Skip to content

City vs. United: Premier League will be decided in Manchester, again

Dec 7, 2012, 6:40 PM EDT

Yaya Toure AP

When Manchester City pasted Manchester United 6-1 last October, it was still too early in the Premier League season to know if the campaign would become a two-team race. But after Chelsea’s winter swoon took them out of title contention, England’s most decorated team (United, 19 titles) was left to defend their title against a rival who had not won the first division since 1967-68.

This year there’s no illusion that the title will be settled outside Manchester. Second place City, defending their first Premier League title, remain undefeated and have a six-point lead on Chelsea and Tottenham. United, three points clear of their rivals at the top of the league, have already won three more matches than anybody else in the league. With the exception of Chelsea’s strong start, there’s been no indication anybody can keep up with the Manchester sides, and with the teams combining for 21 wins and six draws in 30 games, there’s little hint either club will come back to the pack.

MORE: Key man in Sunday’s Manchester Derby

Early Sunday morning, the teams wage their first of two league derbies this year (8:30 a.m. Eastern kickoff), a match that you could see as one of only two big, title-relevant matches of the Premier League season. Sure, history and locality mean matches like Arsenal-Tottenham and Liverpool-Manchester United will always be important, but if you discard folklore and narrow your focus to this Premier League season, the two Manchester derbies start to look disproportionately important. Like Spain’s Clasicos.

While it will take much longer than two years to establish the type of two-tier league Spain’s evolved into, this year’s developments in the Premier League combined with the 19-point gap the Manchesters put on the league last year is noteworthy. If you look at the underlying numbers, goals scored and goals against, the numbers are even more troubling. Last year City and United put up differences of +64 and +59. The next-best mark was Arsenal and Spurs’ +25. Last year, the Premier League was Spain.

If Chelsea can’t get their management issues worked out — if Arsenal and Liverpool don’t recover and if Tottenham can’t cease their window they’ve opened for themselves — we could see a small fissure form between the Manchesters and their competition. It will be small and less entrenched than chasms that exist in Spain and (to a lesser extent, now) Ukraine, but it will soon become something England’s other powers will have to overcome.

MORE: Chelsea finally comes good in Premier League

Within the derby, Manchester United, despite their lead in the standings, finds itself trying to make up ground. Their late-season collapse this spring allowed City to win the title at their expense. Though United has recent wins over City in the FA Cup and Community Shield, the Citizens won both the teams’ Premier League meetings last season and defeated the Red Devils when the clubs met in April 2011′s FA Cup semifinal. Recent big games — the ones both teams have really wanted to win — have gone to City.

source:  There are a number of reasons to think Sunday’s meeting will be different. This time, Manchester United have Robin van Persie, the former Arsenal-man quickly becoming the focal point of Manchester United’s attack. Any doubt that the Red Devils needed a player of van Persie’s potency has been assuaged by 13 goals in 19 all-competition appearances. Add his presence to the a United team who, after losing last year’s race to their noisy neighbors, have no confusion about where their focus should lie and a City side that has struggled to regain last year’s stride may have trouble replicating last year’s dominance.

There is another side to that coin, though. For all his production with Manchester United, van Persie has not scored in his last eight matches against Manchester City. And although Nemanja Vidic could return to Alex Ferguson’s back line, Manchester United’s defense (11th in the Premier League) is among the worst competing for a major European title. It’s rare that a team so flawed can compete for a crown like the Premier League’s, but with the firepower at Ferguson’s disposal, it’s not difficult to imagine a scenario where they can best City.

And within the current landscape of the Premier League, that’s may be all either Manchester club has to do: Beat their rival. Last year, Manchester City took all six league points. Had Manchester United drawn one of those two games, the Red Devils would have won a 20th title. And already three points up on City (nine points ahead of the rest of the league), a draw may be all United needs to take control of this year’s Premier League.

Latest Posts
  1. US women ‘focused’ as Wambach aims for history

    Jun 19, 2013, 11:05 PM EDT

    Abby Wambach - South Korea v United States Getty Images

    MONTCLAIR, N.J. – Thursday’s United States women’s national team match falls smack in the middle of the inaugural National Women’s Soccer League season. It’s a friendly. It’s against the same team, Korea Republic, that the United States just handily defeated 4-1 on Saturday. But its relevance is critical, particularly to Abby Wambach – and for…

  2. Stock Falling: Which U.S. players’ statures are slipping …

    Jun 19, 2013, 10:21 PM EDT

    WCup Honduras US Soccer AP

    Among the many assets in Jurgen Klinsmann’s portfolio, few are trending down.

  3. Get to your DVRs as soon as possible, because that Italy-Japan match was a classic

    Jun 19, 2013, 8:44 PM EDT

    Italy's Sebastian Giovinco scores the winning goal during their Confederations Cup Group A soccer match against Japan at the Arena Pernambuco in Recife Reuters

    Confederations Cup completely worth it when it provides matches like these.

