Skip to content

Is Luis Suarez a victim? Brendan Rodgers thinks so

Apr 25, 2013, 1:35 PM EDT

Britain Soccer Premier League AP

Liverpool manager Brendan Rodgers insists that Luis Suarez has been victimized by the 10 match ban handed down by the FA and that “the punishment has been made against the man and not the incident.”

Since Suarez’ now infamous bite on Chelsea’s Branislav Ivanovic during last Sunday’s 2-2 draw, the Uruguayan was charged with violent conduct and handed a 10 match ban by an independent disciplinary panel. Liverpool, who have still not received the full report, have until Friday afternoon to appeal the decision.

In the meantime, Brendan Rodgers stepped forward to discuss the incident. “It is the severity of the ban that has hurt most,” said Rodgers. “That is something we are bitterly disappointed with – not so much the ban because everyone has seen it and Luis was very open and honest to know it was wrong.

“You can only compare it with similar incidents we’ve had. There have been two similar incidents both in 2006. One player [Tottenham's Jermain Defoe] received no ban and has continued to be picked by the FA for the England team. The other player [defender Sean Hessey, who was charged for biting in a game between Chester City and Stockport County in 2006] received a five-game ban. So when Luis receives a 10-game ban it’s hard to understand.

“I honestly believe the punishment has been made against the man and not the incident.”

While it may be tough to grasp the logic behind Rodgers’ defense of Suarez, it’s hardly surprising that the manager has chosen to stand behind the Uruguayan. This is what Brendan Rodgers does, at least when it comes to his star player. Whether he’d do the same for Martin Skrtel or Jose Enrique remains to be seen.

Rodgers had Suarez’ back throughout both of the player’s prior incidents this season. When Suarez was repeatedly accused of diving (and exacerbated those accusations by celebrating his goal against Everton with a dive in front of David Moyes), Rodgers had his back. When Suarez handled the ball prior to scoring Liverpool’s winner in the FA Cup third round tie at Mansfield, Rodgers defended him.

In truth, it’s exactly what any good manager should do for his player, so long as it’s justified. In the context of diving and handball accusations, it was big of Rodgers to step up and defend the Uruguayan when the rest of the world was out to get him. But when it comes to the biting incident, Rodgers’ defense of Suarez is questionable and his assertion that the player is a victim is borderline asinine.

The claim that the “punishment has been made against the man and not the incident” evidences Rodgers’ misunderstanding of basic principles of justice. In any court system in the world, prior incidents are always factored in when determining punishment. You simply cannot consider punishment for an incident without understanding the man behind the incident.

In a criminal context, multiple violations always results in an extended sentence. Even in many a civil context, liability is easier to prove for repeat offenders. For example, in the context of a dog bite (which feels appropriate when discussing Suarez) a plaintiff in the U.S. must prove negligence of the owner so long as no prior bite has been proven. However, if the owner has been previously found liable for his dog biting someone, a plaintiff merely need to prove strict liability – a much lower and easier threshold to meet than negligence. In other words, history matters.

So was this a punishment made against the man? Absolutely. And rightfully so.

In fact, the 10 match ban seems quite fair when considering Suarez’ bite history. When the striker bit the collarbone of PSV Eindhoven midfielder Otman Bakkal in 2010, the Dutch Football Federation handed him a seven match ban. Logically, this punishment provided the FA with the floor for the potential ban. Anything below that number would have made a mockery of the FA while anything over 10 matches would have seemed egregious given the chomp didn’t cause actual injury to Ivanovic.

For all the criticism the FA has received this season, they got this incident right. One hopes that, in time, Brendan Rodgers will arrive at this understanding.

Latest Posts
  1. It’s me again! Vincent Tan calls out Malky Mackay

    Sep 30, 2014, 11:43 PM EDT

    Cardiff City v Liverpool - Premier League Getty Images

    Are you as tired of Vincent Tan as Cardiff City supporters are?

  2. Mats Hummels says his future is at Dortmund

    Sep 30, 2014, 10:50 PM EDT

    FBL-GER-BUNDESLIGA-DORTMUND-BRAUNSCHWEIG Getty Images

    The German defender was courted by Manchester United and Real Madrid, but says he is at Dortmund for the long-run.

