Skip to content

More MLS salary talk: Three teams collecting bad deals

May 7, 2013, 1:50 PM EST

Houston Dynamo v Chicago Fire - Knockout Round Getty Images

Salary Day around Major League Soccer – let’s find a mainstream sports parallel. Because that’s how these things work, right? Some esoteric event with limited significance that winds up fans and sends them spinning on kitchen floors. The only way to convey its meaning is by looking to the big four. I know how this works.

Let see …It’s the 5×5 rotisserie draft, right? No, not quite right. The salaries are real. Fantasy leagues aren’t. How about the cover announcement for your given EA Sports franchise? Meh, way too far from the field. Really, it’s more like pitchers and catchers reporting, or final cut day for NFL rosters. It has some significance, but if we never heard one peep about it, our sporting lives would change … not at all.

Perhaps the best parallel is Schedule Day in the National Football League. Most of the information is known ahead of time – MLS’s deals either already leaked or carry over from the year before, while the NFL’s matchups are predetermined by a formula – but something about seeing all the details together sends fans buzzing like their favorite band just released another album (and since this is MLS, that album would either be Wilco’s or the dialog track from an Arrested Development rerun). The order of the games, Monday night slots, Thanksgiving assignments – they give football fans something to fill that offseason void. It’s the morning donut – fun, harmless, inconsequentially unless you overindulge.

For MLS fans, the players union’s release sparks a few hours of fervent social media analysis, where “Broncos play Cowboys on Thanksgiving” is replaced by “this sure looks different without Beckham and Marquez.” That Week 17 matchup between Green Bay and Minnesota? Where Adrian Peterson might be going for 2,105 and a playoff spot? That’s MLS fans and their value-for-money finds. “So Rafael Baca only makes $49,500 but Joel Lindpere’s still a $200,000 player?”

[MORE: Major League Soccer’s top earners]

He does, but in insolation, that’s mostly trivia. One good or bad signing isn’t going to break a salary cap, especially when the maximum most players can count against the salary cap is limited by the designated player rule. If, however, you start collecting a bunch of Baca-esque deals? They you’ve really got something. The dollar shaved here, shaved there give you the ability to take some chances, overpay for a project, or take on some players whose veteran rates no longer fit into others’ budgets. You don’t have to be Billy Beane to figure this out.

We’ll look at some of those situations later. Here I want to look at the other end of the spectrum – teams who have a number of deals which, while perhaps not bad in isolation (though there are some there), become problematic when they’re part of a greater pattern.

Some caveats here: Some of these deals might be Designated Player contracts, young designated players, Generation adidas, or another of an array of circumstances that means their full salaries may not count against the cap (or, are even being fully covered by their current team). Still, in a league were very few teams are making money, taking on even “off book” salaries can have a huge effect on a team’s ability to go out and acquire more talent.

[MORE: Some Major League Soccer bargains]

With that in mind, here are a few situations you’d like to see your team avoid:

(all salary figures reflect guaranteed compensation)

source:  Chicago Fire

  • Sherjill MacDonald, $527,125
  • Arne Friedrich, $367,500
  • Dily Duka, $273,000
  • Patrick Nyarko, $249,500
  • Joel Lindpere, $205,000
  • Logan Pause, $197,833.33

Also:

  • Alvaro Fernandez, on six-month loan in Qatar, $366,666.67

Again, in isolation, none of these deals are killers, but when you have six players making above-or-around $200,000 who aren’t giving equivalent production, that’s a symptom as much as it is a problem, especially since Duka and Lindpere were added this winter (as were Jeff Larentowicz and Maicon Santos, who combine to make just over $395,000).

Friedrich can’t stay healthy. Duka cost Chicago Dominic Oduro. Nyarko is immensely capable but has 12 goals in five-plus seasons. We have to start considering if Lindpere’s best days are permanently gone, while Pause was made redundant by the Fire’s offseason moves.

Between those six players, that’s just over $1.8 million in salaries. And Fernandez’s loan expires this summer.

source:  Colorado Rapids

  • Marvell Wynne, $285,000
  • Edson Buddle, $275,000
  • Drew Moor, $247,000
  • Pablo Mastroeni, $200,000
  • Atiba Harris, $173,275
  • Danny Mwanga, $171,250
  • Brian Mullan, $170,335

The four guys who were in Commerce City last year – Wynne, Moor, Mastroeni, and Mullan – are just kind of overpaid. Really, it’s not a big deal when you’re being shrew elsewhere. When you’re getting value lower down the list, you can be sentimental with your veterans – understood.

But Buddle? Harris? Mwanga? Colorado went out and got these guys this offseason. You can see the upside in each of them, but having combined for two goals through the Rapids’ first 10 games, you have to wonder if that $600,000 would have been better spent elsewhere.

Consider some of the other goal scorers that moved this offseason: Ryan Johnson ($144,705), Claudio Bieler ($200,000), Fabian Espindola ($150,000), Robert Earnshaw ($155,150). Buddle, Harris, and Mwanga, for similar money, were much less reliable options. Even Kenny Cooper ($342,500) could have been had for some of the money Colorado spent on their upgrades.

source:  D.C. United

  • Dejan Jakovic, $303,341
  • Rafael, $284,625
  • Brandon MacDonald, $273,250
  • Lionard Pajoy, $205,000
  • John Thorrington, $150,000
  • James Riley, $145,000

The disturbing part about this group is that they were all need signings, to one extent or another. On one hand, yeah, when a team needs somebody, of course the sign a new player, yet with this group, we see a tendency to overpay when addressing those needs. That’s a systemic problem.

