Skip to content

Does Houston coach Dominic Kinnear have a point about diving in MLS?

Mar 18, 2013, 9:28 AM EDT

Seattle Sounders v Portland Timbers Getty Images

Being a referee really is an impossible assignment in some ways.

To call too many fouls is to incur the wrath of half the players and coaches, the set who believe in a more physical match.

But don’t whistle enough of them and we get what Major League Soccer long ego devolved into, an overly physical league full of muscle and tussle – incurring the wrath of players and coaches who prefer a slightly more technical game. Lots of fans, too, though surely not all of them.

So it really comes down to balance.

And that is the starting point for conversations on Dominic Kinnear’s rant on Sunday, aimed most pointedly at FC Dallas striker Kenny Cooper, but also at those who dive and “cheat” around the league, according to the long-serving Houston Dynamo coach.

It’s a tricky balance, indeed.

A few years ago, MLS officials at the time believed that the scourge of diving and the slightly lesser offense of exaggerating or embellishing contact was the bigger issue. So Joe Machnik, head of MLS officials at the time, moved referees toward calling fewer fouls, reckoning that the game would “flow.” (He even cited a reduction in fouls called as evidence of better officiating.)

Of course, that’s not what happens. The referee whistle may blow fewer times – but the game tends to flow about as much as a clogged toilet. Players take the temperature and keep turning up the physical heat until they are made to do otherwise. The result is a mad circus of body checks, kicks and hacks, creating a game of turnovers that quickly gets hard on the eyes.

So, yes, it’s always about balance. It’s about hitting the sweet spot. It’s a contact sport, after all – but tackling and defending must always be about timing, skill, precision and just enough aggressiveness. It shouldn’t be tackle by collision.

Achieving that balance is not easy, but Kinnear has a point about more aggressive oversight on diving from Major League Soccer’s disciplinary committee.

The committee can and has issued punishments for diving. A little more of that certainly could not hurt, putting those who fall and feign in greater danger of something punitive.

That wouldn’t stop the stuff (which Kinnear calls a recent “epidemic”), but it couldn’t hurt.

Latest Posts
  1. PST’s Major League Soccer Power Rankings – The Benefit of Mid-Week Edition

    Aug 22, 2014, 2:13 AM EDT

    joao_plata AP

    LA’s loss is RSL’s gain at the top of our pecking order.

  2. Torres in, Hernández and Jiménez out for Mexico matches against Chile, Bolivia

    Aug 21, 2014, 11:00 PM EDT

    LOS ANGELES, CA - MAY 3: Erick Torres #9 of Chivas USA celebrates after scoring a goal against the Houston Dynamo on May 3, 2014 at StubHub Center in Los Angeles, California. Getty Images

    “Cubo” gets his first call from Miguel Herrera, while two established names stay in Europe.

  3. WATCH: Roberto Martínez talks Arsenal challenge, Ross Barkley injury

    Aug 21, 2014, 10:16 PM EDT

    Martinez AP

    Everton will get answers this weekend against Arsenal, while it’s still too soon to tell when Barkley will return.

  4. Vancouver sends Nigel Reo-Coker to Chivas USA for Mauro Rosales

    Aug 21, 2014, 9:26 PM EDT

    mauro_rosales Getty Images

    Something for nothing? Vancouver swaps a spare part for one of the league’s more prolific assist men.

  5. Howard and Donovan comparisons can only go so far

    Aug 21, 2014, 6:42 PM EDT

    United States v Canada Getty Images

    They’re both stars, both taking elective leave from their national team. That’s where the similarities end between Donovan and Howard.

  6. Howard’s international sabbatical means opportunity for Guzan, Johnson and Hamid

    Aug 21, 2014, 5:22 PM EDT

    FBL-ENG-PR-EVERTON-NEWCASTLE Getty Images

    A new starter will have his chance to stake his claim, while another player will get more looks in camp with the third keeper’s role.

  7. Tim Howard taking a break from U.S. international duty

    Aug 21, 2014, 4:09 PM EDT

    Brazil Soccer WCup US Germany AP

    The 35-year-old is taking a step back, making himself unavailable for selection until Sept. 2015.

