Skip to content

Ancelotti may need more than win over Lyon to stay on at PSG

Dec 15, 2012, 3:30 PM EDT

FBL-LIGUE1-PSG-ANCELOTTI Getty Images

As with all things, the French tend to be philosophical about their sport. Though it would be a mistake to paint the entire population with the same broad brush, you’re more likely to get the larger perspective out of a French soccer fan after results that might lead others to claims of “famous” wins or states of “crisis”. For some, the approach explains why draws seem to be more palatable around Ligue 1. One match’s results are too little to get excited about, especially when the score’s inconclusive.

Carlo Ancelloti, however, has begun to draw conclusions from philosophers. The Milan legend who won the Premier League at Chelsea is nearing his one year anniversary at Paris Saint-Germain. When he took over for Antoine Kombouaré on Dec. 30, 2011, PSG had just used a win over Saint-Etienne to move into first place, a spot they’ve infrequently held since. After falling at Nancy on March 31, PSG lost their lead and eventually the title to Montpellier. They have not led the league at the end of a round since.

That Ancelotti has not faced the same scrutiny that befell Kombouaré seems incongruous until you remember who hired him. Leonardo, brought in last season to serve as PSG’s director of football, chose Ancelotti, his first coaching hired in Paris. The Brazilian inherited Kombouaré, a circumstance that left the coach’s job the source of constant speculation throughout the first half of last season. Ancelotti has already gotten leeway the former PSG defender never saw.

The expectations on Ancelotti, however, are higher, part of the reason the two-time Champions League winner’s viability is starting to be questioned. Paris Saint-Germain enter Sunday’s match against league-leading Olympique Lyonnais three points back despite another huge round of summer investment from their Qatari owners. Most notably, Zlatan Ibrahimovic was not only purchased but has dominated the league, scoring a league-leading 17 times in his first 14 appearances. Add in talents of Ezequiel Lavezzi, Marco Veratti, Thiago Silva and Gregory Van Der Wiel – all added over the summer – and concern over Ancelotti’s results becomes understandable.

But if the coach is to be believed, the influx of new talent may actually be a hinderance. The burdens of expectation may not be something PSG’s new players feel, according to Ancelotti:

“As coach, I have to take my share of responsibility, but the players have to do the same,” Ancelotti said, per ESPNFC. “I get the impression the players feel the club’s project and the problems in the team’s play don’t concern them.

“My players don’t make a team. They’re still a group of individuals. We still don’t have any consistency in our game. It’s neither solid nor unified. The work of a coach is to find a solution very quickly.”

Hinting a solution’s been found, PSG have won three in a row, a stretch that’s included impressive wins over Porto (in Champions League) and at Valenciennes (0-4). Unfortunately a preceding stretch of only three victories in eight games has created a bottom line feel around the team. They may have won three on the trot, but these are the results the team was supposed to be producing all along. Why is PSG in second place? Why are they trailing Lyon?

Part of that is PSG’s regression (they’re on pace for fewer points than last year’s second place campaign), but it would be unfair to not give some credit to Rémi Garde. After the Lyon coach suffered through his own first year struggles (OL failing to claim a Champions League spot for the first time in 14 years), the former Gones sweeper has his team on top of the league despite the club’s continued overhaul. The only imports have been cast offs — Steed Malbranque finding a home at Stade Gerland, Milan Bisevac slotting into defense after becoming surplus at (ironically) PSG — but given the litany of names Garde has lost, Lyon was expected to be fringe contenders at best. Those are the expectations when a team that finished 18 points off the lead loses their No. 1. keeper (Hugo Lloris, to Tottenham), a midfield linchpin (Kim Kallstrom, to Spartak Moscow), their starting left back (Aly Cissokho, to Valencia), and their long-serving defensive leader (Cris, to Galatasaray).

Youth served

With the summer departures of Hugo Lloris, Cris, Kim Kallstrom and Aly Cissokho, Lyon has fully embraced their youth movement:

2012-13 Career
Player Age Pos. GP G GP G
Maxime Gonalons 23 M 16 2 89 4
Dejan Lovren 23 D 7 1 61 2
Alexandre Lacazette 21 A 15 1 54 7
Clement Grenier 21 M 11 1 42 1
Guieda Fofana 21 M 12 0 30 0
Rachid Ghezzal 20 M 4 0 4 0
Samuel Umtiti 19 D 8 0 20 0
Yassine Benzia 18 A 8 0 9 0

They were expectations Lyon president Jean-Michel Aulas set when he hired the inexperienced Garde, and although missing Champions League was a huge disappointment for a club that dominated France not so long ago, Lyon is consciously and successfully undergoing a youth movement. Of Garde’s starters for Nov. 28’s 4-1 Classique victory at Marseille, five were Lyon products age 23 or younger: defender Samuel Umtiti; midfielders Clement Grenier and Maxime Gonalons; and attackers Alexandre Lacazette and Rachid Ghezzal. Add in the contributions of defender Dejan Lovren (bought from Dinamo Zagreb), midfielder Gueida Fofana (Le Havrea) and attacker Yassine Benzia and you have the largest and most deliberate youth movement among Europe’s major clubs.

