Skip to content

See any Major League Soccer Best XI snubs?

Nov 27, 2012, 8:21 AM EDT

AT&T MLS All Star Game - Chelsea v MLS All Stars Getty Images

Major League Soccer announced its Best XI for 2012 Monday afternoon. Hard to disagree with most of the list, as Richard Farley mentioned previously on the blog, but I do see one name perhaps conspicuous by his absence:

Jay DeMerit of the Vancouver Whitecaps:

Most Whitecaps matches I watched, the veteran, former U.S. international was somewhere between “composed and steady” and “just this side of heroic.” Considering the players around him (mostly in the good-but-not-great category), I thought DeMerit deserved a Best XI spot.

Who I would subtract from Monday’s official list? Sporting Kansas City did have a great defense, leading MLS in goals allowed with 27. But three men from the rear guard on the Best XI (two defenders and a goalkeeper)? There must be some mathematical formula that demonstrates how one Best XI reduces the need for others around them to be of Best XI quality. Hence: Aurélien Collin was not on my list.

Let’s put it this way: I know Collins is younger, but if I were starting an MLS team and offered one of these two, it’s a no-brainer. Consider the leadership and the volatility factor – DeMerit doesn’t have much of it, Collin is chock full of it – it’s no contest in my book.

(MORE: ProSoccerTalk’s Best XI selections)

Latest Posts
  1. Ugly scenes in Northern Ireland see Mexican U-19 player attempt to kick opponent’s head during Milk Cup brawl

    Jul 30, 2014, 7:29 PM EDT

    Screen Shot 2014-07-30 at 4.26.41 PM

    Game is eventually cut short after a yet unnamed player aimed at the head of a fallen opponent.

  2. Atlético Madrid latest club linked with Javier ‘Chicharito’ Hernández

    Jul 30, 2014, 6:46 PM EDT

    Chicharito Getty Images

    Atlético’s interest could develop into Chicharito’s best option.

  3. Nick De Santis no longer sporting director in Montréal

    Jul 30, 2014, 5:58 PM EDT

    500px-Montreal_Impact_(MLS)_logo

    Nick De Santis will stay with the Impact, albeit in an administrative role.

  4. Romelu Lukaku completes permanent, $47 million move to Everton

    Jul 30, 2014, 5:11 PM EDT

    MartinezLukaku Getty Images

    Everton’s leading scorer returns to Goodison on a permanent basis.

  5. NWSL implements cooling break procedure

    Jul 30, 2014, 4:01 PM EDT

    NWSL logo

    With immediate effect, U.S.’s women’s league will pause mid-half if when it’s too hot.

  6. VIDEO: Liverpool fan from New Jersey cries, loses the plot, after meeting Gerrard

    Jul 30, 2014, 3:12 PM EDT

    Liverpool fan

    Liverpool roll into town and people freak out! Watch this incredible reaction to Stevie G signing autographs.

  7. Report: US to play friendly vs. Colombia in San Antonio

    Jul 30, 2014, 2:46 PM EDT

    Brazil Soccer WCup Belgium US AP

    Reports from Texas state Jurgen Klinsmann’s side are playing Colombia in September.

  8. Philadelphia Union sign Algerian World Cup star Rais Mbolhi

    Jul 30, 2014, 2:10 PM EDT

    Germany v Algeria: Round of 16 - 2014 FIFA World Cup Brazil Getty Images

    Union grab Algerian goalkeeper Mbolhi, throw MacMath’s future in doubt.

  9. FIFA’s senior vice-president Julio Grondona dies, Argentina mourns

    Jul 30, 2014, 1:42 PM EDT

    FBL-WC2014-QUALIFIERS-ARG-VEN Getty Images

    One of the most influential men in world soccer passed away on Wednesday at the age of 82.

  10. Premier League will use vanishing spray for 2014-15 season

    Jul 30, 2014, 1:07 PM EDT

    Morocco Soccer Club World Cup AP

    After success at the 2014 World Cup, vanishing spray is coming to the PL.

  11. Manchester United’s Luke Shaw agrees he’s not fit enough after Louis van Gaal criticism

    Jul 30, 2014, 12:45 PM EDT

    Luke Shaw Andrea Ranocchia AP

    Shaw: “I didn’t come into United thinking it’s going to be much harder and that’s something I made a mistake on.”

  12. PHOTOS: Scantily clad Cristiano Ronaldo poses for record-breaking magazine cover

    Jul 30, 2014, 12:03 PM EDT

    ronaldo cover final

    Ronaldo flexing the abs as he is set to appear in the largest-ever Men’s Health front cover campaign.

  13. VIDEO: Manchester United dominate Inter, win on penalties in Washington D.C.

    Jul 30, 2014, 11:18 AM EDT

    International Champions Cup 2014 - Inter Milan v Manchester United Getty Images

    United make it three wins from three on their U.S. tour. Watch the highlights from Van Gaal’s men in action.

  14. Manchester United reach “verbal agreement” on $80 million Arturo Vidal deal

    Jul 30, 2014, 10:45 AM EDT

    Arturo Vidal AP

    Will United splash the cash to sign Vidal in central midfield?

  15. Transfer Rumor Roundup: Cuadrado to Manchester United, Lukaku to Everton

    Jul 30, 2014, 9:11 AM EDT

    Colombia v Uruguay: Round of 16 - 2014 FIFA World Cup Brazil Getty Images

    United to splash the cash? Lukaku on his way out of Chelsea? All the latest gossip, right here.

  16. Yaya Toure confirms he will stay at Manchester City

    Jul 30, 2014, 8:27 AM EDT

    Cardiff City v Manchester City - Premier League Getty Images

    Toure: “My decision is that I will stay at Manchester City for as long as possible.”

  17. Steven Gerrard endured “worst three months” of his life after Liverpool, England heartbreak

    Jul 30, 2014, 7:48 AM EDT

    Steven Gerrard believes Liverpool will prove themselves champions come next season. Getty Images

    After losing the PL title late in the season, then England being knocked out of the World Cup, can Gerrard bounce back?

  18. Edin Dzeko in talks with Manchester City over new contract

    Jul 29, 2014, 11:20 PM EDT

    Edin Dzeko

    “I can only say that I’m very happy at City and at the moment we are talking about a contract,” Dzeko said.

  19. San Lorenzo to use Viagra to counter elevation in Bolivar match

    Jul 29, 2014, 10:36 PM EDT

    San Lorenzo

    The 3,600 meters of elevation will provide a stiff challenge, with many opposing clubs having fallen victim to the altitude.