  8. LMA describe Malkay Mackay texts as ‘banter’ as online apology issued

    Aug 21, 2014, 3:19 PM EDT

    Cardiff City v Southampton - Premier League Getty Images

    LMA statement: “These were two text messages sent in private at a time Malky felt under great pressure and when he was letting off steam to a friend during some friendly text message banter.”

  9. Queens Park Rangers sign Chilean international Eduardo Vargas on loan

    Aug 21, 2014, 2:40 PM EDT

    SSC Napoli v PAOK - Preseason Friendly Getty Images

    Exciting attacker arrives at Loftus Road for the 2014-15 season.

  10. Luis Suarez not included in Uruguay’s squad for upcoming friendlies

    Aug 21, 2014, 1:51 PM EDT

    Uruguay's Luis Suarez kicks the ball during the group D World Cup soccer match against Italy at the Arena das Dunas in Natal, Brazil, Tuesday, June 24, 2014. Uruguay defeated Italy 1-0. (AP Photo/Ricardo Mazalan) AP

    Despite being eligible to play for his country, Suarez left off Uruguay’s roster.

  11. Sami Khedira rejects new contract at Real Madrid, alerts Arsenal, Chelsea

    Aug 21, 2014, 12:44 PM EDT

    sami_khedira Getty Images

    Khedira turns down new deal at Real. Will the Spaniards cash in on him now?

  12. Report: Xabi Alonso heading to Manchester United

    Aug 21, 2014, 11:55 AM EDT

    Spain v France - UEFA EURO 2012 Quarter Final Getty Images

    Former Liverpool star could be heading to United as Real Madrid seek to trim squad.

  13. Tottenham eye Champions League spot via Europa League title

    Aug 21, 2014, 11:16 AM EDT

    Mauricio Pochettino AP

    Spurs boss in dramatic U-turn on Europa League after previously dismissing tournament.

  14. Influential CEO Tim Leiweke to leave Toronto FC, MLSE

    Aug 21, 2014, 10:46 AM EDT

    Tim Leiweke, seen here at the announcement of the NBA's 2015 All-Star Game in Toronto, has taken two steps toward reversing the exodus out of BMO Field. (Source: AP.) AP

    Leiweke to leave MLSE, as leading sports executive calls it quits in Toronto.

  15. VIDEO: Watch LA Galaxy launch astonishing comeback, beat Colorado 4-3

    Aug 21, 2014, 10:05 AM EDT

    landon_donovan Getty Images

    After trailing 3-1, LA came roaring back to win 4-3 as Donovan bagged the winner.

  16. Angel Di Maria wants to leave Real Madrid, rejects new contract

    Aug 21, 2014, 9:25 AM EDT

    angel_di_maria Getty Images

    Di Maria wants out of Real, will Manchester United be able to pounce for his signature?

  17. Crystal Palace’s Sporting Director Iain Moody resigns after text scandal

    Aug 21, 2014, 8:54 AM EDT

    West Ham United v Crystal Palace - Premier League Getty Images

    Moody, pictured center, has resigned from his role at Palace following damaging allegations.

  18. Mario Balotelli edging closer to shock $26 million Liverpool switch

    Aug 21, 2014, 8:20 AM EDT

    Balotelli Getty Images

    Liverpool, AC Milan agree Balotelli transfer as player, agent set to arrive at Anfield.

  19. Thursday’s Transfer Rumor Roundup: Tiote to Arsenal, Destro to Chelsea

    Aug 21, 2014, 7:30 AM EDT

    Italy Soccer Serie A AP

    Monster moves rumored. Check out all the latest gossip, right here.

  20. Angel Di Maria gets love from Ronaldo, Sergio Ramos and Diego Simeone

    Aug 20, 2014, 11:15 PM EDT

    Portugal Soccer Champions League Final AP

    Both Ronaldo and Ramos have gone to Madrid president Florentino Perez to ask him to keep Di Maria.

Featured video

Top five PL goals, Week 1