It’s a point of literary irony that it’s a build from within, cut costs, shun the benefits of big buys philosophy that’s proved an obstacle Paris Saint-Germain’s ambition. While Lyon still has names Lisandro Lopez, Michel Bastos, and Bafetimbi Gomis among their ranks, this was once a team that had the likes of Karim Benzema, Michael Essien, and Florent Malouda. It’s not quite the talent currently patrolling the Parc de Princes, but there was a time that OL’s talent lapped the Ligue 1 field, one of the main reasons the club won seven straight titles through 2008. For the last two years, the talent advantage has lied with the Parisians, yet they lost last year’s race to an undermanned Montpellier and trail a reconfiguring Lyon as we approach this year’s break. (Aulus recently conceded all of Lopez, Basots, and Gomis could still go as the team looks to further reduce payroll.)

But Lyon’s reconfiguring has gone beyond mere roster turnover. On the field, Garde has settled into the 4-2-3-1 formation that never took hold last season. In the past it would have seemed a counter-intuitive approach, a setup that isolates OL’s best player (Lopez) out left, but given Lopez’s fitness concerns and the depth and variety of talent Garde has in midfielders and wider attackers, it’s been the team’s best approach. The resulting system has gotten the most out of Gomis, one of two double-digit scorers in France, while promoting a possession game that’s helped drastically reduce the team’s goals allowed (Lyon’s conceded 16 in 17 games after allowing 51 last season).

source: Getty ImagesIt’s all part of a year’s worth of hard-earned lessons for Garde (right), who has no head coaching experience before being appointed by Aulus. But seeing how Garde’s grown after one year on the job,  it’s worth asking whether Ancelotti could do the same. But the PSG boss has always enjoyed strong starts at his previous stops, something that makes his PSG experience all the more concerning. And the Parisians aren’t a side in the middle of scaling back a once dominant operation. They’re building to not only win in France but to compete at a level which will make them a global brand. Ancelotti was hired to bring immediate success, not implement a process.

This is why, as Andy Brassell points out today in The Independent, the French media has started to be brash about a post-Ancelotti future. L’Equipe, France’s sports daily, has reported PSG’s management has already sounded out Pep Guardiola, with long-time link Arsène Wenger and Real Madrid’s José Mourinho also in frame. The recent, thin support of PSG president Nasser al-Khelaifi (“Today, Carlo is here” he said after the Porto win) left little doubt the Italian’s future is being evaluated.

Consider the implications if Paris Saint-Germain lose on Sunday. They’ll trail going into winter break, six points back of Lyon. There’ll be no three-match winning streak to assuage doubts. Worse for Ancelotti, there’ll be a two week break that will allow the Qataris to ask the question normally reserved for presidential elections: Are we better off than we were before?

Even if PSG draw, it’s hard to see that answer coming back as yes. Despite far more talent, the Parisians aren’t getting noticeably better results. Perhaps ownership will fall back on Ancelotti’s Champions League success as reason to retain him through the European season, but where their evaluation of his predecessor was clinical and cold, Ancelotti would be fortunate to survive the holiday season without a win over Lyon.

One game’s results might be harder to get worked up about in France than other cultures, but there’s little doubt Ancelotti needs to win on Sunday. But if we look back on the circumstances of Antoine Kombouaré’s dismissal, even that may not be enough to avoid change in Paris.

Latest Posts
  1. Premier League Saturday recap: West Ham stuns Manchester City, Sanchez braces Arsenal

    Oct 25, 2014, 7:23 PM EDT

    Britain Soccer Premier League AP

    Short recap and highlights of Saturday’s Round 9 Premier League matches.

  2. Premier League Sunday preview: Manchester United vs. Chelsea headlines

    Oct 25, 2014, 7:08 PM EDT

    Britain Soccer Premier League AP

    With three games on the slate, here’s what you can look forward to on Sunday.

  3. MLS Snapshot: Montreal Impact 1-1 DC United

    Oct 25, 2014, 6:18 PM EDT

    Marco Di Vaio, Patrice Bernier, AP

    Final: Montreal Impact 1, D.C. United 1

  4. Chicago Fire pleased with former Tottenham Hotspur trialist Jaime O’Hara

    Oct 25, 2014, 5:23 PM EDT

    ohara_1496113c Getty Images

    The Chicago Fire are seeking to bolster the strength of their roster, examining the possible signing of ex-Tottenham Hotspur midfielder Jaime O’Hara.

