davies Steve Clark, Lee Nguyen, Charlie Davies

    It’s been a long time since the New England Revolution lost by mulitple goals, which the New York Red Bulls must achieve to reach MLS Cup 2014.

  2. Europa League roundup: Spurs, Celtic advance; Inter Milan, Fiorentina clinch top spots

    Nov 27, 2014, 9:26 PM EST

    The big Europa League sides have begun to advance to the knockout round, with a few more very close to joining them.

  3. Everton win Europa League group, qualify for knockout round

    Nov 27, 2014, 4:09 PM EST

    Toffees seal spot in Europa League knockout rounds after terrific away day display.

  4. Five investigated, including three FIFA execs, in World Cup corruption probe

    Nov 27, 2014, 3:17 PM EST

    64th FIFA Congress 64th FIFA Congress

    Three FIFA ExCo members and German legend latest to be under the spotlight.

  5. Pele moved to “special care” unit as treatment continues

    Nov 27, 2014, 2:05 PM EST

    Edson Arantes do Nascimento, Pele AP

    Brazilian legend hospitalized for second time this month.

  6. English FA charge Dave Whelan after anti-Semitic, racist comments

    Nov 27, 2014, 1:15 PM EST

    Barnsley v Wigan Athletic - Sky Bet Championship Getty Images

    Whelan charged by FA over accusations of anti-Semitic, racist remarks.

  7. VIDEO: PST Extra examines huge top four showdowns in Premier League

    Nov 27, 2014, 10:55 AM EST

    Hull City v Tottenham Hotspur - Premier League Getty Images

    Can Spurs and Everton make a top four charge? Will Saints stun Man City?

  8. Huge blow for Arsenal as Jack Wilshere is out for three months

    Nov 27, 2014, 9:13 AM EST

    Wilshere AP

    Wilshere has surgery on left ankle, as young midfielder set for another lengthy spell on the sidelines.

  9. Bob Bradley talks Stabaek, job offers, offseason plans and more

    Nov 27, 2014, 8:51 AM EST

    Bradley, Stabaek

    Bradley opens up about his first season at Stabaek, his future in Europe and much more.

  10. USA drop five places in latest FIFA world rankings; England on the up

    Nov 27, 2014, 7:28 AM EST

    Ireland US Soccer AP

    Klinsmann’s men drop further in FIFA’s latest rankings.

  11. Arsene Wenger hails his team’s attitude, Sanogo and the path forward

    Nov 26, 2014, 10:30 PM EST

    FBL-EUR-C1-ARSENAL-ANDERLECHT-TRAINING Getty Images

    Wenger was in good spirits following his side’s victory that put an end to his two-match losing skid.

  12. Ross Barkley Divegate: Why Martinez defends him and what it means

    Nov 26, 2014, 9:50 PM EST

    Everton v West Ham United - Premier League Getty Images

    Yes, Barkley dove and yes, (news flash) Martinez is overly protective of his players.

  13. Cesc Fabregas claims he’s playing the best football of his life

    Nov 26, 2014, 8:32 PM EST

    Let's talk about Cesc... Getty Images

    “I feel that right now I am playing some of the best football of my career,” Fabregas said.

  14. Emile Heskey offers himself to Leicester City to help scoring woes

    Nov 26, 2014, 7:38 PM EST

    FBL-ENG-PR-DISCRIMINATION-HESKEY-SIN

    “It goes without saying, I’d love to come,” Heskey told BBC Radio Leicester.

  15. Franck Ribery lashes out at “politics” behind the Ballon d’Or

    Nov 26, 2014, 6:44 PM EST

    gareth_bale_franck_ribery AP

    Poor Franck. All fired up and not even on the 23-man shortlist.

  16. Despite their struggles, Liverpool’s season intact as spirit shines through

    Nov 26, 2014, 6:00 PM EST

    Can Liverpool build off this draw in Sofia? Their manager Brendan Rodgers has cause for optimism.

Featured video

PST Extra: Top 4 showdowns on Sunday