Skip to content

Let’s face it: Zlatan Ibrahimovic shouldn’t have been red carded

Feb 12, 2013, 11:15 PM EST

As I watched the replay of Tuesday’s Valencia-Paris Saint-Germain match (because I hit Celtic-Juve first), I was surprised to hear relatively little debate about Zlatan Ibrahimovic’s red card. The PSG star saw straight red and earned the corresponding suspension after this stoppage time challenge:

The two arguments on this:

Ibrahimovic went over the top of the ball, making this a reckless, unnecessary challenge. He made full contact in a way that could have hurt Andres Guardado, therefore making it dangerous. While that may not be a red card every time, referee Paolo Tagliabento was within his rights to show Ibra red.

If that argument sounds dispassionate, it’s because I’m not buying it. This is just Ibrahimovic stepping on somebody’s foot, and while it’s conceivable the game could evolve to the point where this type of cynical foul would be an automatic red, dismissing Ibrahimovic is disproportionate. We just don’t see red cards for that type of foul. There’s no reason for Ibrahimovic, in the moments leading into that action, to believe he’d see red for what he’d decided to do. For Tagliabento to dismiss him for it is unjust.

Within the wiggle room referees get to interpret dangerous plays, Tagliabento’s entitled to his interpretation. It’s not outright wrong, and it’s probably not worth making a big deal about. Even if he is wrong, Tagliabento is entitled to occasional mistakes. Unless this is type of decision is a pattern from the Italian official, it’s better to just chalk it up to the game’s natural variance. Just bad “luck” for Ibra.

Though you could argue Ibrahimovic’s play was dangerous because it could have broken some toes, that interpretation of danger (potential harm) is problematic. There are a number of more common, more dangerous plays that are allowed to transpire through the course of a game – plays that would never draw a red card. Almost any time a player goes to ground, he’s exposing his opponent to more injury than Guardado was exposed to. Then a player is second in the air to contest a header, he’s risks concussions for both himself and this adversary. Even when a goalkeeper goes to punch a ball, he often puts other players at risk with the follow through or his jump.

In each of those situations, players commit to “dangerous” actions because they know they’re allowed to. Game in, game out they play by a set of standards enforced by the officiating community, standards to which they’ve adapted their game. They know what will and won’t bring red cards, and they act accordingly.

Going into today’s match, the game’s conventions allowed for what Ibrahimovic did. At least, they didn’t call for Ibrahimovic to be dismissed for that challenge. At some point before Tagliabento’s whistle, that changed. And now Ibrahimovic will miss the return leg.

Latest Posts
  1. Bayern Munich sets record for most points at halfway stage

    Dec 19, 2014, 8:50 PM EST

    FC Bayern Muenchen v SC Freiburg - Bundesliga Getty Images

    With 45 points through 17 matches, Bayern Munich is having the best season in Bundesliga history.

  2. MLS announces home openers for 2015 season

    Dec 19, 2014, 8:00 PM EST

    mls Getty Images

    The opening weekend of MLS play features Orlando City SC and New York City FC facing off in a battle of expansion teams.

  3. Pardew and Poyet call for peace ahead of Tyne-Wear derby

    Dec 19, 2014, 7:10 PM EST

    Newcastle United v Sunderland - Premier League Getty Images

    Newcastle and Sunderland may be bitter rivals, but their managers are telling supporters to behave on Sunday.

  4. Mourinho says Eden Hazard can become an all-time great

    Dec 19, 2014, 6:20 PM EST

    eden Getty Images

    The Blues’ boss said his Belgian playmaker can become a Chelsea legend, but must win titles first.

  5. Joe Hart signs new contract at Manchester City

    Dec 19, 2014, 5:30 PM EST

    jh Getty Images

    England’s number one keeper finally put pen to paper with a new deal that will keep him at the Etihad until 2019.

  6. Nigel Pearson suspended one match for verbal spat with fan

    Dec 19, 2014, 4:40 PM EST

    Southampton v Leicester City - Premier League Getty Images

    The Leicester City boss was also fined $15,000 by the FA following his altercation with a fan.

  7. Tim Howard’s book details Cristiano Ronaldo’s soccer-obsessive nature

    Dec 19, 2014, 3:55 PM EST

    article-2664329-02DF3BFA0000044D-836_634x497

    CR7 and Howard, it seems, are among the few blessed with tons of talent and even more desire to work.

  8. Americans Abroad weekend preview: Rubin v. Aron, Derby day for Jozy

    Dec 19, 2014, 3:20 PM EST

    FBL-ENG-PR-SUNDERLAND-NEWCASTLE Getty Images

    In the Premier League, Brad Guzan is tasked with keeping Manchester United off the scoreboard.

  9. After failed odyssey abroad, Brek Shea returns to MLS with Orlando City

    Dec 19, 2014, 2:05 PM EST

    Orlando City SC photo of Brek Shea signing Orlando City SC photo of Brek Shea signing

    Orlando City founder and president Phil Rawlins described Shea as a big addition to the squad.

  10. Lille, Werder Bremen noted frontrunners for Jozy Altidore’s services

    Dec 19, 2014, 1:43 PM EST

    Liverpool v Sunderland - Premier League Getty Images

    Altidore’s production for his country and in the Eredivisie prove he’s a much better player than his horrible spell at Sunderland.

  11. Friday’s transfer rumor roundup: Shaqiri to Arsenal, Benzema a Red for $78 million?

    Dec 19, 2014, 12:52 PM EST

    Xherdan Shaqiri

    According to The Daily Express, Man Utd’s man if Mats Hummels won’t come over from Borussia Dortmund is Nicolas Otamendi of Valencia.

  12. WATCH: Premier League TV schedule – Week 17

    Dec 19, 2014, 12:00 PM EST

    PremierLeagueNBC

    Where and how to watch all the PL games during Week 17.

  13. Premier League Preview: Aston Villa vs. Manchester United

    Dec 19, 2014, 10:50 AM EST

    Britain Soccer Manchester United Angel Di Maria AP

    Villa Park hasn’t been a fortress for the Villans, and that’s underlined when bigger teams visit.

  14. Sporting KC adds former Chilean World Cup vet at goalkeeper; What’s next?

    Dec 19, 2014, 10:10 AM EST

    U de Chile v Palestino - Torneo Clausura 2014 Getty Images

    Sporting also added Hungarian striker Kristian Nemeth and Haitian mid James Marcellin.

  15. Prince-Wright’s Premier League picks: Everton, Manchester United, Liverpool

    Dec 19, 2014, 10:02 AM EST

    FBL-ENG-PR-EVERTON-QPR FBL-ENG-PR-EVERTON-QPR

    Here’s how PST’s lead writer and editor sees things panning out this weekend.

  16. Premier League Preview: Manchester City vs. Crystal Palace

    Dec 19, 2014, 9:06 AM EST

    mcfc.com mcfc.com

    Mangala on visitors to the Etihad: “Normally, teams that are coming here play more defensively.”

  17. Report: Garcia’s World Cup ethics report to be released after all

    Dec 19, 2014, 8:05 AM EST

    "I've done what?" — Getty Images Getty Images

    And to think, all it took was months and months of continuous anger and frustration from nearly everyone who wasn’t a part of FIFA itself.

Featured video

Man United thrash Liverpool