  5. Seattle 2-0 L.A. Galaxy: Pappa the hero again, Sounders win 1st Shield

    Oct 25, 2014, 4:55 PM EDT

    MLS Galaxy Sounders Soccer AP

    A sleepy game for over an hour, Seattle and L.A. used the last hour to stage a contest worthy of a trophy-winning event.

  6. Gerard Pique calls his handball ‘unintentional’ in El Clasico defeat

    Oct 25, 2014, 4:29 PM EDT

    Pique Getty Images

    Pique speaks of his handball in Barcelona’s 3-1 defeat to Real Madrid: “It was unintentional.”

  7. LIVE ON NBC: Scoreless half has Seattle 45 mins from Supporters Shield

    Oct 25, 2014, 3:47 PM EDT

    @lagalaxy @lagalaxy

    The L.A. Galaxy and Seattle Sounders are scoreless through 45 minutes at CenturyLink in Washington.

  8. Leeds United ax manager Darko Milanic after six games at the helm

    Oct 25, 2014, 3:30 PM EDT

    darko_3045587b Getty Images

    Leeds United have fired manager Darko Milanic after only 32 days leading the squad.

  9. Bundesliga wrap: Dortmund’s freefall continues, 9-goal thriller in Frankfurt

    Oct 25, 2014, 2:59 PM EDT

    FBL-GER-DORTMUND-HANOVER Getty Images

    Several fun games whet the appetite for a massive top of table Sunday tilt between Bayern Munich and Borussia Monchengladbach.

  10. Swansea City 2-0 Leicester City: Bony brace tames timid Foxes in Wales (video)

    Oct 25, 2014, 2:20 PM EDT

    Swansea City v Leicester City - Premier League Getty Images

    Wilfried Bony scored both goals for Swans, 2-0, who cruised to the win against the suddenly-struggling Foxes.

  11. Watch Live: Seattle Sounders vs. L.A. Galaxy (Lineups and Live Stream)

    Oct 25, 2014, 2:07 PM EDT

    Obafemi Martins, Robbie Rogers AP

    Will the Sounders handle the Galaxy and expectations to clinch home-field throughout the playoffs?

  12. Southampton manager Ronald Koeman: “It’s fantastic” to be in Premier League’s second place

    Oct 25, 2014, 1:54 PM EDT

    Southampton v Stoke City - Premier League Getty Images

    “Maybe they [Stoke] created two possibilities, not chances and that’s a great team effort,” Koeman said of his Saints.

  13. Real Madrid 3-1 Barcelona: Real win El Clasico, Suarez returns

    Oct 25, 2014, 1:47 PM EDT

    Pepe Pepe

    Despite going behind earlier, Real came roaring back to win the first El Clasico of 2014-15.

  14. WATCH: Bony and Sigurdsson team up for beauty versus Leicester on NBC

    Oct 25, 2014, 1:28 PM EDT

    Reading v Swansea City - Pre Season Friendly Getty Images

    Watch and enjoy, then follow the second half live on NBC and online via Live Extra.

  15. LIVE – At the half: Neymar, Cristiano Ronaldo have Real Madrid, Barcelona level

    Oct 25, 2014, 12:59 PM EDT

    Real Madrid CF v FC Barcelona - La Liga Real Madrid CF v FC Barcelona - La Liga

    Neymar and Ronaldo stealing the show so far, as four on yellows for Barca. Live updates, here:

  16. VIDEO: Manuel Pellegrini “not disappointed” by Manchester City’s defeat

    Oct 25, 2014, 12:48 PM EDT

    FBL-ENG-PR-WEST HAM-MAN CITY FBL-ENG-PR-WEST HAM-MAN CITY

    Pellegrini magnanimous in defeat, but City could be eight points off top spot by the end of the weekend.

  17. Liverpool 0-0 Hull City: Clean sheet small consolation for rigid Reds (video)

    Oct 25, 2014, 12:05 PM EDT

    Reds thwarted by stubborn Tigers, as Balotelli fires a blank once again.

  18. West Bromwich Albion 2-2 Crystal Palace: Baggies find deserved point (video)

    Oct 25, 2014, 12:04 PM EDT

    West Bromwich Albion v Crystal Palace - Premier League Getty Images

    West Brom won the shots battle 17-8 and carried nearly 70 percent of the possession by the time all was said and done.

  19. Southampton 1-0 Stoke City: Dominant Saints only need one goal (video)

    Oct 25, 2014, 11:59 AM EDT

    Southampton v Stoke City - Premier League Getty Images

    It was 1-0 at half, and it was all the Saints would need.

Featured video

PST Extra: Can United beat Chelsea?