A couple of years ago, D.C. United’s defense was terrible. They elected to keep an expensive Jakovic and acquire MacDonald. They now have one of the priciest central pairings in the league, even if few would call the duo one of the league’s best.

Pajoy and Rafael were brought in because D.C. United needed strikers, but each make more than Maicon Santos will earn from Chicago this year. Pajoy didn’t cut it in Philadelphia before being traded, and Rafael (a young designated player) had only scored one, circumstantially meaningless goal in Brazilian national league play (all of his production was in the quasi-competitive state league). Through 213 minutes in D.C., his only MLS tally came off a Andy Greunebaum misread.

Thorrington and Riley aren’t super expensive, but they fit the same pattern. D.C. has a need, they spend more than they probably needed to, and the upgrade isn’t obvious. Thorrington’s fitness concerns mean it’s too early to pass judgment on his acquisition, but did D.C. really need James Riley at $145,000 when they already had Chris Korb, Daniel Woolard, and Robbie Russell?

Latest Posts
  1. Garry Monk labels Jonjo Shelvey “lazy,” issues Swansea midfielder a final warning

    Dec 28, 2014, 10:00 PM EST

    Swansea City v Southampton - Premier League Swansea City v Southampton - Premier League

    Jonjo Shelvey is apparently “lazy” and lacks focus on the field, and Garry Monk is tired of it.

  2. VIDEO — Ronald Koeman: Southampton “passed the test” in draw with Chelsea

    Dec 28, 2014, 8:00 PM EST

    A point against Chelsea was nice, but Southampton have passed a much bigger test of late.

  3. VIDEO: Manuel Pellegrini, Louis van Gaal feel two games in 48 hours had negative impact on their teams

    Dec 28, 2014, 7:30 PM EST

    Manchester City v Burnley - Premier League Manchester City v Burnley - Premier League

    Two games in 48 hours — too much and managers/players have a point, or not a big deal and they should stop whining?

  4. Premier League Preview: Liverpool vs. Swansea City

    Dec 28, 2014, 6:00 PM EST

    Swansea City v Liverpool - Premier League Swansea City v Liverpool - Premier League

    In the last Premier League game of 2014, Liverpool host Swansea.

  5. VIDEO: Harry Redknapp jokes he’d like QPR to sign Sergio Aguero, gets no laughs

    Dec 28, 2014, 4:40 PM EST

    Queens Park Rangers v Crystal Palace - Premier League Queens Park Rangers v Crystal Palace - Premier League

    Harry wants Aguero, presumably because he’s already signed every other player in the world.

  6. Premier League roundup: Chelsea, Man City stumble as Arsenal makes up ground

    Dec 28, 2014, 2:28 PM EST

    Britain Soccer Premier League AP

    The final heavy match day in the Premier League for 2014 had goals, ejections, upsets and disallowed scores.

  7. Newcastle United 3-2 Everton: Thriller at St. James Park sees Magpies hold on

    Dec 28, 2014, 1:12 PM EST

    Newcastle United v Everton - Premier League Getty Images

    Newcastle moved back above Everton and into 10th place on the table with 23 points. The Toffees are in 12th with 21.

  8. QPR players, Tony Fernandes react to Air Asia flight QZ8501’s disappearance

    Dec 28, 2014, 12:28 PM EST

    Tony Fernandes AP

    The entire R’s family has joined the world in hoping for the best, as 162 people are missing.

  9. Jose Mourinho claims there’s a “campaign” against Chelsea after Fabregas diving furor

    Dec 28, 2014, 12:19 PM EST

    Mourinho claims Chelsea are being victimized for simulation, as Fabregas denied penalty kick.

  10. Hull City 0-1 Leicester City: Foxes earn first win since September

    Dec 28, 2014, 12:11 PM EST

    Leicester Getty Images

    They’re still bottom of the table, but not by much anymore.

  11. Aston Villa 0-0 Sunderland: Black Cats fail to break down 10-man hosts

    Dec 28, 2014, 12:09 PM EST

    359944e7cc1c143e989791f8b92f8068 Getty Images

    The point Sunderland pulls four points clear of the drop zone, while Aston Villa is a point above the Black Cats.

  12. Manchester City 2-2 Burnley: Brave Burnley battles back behind Boyd, Barnes

    Dec 28, 2014, 12:03 PM EST

    Manchester City v Burnley - Premier League Getty Images

    City remains three points back of Chelsea, and now sit 7 points ahead of No. 3 Manchester United.

  13. QPR 0-0 Crystal Palace: Rangers wasteful in unimaginative affair

    Dec 28, 2014, 11:59 AM EST

    QPRCP Getty Images

    There was little for fans to latch onto at Loftus Road, and it appropriately ended goalless.

  14. Three things we learned from Chelsea’s draw vs. Southampton

    Dec 28, 2014, 11:59 AM EST

    What stood out from the clash at St Mary’s? Here’s three things.

  15. Stoke City 2-0 West Brom: Hosts capitalize on chances with Diouf brace

    Dec 28, 2014, 11:55 AM EST

    Diouf Getty Images

    One quality goal from the Stoke forward plus one lucky one meant West Brom slumped to yet another defeat.

Featured video

JPW's top five PL moments of 2014