  3. UEFA Champions League preview: Liverpool face Basel, Arsenal defend the Emirates

    Sep 30, 2014, 9:45 PM EDT

    Paris Saint-Germain v FC Barcelona - UEFA Champions League Getty Images

    Wednesday features eight Champions League matches, including important matchups for Premier League sides Arsenal and Liverpool.

  4. Xabi Alonso breaks Bundesliga record for touches

    Sep 30, 2014, 8:56 PM EDT

    FC Bayern Munchen v Manchester City FC - UEFA Champions League Getty Images

    The newly signed Bayern midfielder had 204 touches in Munich’s 2-0 win over FC Koln.

  5. Norway calls up 15-year-old for Euro qualifying

    Sep 30, 2014, 8:03 PM EDT

    FBL-NOR-OEDEGAARD Getty Images

    Martin Odegaard made his international debut this summer as Norway’s youngest player ever.

  6. Why do Manchester City struggle so much in the Champions League?

    Sep 30, 2014, 7:27 PM EDT

    FBL-EUR-C1-MAN CITY-ROMA AP

    With City struggling in the group stages once again, why does this keep happening?

  7. PHOTOS: David Beckham, Beyonce, Jay-Z among stars at PSG vs. Barcelona

    Sep 30, 2014, 7:00 PM EDT

    Stars on show: Beyonce, Jay-Z, Beckham. Stars on show: Beyonce, Jay-Z, Beckham.

    All the stars were out to play as PSG took on Barca in the French capital on Tuesday.

  8. Xavi breaks record for Champions League appearances

    Sep 30, 2014, 6:30 PM EDT

    FC Barcelona v Club Leon - Joan Gamper Trophy Getty Images

    The Barcelona midfielder appeared in his 143rd Champions League match today.

  9. Kevin Mirallas could miss serious time for Everton

    Sep 30, 2014, 5:35 PM EDT

    Liverpool v Everton - Premier League Getty Images

    The Belgian international was taken off the pitch on a stretcher this weekend with an apparent hamstring injury.

  10. UEFA Champions League roundup: PSG beat Barcelona, Chelsea top Sporting

    Sep 30, 2014, 5:15 PM EDT

    FBL-EUR-C1-PSG-BARCELONA AP

    Want a recap of all eight UCL games that took place across Europe on Tuesday? Look no further…

  11. Sporting CP 0-1 Chelsea: Blues win chippy UCL affair in Lisbon

    Sep 30, 2014, 4:36 PM EDT

    Chelsea dominated Sporting and should have won by more. AP

    Only Nemanja Matic, much to the chagrin of the Sporting crowd, could beat a fantastic Rui Patricio.

  12. Golden oldie: Francesco Totti becomes oldest scorer in Champions League history

    Sep 30, 2014, 3:37 PM EDT

    AS Roma Team Presentation Getty Images

    Magnifico from Totti, as Italian legend writes his name in the history books.

  13. Follow live – UEFA Champions League: Manchester City vs. AS Roma

    Sep 30, 2014, 2:18 PM EDT

    Will Yaya Toure and City get off to a winning start at St. James' on Sunday? Getty Images

    Moscow was skunked by Roma 5-1 in the first round of group matches, while City fell 1-0 to Bayern.

  14. Premier League Team of the Week: Find out who starred on Matchday 6

    Sep 30, 2014, 2:11 PM EDT

    Sunderland v Swansea City - Premier League Getty Images

    Check out if your favorite player made it onto Round 6’s Team of the Week.

  15. UCL: Bayern Munich picks up win over CSKA Moscow in empty Arena Khimki

    Sep 30, 2014, 1:58 PM EDT

    APTOPIX Russia Soccer Champions League AP

    Mario Gotze drew a penalty that Thomas Muller finished, and Bayern Munich emerged victorious from a relatively-quiet stadium.

  16. PST’s Major League Soccer power rankings: More movement, just not No.1

    Sep 30, 2014, 12:31 PM EDT

    oscar_pareja AP

    The Los Angeles Galaxy are really, really good, while Chivas USA is across town and the PR table.

Featured video

Week 6: Premier League recap