Skip to content

Nine charged after unrest at Manchester Derby

Dec 10, 2012, 12:08 PM EDT

Manchester City v Manchester United - Premier League Getty Images

Nine people have been charged by Manchester police after late match unrest yesterday at the Etihad Stadium. Although the person who threw the coin that struck Manchester United defender Rio Ferdinand has yet to be identified, others have been charged with racially aggravated public order offenses, pitch encroachment, breaching banning orders, or drunk and disorderly conduct.

And perhaps the best part, their names and ages have been printed in the national papers. At least the people of Manchester know which idiots caused yesterday’s chaos.

As soccer matches go, the chaos was rather mild. That didn’t make it any more palatable. After Robin van Persie’s stoppage top restart was deflected into Joe Hart’s net, Manchester City’s home crowd caused a small delay in the match. People invading the playing field drew the attention of security and Hart, who physically confronted one frightened fan as he approached Ferdinand. As Ferdinand celebrated, a coin from the crowd his him above the left eye, requiring his trainer’s attention as blood streamed down the defender’s face.

The spectacle has drawn critique from higher ups in the English game. Professional Footballer’s Association chief executive Gordon Taylor, as told to BBC Radio 5 Live:

“I think you’ve got to give consideration to possibly, as has been suggested, some netting in vulnerable areas, be it behind the goals and round the corner flags.”

Football Association chairmen David Bernstein:

“It is deplorable to see those incidents and to see Rio Ferdinand with blood on his face is absolutely terrible.

“I think it’s disturbing that we’re seeing a recurrence of these types of incidents. We’ve had racial abuse issues, the odd pitch incursion, things being thrown at players – it’s very unacceptable and has to be dealt with severely.”

The indignation’s predictable, and the words are nice, but the issue goes deeper than nets. It’s easy to point to other sports leagues and cultures and say “they don’t have these problems,” but that doesn’t make it any less constructive. Why is this a problem in one environment and not in others?

The sad fact is that this type of behavior has been permitted to be part of the game in too many places. Perfunctory words from executives when the dark cloud rises does little to change the culture.  Nor does noting things have improved over the last couple of decades. Just because things were worse before doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be better now.

There needs to be a more concerted, persistent, and aggressive push to make clear what is acceptable behavior at soccer grounds. The effort needs to be proactive, not reactive. Until that happens, it’s hard to see the English game as anything more than mildly concerned about problems like Sunday’s.

  1. dfstell - Dec 10, 2012 at 2:12 PM

    How hard / expensive is it to put up cameras on the crowd? I’m not an expert, but it seems like if you can wire up security cameras around your home for a few thousand dollars, it should not be too hard to do a whole stadium The resolution on these cameras is getting insane. I took a bunch of pictures at a PDL game last summer with my new Nikon and was amazed that I could zoom in and see that one player was wearing a wedding band. Surely you could identify a monkey chant or coin thrower without too much trouble.

    • schlom - Dec 10, 2012 at 3:10 PM

      I’m pretty sure they do have cameras but there’s only so much they can cover. Unless a camera just happened to be pointed at the coin thrower (and who is to say there was only one person throwing things at Ferdinand) it might be impossible to pick out one person from fifty thousand.

  2. charliej11 - Dec 10, 2012 at 2:30 PM

    IF someone threw something on the field next to me, I am reporting him. I would guess 99% of the 40k-60k at the games I go to agree with me.

    I don’t really understand how racism and incidents like this are going on, other than the fans want it to.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

PST Extra: Analyzing transfer deadline day