Skip to content

Discussing a big decision in a big game, the PK and red card in Arsenal-Manchester City

Jan 13, 2013, 12:40 PM EDT

Arsenal v Manchester City - Premier League Getty Images

Just nine minutes into Arsenal’s important meeting at home against Manchester City, this one took a fast turn toward the lesser fancied Sunday morning nether region of: “Uh, what time do those NFL playoff games start?”

That is to say, it was very nearly not worth watching.

Not because these two well-stocked clubs don’t deserve watching; both have exciting players and both are desperately chasing their own Premiership rewards. Rather, the watchability factor slipped because of a 9th minute incident that tilted the field heavily.

Sure enough, visiting City was in charge through much of the match and emerged with the 2-0 result.

Arsenal center back Laurent Koscielny was all over City striker Edin Dzeko as a ball dropped perilously in front of Gunners goal, blatantly wrapping both arms around the Bosnian striker. Both tumbled as Dzeko moved in for a potential early strike. Referee Mike Dean pointed to the spot, held up the red and … well, let’s talk about it:

  • It’s a tough call to make so early, but Dean made the right one (on the penalty kick, at least.) If Koscielny could have merely put a body on Dzeko, perhaps even laid an arm into him, that might have provided Dean sufficient cover to wave “play-on” or to think twice the expulsion, at least. More to the point, it might not have actually been a blatant foul. As it was, it’s a foul – and therefore a penalty kick.
  • It’s a brutal development, affecting the match so dramatically, so early. But as the game’s laws are written, Dean was mostly correct here. It’s a bold, bold call and Dean is no dummy; he recognizes exactly how much moment is altering fortunes.
  • For the reason I just stated – the titanic impact, that is – I wonder if City might have complained too much if Dean would have awarded the penalty kick and kept Koscielny on the field? I tend to believe most of us would have had little problem with that.
  • I’ve said before, I really wish the game’s lawmakers would review the double jeopardy involved in these decisions. Awarding a penalty kick (about 80 percent chance of scoring) and reducing a side to 10 men is so very harsh. I understand the argument: “Don’t foul!”  But we know there is so very much fouling and contact that goes on near goal. So these important decisions inside the 18 aren’t really about fouling, per se.  So much of that does go on.  It really comes down to chance and providence; it’s really more about which clear fouls are spotted by the man in the middle.

I said “double jeopardy” on the decision. I noticed a few minutes later where NBC colleague and pal Arlo White reminded mentioned on Twitter that my assessment may be a tad low:

source:

Latest Posts
  1. MLS Snapshot: New York Red Bulls 3-0 DC United

    Aug 30, 2015, 9:15 PM EDT

    Bradley Wright-Phillips, New York Red Bulls AP

    A complete performance from the Red Bulls, who will finish the season unbeaten against their Atlantic Cup rivals.

  2. Done Deals: De Bruyne joins Manchester City in busy day for Wolfsburg

    Aug 30, 2015, 8:05 PM EDT

    FBL-ENG-GER-ARSENAL-WOLFSBURG-FRIENDLY Getty Images

    Find out what moves have been completed with the transfer deadline approaching, as Wolfsburg made three big deals today.

  3. MLS Snapshot: Seattle Sounders 2-1 Portland Timbers

    Aug 30, 2015, 7:04 PM EDT

    cd0ymzcznguwzdbhnduynddiytjhm2yyzthlmtjjotqwyyznpwiwy2q3odk1zwm3ownizgywzdkyota2nwzhymvkmgrl AP

    More than 64,000 supporters packed CenturyLink Field as the Sounders downed the Timbers in a Cascadia Cup clash.

  4. La Liga & Serie A roundup: Madrid clubs cruise; Juve loses again

    Aug 30, 2015, 6:20 PM EDT

    Karim Benzema AP

    Catch up on all of this weekend’s action from Spain and Italy’s top flights.

  5. Bayern Munich signs teen sensation Kingsley Coman from Juventus

    Aug 30, 2015, 5:30 PM EDT

    FBL-ITA-SERIEA-FIORENTINA-JUVENTUS Getty Images

    The French winger has played for Paris Saint-Germain, Juventus, and now Bayern Munich. All before his 20th birthday.

  6. USMNT releases 23-man roster for September friendlies

    Aug 30, 2015, 4:38 PM EDT

    Howard AP

    Tim Howard and Geoff Cameron are back in the squad, while the relatively unknown Andrew Wooten gets his first call-up.

