Skip to content

NFL playoff construction right; MLS construction, not so much

Jan 6, 2013, 8:30 AM EST

Sounders FC Sporting Kansas City Soccer

I’m watched the NFL playoffs yesterday, taking a wee break from our game. But I’m never very far from thinking about soccer. So …

I could not help but think about how the ratio of NFL teams that qualify for the playoffs is spot-on perfect, whereas Major League Soccer’s more lenient qualification policy continues to leave me feeling a tad underwhelmed.

And that’s frustrating, because there are so many areas where Major League Soccer simply cannot compare to the mighty NFL. In any measure of public appeal, it’s no contest, so there’s little cause for comparison.

But in terms of procedures and policies, there’s no reason why MLS cannot match its much bigger “football” brother.

In NFL, 12 of 32 teams make the playoffs. That’s 37.5 percent, or slightly more than a third. Combine that with the fact that NFL teams get just 16 cracks at regular season success, every single game day is a biggie.

By contrast, Major League Soccer’s more forgiving format provides safe playoff passage to 10 of 19 teams. That’s more than half.

And that’s still too many.

The result is too many regular season matches that still don’t carry sufficient weight. (Yes, it would help if there was a promotion-relegation structure – but that’s not going to happen, so let’s not wander down that rabbit trail just now, please.)

Think about this: in the NBA, 16 of 30 teams qualify for the “tournament.” That’s about the same as in MLS, right around 53 percent. They play a whole bunch of regular season games (82), which is the primary reason the regular season is sometimes reduced to a punch line, due to that lack of weight attached to each individual contest.

While the NBA condition is mostly about having so many regular season games, it is also about a playoff format that allows safe post-season passage for too many mediocre teams.

Want to identify one way to instantly make MLS games a little more exciting through the bulk of the season? Go back to the days when just 8 clubs made the post-season. That would certainly help.

Latest Posts
  1. Real Salt Lake’s Joao Plata to undergo surgery on broken foot, miss start of season

    Jan 26, 2015, 8:22 PM EST

    Joao Plata, Real Salt Lake Joao Plata, Real Salt Lake

    3-4 months on the sidelines means a massive hole to fill to start the 2015 season.

  2. Africa Cup of Nations roundup: Tunisia, DR Congo draw in group finale, advance to QF

    Jan 26, 2015, 7:10 PM EST

    Ahmed Akaichi, Tunisia Ahmed Akaichi, Tunisia

    After two more places in the knockout rounds were booked on Tuesday, half the quarterfinal matchups are set.

  3. Chile vs. USA preview: Who’s here to stay as USMNT kicks off 2015?

    Jan 26, 2015, 6:15 PM EST

    Wil Trapp (left), Columbus Crew Wil Trapp (left), Columbus Crew

    Half the current USMNT roster was built with the Gold Cup in mind, while the other half is about next year’s Olympics. So, who’s who, then?

  4. Report: Juan Agudelo close to signing with his former MLS team, New England Revolution

    Jan 26, 2015, 4:05 PM EST

    Juan Agudelo, FC Utrecht Juan Agudelo, FC Utrecht

    After eight months without a club, Juan Agudelo is reportedly returning to the place he should have been all along: MLS.

  5. VIDEO: Legendary Argentine playmaker Juan Roman Riquelme retires

    Jan 26, 2015, 2:59 PM EST

    Juan Roman Riquelme Juan Roman Riquelme

    As the soccer world will no longer see the maverick skills of the Argentine playmaker, here’s a look at some of his best moments.

  6. FA Cup fifth-round draw: Arsenal vs. Middlesbrough, Midlands derby, minnows at home

    Jan 26, 2015, 2:38 PM EST

    Here’s the draw for the last 16 of the FA Cup, as PL big boys get more tough tests.

  7. Head of Dutch FA, Michael van Praag, will challenge Blatter for FIFA presidency

    Jan 26, 2015, 1:57 PM EST

    UEFA Europa League Handover In Amsterdam Getty Images

    Van Praag announces his intentions to run against Blatter, says he has the backing of five federations.

  8. Drinks on her! Lady wins $24,000 after $3 bet predicted huge FA Cup upsets

    Jan 26, 2015, 1:00 PM EST

    Hartlepool United v Blyth Spartans - FA Cup Second Round Getty Images

    Betting on five underdogs away from home in the FA Cup will win you serious cash.

  9. Diego Fagundez says he was “tired of waiting for the U.S.” after choosing to play for Uruguay

    Jan 26, 2015, 12:32 PM EST

    FBL-U20-SOUTHAM-URU-COL FBL-U20-SOUTHAM-URU-COL

    Fagundez explains why he couldn’t wait any longer to select his national team.

  10. Chelsea’s Andre Schurrle rumored to want Wolfsburg move. Should he move on?

    Jan 26, 2015, 12:00 PM EST

    Swansea City v Chelsea - Premier League Getty Images

    If Wolfsburg can agree a fee for Schurrle, should he leave Stamford Bridge?

  11. Transfer ban for Real Madrid? Probe launched after signing of Venezuelan kids

    Jan 26, 2015, 9:20 AM EST

    Official logo of the spanish football team, Real Madrid. Official logo of the spanish football team, Real Madrid.

    The signing of two Venezuelan youngsters could put Real in plenty of trouble with FIFA, as Barcelona-esque transfer ban could be on the cards.

  12. VIDEO: South Korea beat Iraq to reach first Asian Cup final since 1998

    Jan 26, 2015, 8:34 AM EST

    FBL-ASIA2015-KOR-IRQ FBL-ASIA2015-KOR-IRQ

    The Koreans will face either Australia or the UAE in Saturday’s final in Sydney.

  13. City’s Pellegrini concerned at home form after Arsenal, Middlesbrough losses

    Jan 25, 2015, 11:33 PM EST

    Britain Soccer FA Cup AP

    “I am concerned, not because of Chelsea but because we didn’t score in our last two home games,” Pellegrini said.

  14. Eto’o passes physical at Sampdoria, move from Everton all but official

    Jan 25, 2015, 10:50 PM EST

    twitter.com/sampdoria twitter.com/sampdoria

    The 33-year-old Cameroonian striker joins a Sampdoria side currently tied for third in the table with 34 points.

  15. Rodgers: Sturridge could face Chelsea in League Cup, certain to be back for Saturday vs. West Ham

    Jan 25, 2015, 10:13 PM EST

    Liverpool FC Training Session Getty Images

    “If he’s not ready for Tuesday then he’ll be back, for sure, against West Ham next weekend,” Rodgers said.

  16. Scotland, Wigan mid joins Chicago Fire as third Designated Player

    Jan 25, 2015, 9:22 PM EST

    twitter.com/chicagofire twitter.com/chicagofire

    Maloney turned 32 on Saturday and will be unveiled by Chicago on Monday.

  17. Sepp Blatter keeps talking trash at UEFA regarding FIFA election

    Jan 25, 2015, 8:31 PM EST

    FBL-FIFA-BALLONDOR-AWARD Getty Images

    Sepp Blatter: Kind of like “The Godfather”. But let’s be clear, we’re talking “The Godfather: Part III”.

Featured video

Top five Premier League goals: Week 22