  4. Stock Rising: United States men whose values are rising out of Salt Lake

    Jun 19, 2013, 7:35 PM EDT

    Honduras v United States - FIFA 2014 World Cup Qualifier Getty Images

    There’re no shortage of players to praise after the U.S. completes a nine-out-of-nine run.

  5. A little media hiccup from the U.S. Soccer players

    Jun 19, 2013, 6:47 PM EDT

    FBL - WC2014 - QUALIFIER - USA - HON

    Most U.S. players were still in the locker room an hour after final whistle Tuesday … watching a basketball game. Hmmm.

  6. MLS Preview: Portland Timbers at LA Galaxy

    Jun 19, 2013, 5:58 PM EDT

    Landon Donovan

    Even while struggling, LA’s still the standard, but can they turn things around enough to keep Portland from the top of the West.

  7. Goal, assist from Neymar give Brazil win, prolong Mexico’s woes

    Jun 19, 2013, 5:25 PM EDT

    FBL-WC2014-CONFED-BRA-MEX

    Neymar’s show compounded problems for CONCACAF’s champions.

  8. Brad Friedel reveals he wants to coach after career is over

    Jun 19, 2013, 4:52 PM EDT

    FBL-EUR-C3-TOTTENHAM-BASEL Getty Images

    The 42-year-old American revealed he is taking coaching courses to prepare for whenever his career is over.

  9. Exploring the Jermaine Jones conundrum. Again.

    Jun 19, 2013, 4:17 PM EDT

    Honduras v United States - FIFA 2014 World Cup Qualifier Getty Images

    Some of those old issues of communication and understanding between Jones and Michael Bradley were on display once again in Utah:

  10. MLS Preview: Houston Dynamo at Montréal Impact

    Jun 19, 2013, 3:32 PM EDT

    Andres Romero, Patrice Bernier, Marco Di Vaio,

    Montréal can open a gap atop the East with a win tonight. If Houston springs the upset, they’ll be within one point of the conference leaders.

  11. Pepe Reina wants to see out his contract at Liverpool…for now

    Jun 19, 2013, 2:44 PM EDT

    Manchester City v Liverpool - Premier League Getty Images

    He didn’t exactly say much, but Pepe Reina’s club is Liverpool – at least, right now.

  12. USA can theoretically clinch a World Cup berth in their next match

    Jun 19, 2013, 1:24 PM EDT

    Honduras v United States - FIFA 2014 World Cup Qualifier Getty Images

    It’s a bit of a longshot, but the United States has a mathematical chance of securing qualification for Brazil in the next round of play.

  13. Graham Zusi keeps making it harder for Landon Donovan to get back into U.S. national team

    Jun 19, 2013, 12:48 PM EDT

    Graham Zusi, Arnold Peralta

    The Sporting Kansas City man had a lot to say about last night’s breakout (finally!) in the second half vs. Honduras:

  14. De Gea message to Thiago on signed match ball sparks rumor flurry

    Jun 19, 2013, 12:04 PM EDT

    Italy v Spain - UEFA European U21 Championships: Final Getty Images

    Cameras caught a message from Manchester United goalkeeper David de Gea, could it foreshadow a move?

  15. PSG still can’t lock down a manager

    Jun 19, 2013, 11:22 AM EDT

    Russia's coach Fabio Capello listens to a question during a news conference at Luz Stadium in Lisbon Reuters

    Fabio Capello is the latest manager to say “no” to the defending Ligue 1 champions.

  16. Official: West Ham make Andy Carroll record signing

    Jun 19, 2013, 10:23 AM EDT

    Chelsea v West Ham United - Premier League Getty Images

    Liverpool take a huge net loss on the 24-year-old while West Ham set their transfer fee record.

  17. Chivas U-18 captain killed in car accident

    Jun 19, 2013, 9:48 AM EDT

    BlackRibbon_DLimage

    Tragedy struck Chivas USA’s youth squad Monday night.

  18. Premier League decides to put FA Cup final at season’s end

    Jun 19, 2013, 9:15 AM EDT

    Wigan Athletic's manager Roberto Martinez holds the trophy after defeating Manchester City in their FA Cup final soccer match at Wembley Stadium in London Reuters

    At the call of fans and media alike, the FA Cup final at Wembley will return to its post-league date.

  19. Jurgen Klinsmann gets his lineup selection spot on again

    Jun 19, 2013, 8:35 AM EDT

    FBL - WC2014 - QUALIFIER - USA - HON Getty Images

    The United States had the perfect lineup to slowly whittle away at the Honduras defense before it finally broke.

  20. Eric Lichaj signs with Nottingham Forest

    Jun 19, 2013, 7:45 AM EDT

    Britain Soccer Premier League Getty Images

    The 24-year-old American has found a new team after spending 5 seasons at Villa Park.

Top 10 Player Searches
  1. D. Wade (NBA)
  2. W. Myers (MLB)
  3. T. Parker (NBA)
  4. Y. Puig (MLB)
  5. D. Green (NBA)