  7. VIDEO: Garry Monk’s tactical changes led to win over Manchester United

    Aug 30, 2015, 4:00 PM EDT

    Newcastle United v Swansea City - Premier League Getty Images

    In a managerial battle between the young Garry Monk and the veteran Louis van Gaal, the kid came out on top.

  8. Roma beats Juventus 2-1 as defending champs drop second straight

    Aug 30, 2015, 3:05 PM EDT

    cd0ymzcznguwzdbhnduynddiytjhm2yyzthlmtjjotqwyyznptqwogu2mgu2njgznjflnjbhmtyyota3mdazymzkyjvm AP

    After losing three matches all of last season, Juventus has now lost their first two games of the new campaign.

  9. VIDEO: Louis van Gaal laments being “too dominant” in loss to Swansea City

    Aug 30, 2015, 2:08 PM EDT

    VanGaal Getty Images

    The Manchester United manager believed his club got so comfortable on the ball that they lost their focus.

  10. Saint-Etienne striker Bahebeck hospitalized after breathing troubles

    Aug 30, 2015, 1:38 PM EDT

    Bahebeck Getty Images

    Reports indicate the Saint-Etienne medical staff was initially afraid that the young striker had suffered a heart attack, but it appears the issues are just heat related.

  11. Swansea City 2-1 Manchester United: Swans comeback stuns Red Devils

    Aug 30, 2015, 12:51 PM EDT

    Gomis Getty Images

    The Red Devils thought they’d picked up points at the Liberty Stadium, but Bafetimbi Gomis had other ideas.

  12. Sunday Transfer Rumor Roundup: Draxler to Wolfsburg, Wanyama to leave Saints

    Aug 30, 2015, 11:48 AM EDT

    Draxler Getty Images

    Juventus was in for the Schalke winger, but Wolfsburg now need a replacement for Kevin de Bruyne.

  13. Manchester City officially signs Kevin de Bruyne

    Aug 30, 2015, 11:12 AM EDT

    DeBruyne Getty Images

    Wolfsburg tried its darndest, but Kevin de Bruyne still decided to leave in favor of a crowded Manchester City squad.

  14. Watch Live: Swansea City vs Manchester United (Lineups and Live Stream)

    Aug 30, 2015, 10:42 AM EDT

    cd0ymzcznguwzdbhnduynddiytjhm2yyzthlmtjjotqwyyznptfly2fjmgq3njvimzkxyze4mmmxowe2zwziyzg0mwvi AP

    Manchester United has started the season strong, but they take on a team that beat them twice last season.

  15. Southampton 3-0 Norwich City: Saints swarm 10-man Norwich for season’s first win

    Aug 30, 2015, 10:22 AM EDT

    Pelle Getty Images

    Graziano Pelle grabbed the opener and Dusan Tadic finished it off with a brace as Southampton flew to its first win of the year.

  16. Victor Valdes to trudge on at Manchester United after Besiktas move falls apart

    Aug 30, 2015, 9:29 AM EDT

    Valdes Getty Images

    Could Valdes be forced to stay with Manchester United despite his obvious wish to leave?

  17. Australian striker scores eight goals in A-League preseason match

    Aug 30, 2015, 8:46 AM EDT

    Maclaren Getty Images

    Oh the season hasn’t started yet? Jamie Maclaren wasn’t aware.

  18. Watch Live: Southampton vs Norwich City (Lineups and Live Stream)

    Aug 30, 2015, 7:50 AM EDT

    Koeman Getty Images

    Ronald Koeman must pick up a win fast or risk seeing Southampton in a serious early season hole.

  19. Montreal’s Frank Klopas becomes first MLS head coach fired this season

    Aug 30, 2015, 7:30 AM EDT

    Klopas Getty Images

    A single coach had yet to be fired as we approach the start of September, but that changed as Montreal made a change.

  20. MLS Snapshot: FC Dallas 2-0 Real Salt Lake (video)

    Aug 29, 2015, 11:37 PM EDT

    Fabian Castillo, FC Dallas Fabian Castillo, FC Dallas

    The playoffs look a might big ask of RSL, as they sit rock bottom, 10th place, in the Western Conference.

Featured video

Highlights: Swansea's win vs. Man United