Skip to content

MLS needs a re-think on enforcing preseason discipline

Feb 24, 2013, 2:54 PM EDT

Philadelphia Union v DC United - Disney Pro Soccer Classic Getty Images

The matches are about to be real, and so will be the suspensions for those who misbehave.

Until now, Major League Soccer players have been operating in a gray area. It may be time to ask whether they should be?

The pressure point here will be Saturday’s not-so-friendly preseason tournament contest between D.C. United and East Coast rival Philadelphia – a contest that got fairly nasty.

The Washington Post’s Steven Goff was there to report on the 59th minute incident, when United captain Dwayne De Rosario was ejected for allegedly head-butting his former teammate, Danny Cruz.

The preseason friendlies get this way too often. It’s easy to blame the referees for failing to take control, but these are tough situations for the men in the middle.

The players aren’t ignorant; they understand that actual jeopardy is almost non-existent. Yellow card? So what, they don’t accumulate and mean nothing for the player once the real games begin. (First kick is Saturday, the schedule is here.)

Red card? The stakes are minimal since players and coaches don’t really care about results. Leaving your team a man down, if we’re honest, is really no biggie in the big picture.

Plus, there’s no carry-over in terms of missing the next match. In fact, in plenty of cases referees will simply ask the player to leave or ask a manager to remove them from the field rather than issuing a red card per se. As these contests are all about getting teams tuned up for the regular season, and generally about nothing else, coaches on both sides prefer to keep the games at a more useful 11-on-11.

Fly in too hard or recklessly on a tackle? Players generally aren’t hurting their teams if the referee takes action. Exact a little retribution against a player with whom there is history? Why not? They are likely to get away with it sans any punitive action.

What is the answer? MLS should be slightly more proactive in issuing suspensions that carry into the season. Or perhaps issue a two-match suspension for upcoming preseason contests.That would get players attention, at least, as they would hate being left behind when teammates were getting ahead on fitness and match sharpness.

  1. pensfan603 - Feb 24, 2013 at 3:35 PM

    Ill be honest i kind of like it, You dont think DC vs Philly wll be more intense because of this?

    • Steve Davis - Feb 24, 2013 at 4:40 PM

      I get it … but you don’t want players getting hurt because some guys knows that he get away with whatever. Sooner or later, there is bound to be an injury that matters because of of these games gets out of hand.

  2. tjromanello - Feb 24, 2013 at 6:56 PM

    Here’s a thought…get rid of preseason games altogether. They are professional athletes, they should be prepared already.

    • mesheke - Feb 24, 2013 at 7:44 PM

      preseason games are less about getting fit than allowing coaches the chance to see not only who will be in the starting line-up, but also your 30 man roster.

      Practices just do not have the same intensity as a game does, coming from a player who played way better than he practiced in college.

  3. unclemosesgreen - Feb 25, 2013 at 10:21 AM

    Here’s an idea – whistle them the same as you whistle an in-season game. And then do what Uncle Stevey said – and have suspensions that begin in the regular season. Losing game checks gets the immediate and undivided attention of players.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

Premier League, Week 3 review