Skip to content

Nobody is really worried about Mikael Silvestre … Right?

Mar 4, 2013, 2:32 PM EDT

New York Red Bulls v Portland Timbers Getty Images

The Portland Timbers could become a poor man’s Barcelona for all we know. They could intimidate clubs with high pressure, flummox with passing that’s quick and intricate, and score goals in numbers only dreamed about over the first two seasons at Jeld-Wen.

But if the Timbers 2.0 cannot staunch the flow of defensive boo-boos, no amount of fancy-schmancy when in possession will matter.

And it certainly won’t matter if the club’s new high-priced veteran defender Mikael Silvestre cannot get his personal roses in a bunch along the back line in the Rose City.

I’ll get out on the limb here and say it: the 35-year-old Frenchman will be fine. (Well, so long as this, along with the inexorable sands of time, do not become quickly toxic to the man’s confidence. It shouldn’t.)

He had a bad moment on that unwise back pass against New York on Sunday. Later, the ball that got by on New York’s second goal was likely as simple as unfamiliarity with a surface on which Silvestre has almost no experience.

Not saying he’s blameless, just saying the good will eventually top the bad here.

I could be wrong, of course … but that means two coaches are wrong, too. Timbers coach Caleb Porter clearly believes in the guy. Sigi Schmid told me three weeks ago in Arizona that Silvestre could clearly defend effectively in MLS.

And this piece from Stumptown Footy makes the case as well. Geoff Gibson talks Timbers fans off the ledge on this one. A quick excerpt, on how Silvestre rebounded nicely in the second 45 minutes.

We saw it in the second half. Silvestre, for all his woes in the first half, was a completely different player in the second. He marked his men. He made daring tackles when needed. It wasn’t perfect, but it was a far better performance. We saw it in the preseason as well when Silvestre was very capable of marking and tackling MLS forwards.”

Clearly, a tiring bunch from New York, guided by the older likes of Tim Cahill, Juninho and Thierry Henry, was causing far fewer problems. Still, there was occasional work to be done, and the Timbers back line dealt with problems that needing dealing with.

  1. spikenyc - Mar 4, 2013 at 4:08 PM

    I would fault Ricketts more for the first goal. Why would he try to pick it up? It wasn’t the best pass and Silvestre took his eye off the ball right before contact, but c’mon, you got to just clear that.

    • Steve Davis - Mar 4, 2013 at 4:28 PM

      You’re certainly onto something here … I would LOVE to know what kind of information is being communicated from Ricketts to the DFs at that moment. “Away! Away!” goes a long way, you know? Or, yes, if he’s presenting himself as an option, that needs to be communicated clearly and then executed correctly. All that said … Silvestre has enough skins on the wall to know the best option there, which is somewhere in the 15th row.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

Premier League, Week 3 review