Skip to content

Silverware or stability? Would winning the FA Cup or staying in the Premier League be better for Wigan?

May 10, 2013, 10:13 PM EDT

FBL-ENG-FACUP-WIGAN-TRAINING Getty Images

Wigan face a very real “would you rather” scenario Saturday and in the coming weeks as the FA Cup final looms and the Barclays Premier League season comes to a close:

Would you rather feel the glory of winning the FA Cup and bring home silverware, at the expense of relegation from Premier League? Or would you prefer to forgo winning the Cup if it meant the guarantee of playing in the top flight again next season?

It is a decision that no doubt weighs on Roberto Martinez’s mind as he prepares for the coming matches – Wigan turn around to play their penultimate Premier League game on Tuesday, currently sitting in 18th place and the favorites to be sent down. But first, he must traverse the FA Cup final against Manchester City at noon ET Saturday.

Is stability and accumulated wealth what is valued by a club the most? The relative riches the Premier League brings with TV deals and the like are certain to draw any sensible front office.

Or is soccer ultimately about trophies and unforgettable moments that fans and players alike will never forget?

Take Fulham for instance. Poll enough fans at Craven Cottage – or even Clint Dempsey – and many are sure to list off a number of things they would sacrifice to have beaten Atletico Madrid at the end of their improbable Europa League run a few years back. For sure a few would have included their Premier League status in that group. Dempsey’s unbelievable chip goal to beat Juventus is still one of the greatest goals in club history, but the job was left unfinished, unresolved, forever lost to time.

Or flip the coin and ask a Portsmouth supporter if they’d still not want the club’s financial nightmares wiped clean in exchange for their 2010 FA Cup victory. Pompey have just this year been relegated yet again, down to League Two, the lowest professional division in English soccer – the old Fourth Division – after falling into administration for the second time in two years. The club came a whisker from folding altogether, unable to pay player wages. Would erasing years of heartache be worth a piece of silverware?

The choice is simple: short-term glory, or another shot at long-term stability? There’s no guarantee that even by avoiding relegation this season that they wouldn’t be sent down in the near future. But there’s also no telling when Wigan will come this close to obtaining a trophy – the ultimate prize of the sport.

One thing is for certain come this FA Cup final – Wigan are in the Europa League next season no matter the outcome, as their opponent Manchester City have already been booked into the Champions League.

Roberto Martinez has a chance to cement his name in Wigan lore. Just how he chooses to attack the history books remains a highly debatable question.

Would you prefer a trophy at the cost of relegation of your club? Or do you believe remaining in England’s top division should be the top priority?

Latest Posts
  1. Premier League Preview: Chelsea vs. Sunderland

    May 22, 2015, 4:40 PM EDT

    Britain Soccer Premier League AP

    Preview of Chelsea-Sunderland match on Championship Sunday, available to watch on NBCSN beginning at 10 a.m. ET.

  2. Americans Abroad preview: Guzan benched, Friedel could make farewell appearance

    May 22, 2015, 3:54 PM EDT

    Colchester United v Tottenham Hotspur - Pre Season Friendly Getty Images

    As usual, several Americans are ready to take the pitch in Europe this weekend.

  3. Premier League Preview: Newcastle United vs. West Ham United

    May 22, 2015, 3:20 PM EDT

    Newcastle United v West Bromwich Albion - Premier League Getty Images

    If the Magpies win they will survive on the final day. Watch them host West Ham live on USA, online via Live Extra, 10 a.m. ET.

  4. Report: Bad-boy Dani Osvaldo linked with move to New York Red Bulls

    May 22, 2015, 2:52 PM EDT

    Dani Osvaldo, Inter Milan Dani Osvaldo, Inter Milan

    Are the Red Bulls willing to take a risk on Osvaldo to bolster their attacking options?

  5. Premier League Preview: Hull City vs. Manchester United

    May 22, 2015, 2:08 PM EDT

    Tottenham Hotspur v Hull City - Premier League Getty Images

    Can the Tigers pull off a “great escape” on the final day? Watch live on NBC at 10 a.m. ET on Sunday.

  6. Louis van Gaal believes David De Gea will stay at Manchester United

    May 22, 2015, 1:20 PM EDT

    Liverpool v Manchester United - Premier League Getty Images

    The Red Devils boss is confident DDG will be around next season.

