Skip to content

Manchester City fans let their voices be heard: Mancini, not Pellegrini

May 11, 2013, 12:51 PM EST

Manchester City v Wigan Athletic - FA Cup Final Getty Images

Just after Abide With Me was done, the anthem was finished, and the FA Cup Final had kicked off, the 31,000 Manchester City fans occupying the club’s section at Wembley let their voice be heard. Their targets were Friday reports that Roberto Mancini, who had managed City to their second FA Cup Final in three years, would be replaced after the season with Málaga’s Manuel Pellegrini. And suffice to say, a sentimental and appreciative fan base attached to the man who has delivered a Premier League title was none too thrilled with those reports.

We went into the case for the change earlier today. As was the case at Inter Milan, Mancini’s success at City requires some context. While he’s taken the club to unprecedented heights, he’s not the only man who could get the job done. Most would say the financial backing of Sheikh Mansour’s group mandates more.

Tell that to City fans, for many of whom memories of lower division soccer are still fresh in the mind. As expressed by Saturday’s songs, there’s little desire among supporters for the club to turn their back on man who has brought results in the name of a hypothetical upgrade:

So if you’re Sheikh Mansour and his family, what do you do? The supporters made their feelings known loud and clear. At the same time, they’re not the first fan base to develop sentiment for a coach. Should Liverpool bring Rafa Benítez back just because the Kop overlooks the Reds’ Benítez-orchestrated dive out of Champions League? Definitely not.

These are the difficult decisions for ownership – how to balance the club of the present against the club you want to build. When a team’s yet to accomplish anything, it’s easy to let ambition win out, but when you’re working at the margins — looking to squeeze that final three or four percent out of your squad – the decisions become more difficult. Is it worth antagonizing your supporters to make a move when, playing at the extremes of European soccer, improvement might not necessarily equate to results? It all depends on what the Skeikh sees the club: Still growing, or at the point to expect results commensurate with the outlay.

Does anybody really believe City should view themselves as a still-building club?

I tend to be higher on Pellegrini than most, so I’d make the move. Where a new coach will likely have to improve on Mancini’s record to be accepted as his replacement, I think Manuel Pellegrini highly likely to do so. His Champions League record is much better, and with Pellegrini, I believe City could have challenged for this year’s Premier League title. There’s never been a point where Pellegrini’s results haven’t matched his talent, whereas with Mancini, that’s a constant question.

But with the fans voicing their opinions, City’s owners will have to be as high on Pellegrini as I am for a move to make sense. While you always want to make the right decisions over the popular ones, the uncertainty that comes with a coaching change at this level of the game is enough to justify caution.

Now if City loses today’s final (0-0 at 25′ as I write)? Then you can ignore those chants.

Latest Posts
  1. Bayern Munich down FC Köln, cruise to 11-point Bundesliga lead

    Feb 27, 2015, 5:40 PM EST

    FC Bayern Muenchen v SC Freiburg - Bundesliga Getty Images

    Bayern Munich unsurprisingly improves on their position in league competition.

  2. Americans Abroad preview: Cameron back, Bedoya questionable

    Feb 27, 2015, 4:50 PM EST

    Guzan Getty Images

    Quick look at Americans utilizing their talents overseas.

  3. Prince-Wright’s Premier League picks: Everton, Man United, Man City, Stoke

    Feb 27, 2015, 4:20 PM EST

    464041878 Getty Images

    Citizens, Red Devils and Toffees will all bag big wins this weekend, according to PST’s Editor and Lead Writer.

  4. Premier League Preview: West Ham vs. Crystal Palace

    Feb 27, 2015, 3:50 PM EST

    FBL-ENG-FACUP-CRYSTAL PALACE-LIVERPOOL Getty Images

    Preview of West Ham-Crystal Palace match airing live on NBCSN this Saturday morning.

  5. Watching a UEFA Champions League game with US star Geoff Cameron

    Feb 27, 2015, 3:16 PM EST

    Cameron admires, and has beaten, Arsenal. Cameron admires, and has beaten, Arsenal.

    In our latest with Stoke City and U.S. national team star Geoff Cameron, we sit down in his house and watch Arsenal’s clash with AS Monaco.

  6. WATCH: PST Extra previews Liverpool vs. Manchester City

    Feb 27, 2015, 2:55 PM EST

    PST Extra - Feb. 27

    The PST Extra crew dissect the key areas as Liverpool host Man City on Sunday.

  7. Premier League Preview: Manchester United vs. Sunderland

    Feb 27, 2015, 2:25 PM EST

    Swansea City v Manchester United - Premier League Getty Images

    Watch United vs. Sunderland live on NBCSN and online via Live Extra at 10 a.m. ET on Saturday.

  8. WATCH: Premier League TV schedule – Week 27

    Feb 27, 2015, 12:44 PM EST

    PremierLeagueNBC

    Where and how to watch all the Premier League games during Week 27.

  9. Sepp Blatter wants 2022 World Cup final to be played on December 18

    Feb 27, 2015, 12:01 PM EST

    Blatter: “The World Cup will not go on until the 23rd, definitely not.”

  10. Europa League last 16 draw: Everton head to Ukraine; Spanish, Italian clubs clash

    Feb 27, 2015, 10:00 AM EST

    The Toffees get a tricky test in Kiev, while Italy dominates the last 16 with five clubs.

  11. Jack Wilshere undergoes latest surgery, as Arsenal return is delayed

    Feb 27, 2015, 9:20 AM EST

    Wilshere AP

    Gunners midfielder goes under the knife once again.

  12. Report: Chelsea join Manchester United in chase for Nathaniel Clyne

    Feb 27, 2015, 7:37 AM EST

    Queens Park Rangers v Southampton - Premier League Getty Images

    Will Clyne stay at Saints or move to one of the big boys?

  13. Toronto FC unveil new primary jersey for 2015 MLS season

    Feb 26, 2015, 11:37 PM EST

    Photo credit: MLSsoccer.com Photo credit: MLSsoccer.com

    It’s red — lots of red — and “All For One.” Do you dig it?

  14. Ahead of Capital One Cup final, Thibaut Courtois admits he’s never been in a PK shootout

    Feb 26, 2015, 11:10 PM EST

    Thibaut Courtois, Chelsea FC Getty Images

    Petr Cech has been in plenty of PK shootouts for Chelsea, but Courtois has never done it.

  15. CONCACAF Champions League: D.C. United battered by Alajualense, 5-2

    Feb 26, 2015, 10:32 PM EST

    Andrew Dykstra, D.C. United Andrew Dykstra, D.C. United

    *sigh* Another MLS team gets hammered in CCL, and we’re (probably) down to one last hope.

  16. Keller, Hejduk, Conrad headline 13 new eligibles for National Soccer HOF

    Feb 26, 2015, 8:15 PM EST

    Kasey Keller & Frankie Hejduk, USMNT Kasey Keller & Frankie Hejduk, USMNT

    It’s a who’s-who of USMNT, USWNT and MLS stars who are now eligible for the U.S. Soccer HOF.

  17. World War II bomb found, defused near Borussia Dortmund stadium

    Feb 26, 2015, 6:51 PM EST

    Signal Iduna Park, Borussia Dortmund Getty Images

    A 550-pound British bomb was found near Dortmund’s stadium on Thursday. That’s a little bit crazy.