  7. TV SCHEDULE: Premier League finale – 10 games, 10 channels on Championship Sunday

    May 22, 2015, 12:40 PM EDT

    CFnp4ZXUMAEF99h

    Here’s how and where to watch every PL game on the final day of the season.

  8. Geoff Cameron takes us behind-the-scenes at Stoke City

    May 22, 2015, 11:15 AM EDT

    Geoff is finishing the season strong and is working on his upper-body. Geoff is finishing the season strong and is working on his upper-body.

    In his latest blog, our man in the PL gives us a glimpse of what life is like at Stoke’s training ground.

  9. MLS gossip: Del Piero, Cisse, De Rossi all linked with moves to the US

    May 22, 2015, 10:30 AM EDT

    UEFA Champions League Final - AC Milan v Liverpool Getty Images

    It’s that time of year again ladies and gents. Get ready for the rumors regarding European veterans heading to MLS.

  10. David Luiz hits out, dismisses reports of him being a “virgin”

    May 22, 2015, 9:56 AM EDT

    FBL-FRA-LIGUE1-LIGUE2-UNFP-AWARDS FBL-FRA-LIGUE1-LIGUE2-UNFP-AWARDS

    The Brazilian defender wants to put the record straight. David, over to you…

  11. Jose Mourinho, Eden Hazard win Premier League Manager, Player of the Year awards

    May 22, 2015, 9:00 AM EDT

    After already winning two trophies this season, Chelsea cleaned up once again.

  12. Brendan Rodgers insists Raheem Sterling will remain at Liverpool

    May 22, 2015, 8:20 AM EDT

    Liverpool Training Session Liverpool Training Session

    After Sterling’s agent says his client will not sign a new deal at Liverpool, Reds boss is adamant he will remain at Anfield.

  13. MLS preview: Sounders vs. Sporting KC, Revs vs. D.C. United headline Week 12

    May 22, 2015, 7:45 AM EDT

    Dom Dwyer, Sporting Kansas City Dom Dwyer, Sporting Kansas City

    The MLS weekend is upon, and that means just one thing, Americans: It’s time to support your domestic league.

  14. Agent: Rafa Bentiez “would be truly happy” to manage Real Madrid

    May 22, 2015, 12:02 AM EDT

    Rafael Benitez, SSC Napoli Rafael Benitez, SSC Napoli

    Firing one of the world’s elite managers, so you can hire a good-but-not-great replacement? Not smart, Real Madrid, not smart at all.

  15. Scholes: If De Gea leaves, Manchester United should sign Petr Cech

    May 21, 2015, 10:57 PM EDT

    Petr Cech, Chelsea FC Getty Images

    According to Scholes, the solution to Man United’s goalkeeping problem is a no-brainer.

  16. Emmanuel Adebayor given compassionate leave after revealing suicidal thoughts

    May 21, 2015, 9:47 PM EDT

    Emmanuel Adebayor, Tottenham Hotspur FC Emmanuel Adebayor, Tottenham Hotspur FC

    Well done to Tottenham Hotspur for showing the necessary compassion and taking care of one of their own.

  17. US Open Cup draw: Sounders-Timbers, NYCFC-NY Cosmos highlight possible 4th-round clashes

    May 21, 2015, 8:24 PM EDT

    US Open Cup trophy Getty Images

    The draw for the 4th round of the 2015 US Open Cup tossed up a couple of absolute doozies on Thursday night.

  18. Hodgson: England very happy to take Jack Grealish from Ireland, if he so chooses

    May 21, 2015, 7:23 PM EDT

    Jack Grealish, Aston Villa FC Jack Grealish, Aston Villa FC

    Jack Grealish has a big decision to make in the not-so-distant future, and it’s going to affect the course of the rest of his career.

  19. War of words: Henry, Giroud trading jabs over Thierry’s “dull” punditry comments

    May 21, 2015, 5:29 PM EDT

    Olivier Giroud, Arsenal FC Olivier Giroud, Arsenal FC

    Thierry Henry is riding Olivier Giroud very hard these days, claiming Arsenal will never win a PL title with him leading the line.

  20. Poland federation president calls for Russia to be stripped of 2018 World Cup

    May 21, 2015, 3:25 PM EDT

    ZbigniewBoniek Getty Images

    Qatar isn’t the only World Cup host to make others upset.

Featured video

PST Extra: Relegation drama on final day