Skip to content

Roberto Mancini did himself no favors in City’s FA Cup flop

May 11, 2013, 4:54 PM EST

FBL-ENG-FACUP-MAN CITY-WIGAN Getty Images

Manchester City’s manager bears a large portion of the blame for what happened today at Wembley, and with speculation about his job hitting a fever pitch prior to kickoff against Wigan, his team’s 0-1 upset loss may be the last chapter for Roberto Mancini on City’s sidelines. On a day that started with fans chanting support, denouncing the idea of replacing him with Manuel Pellegrini, Mancini did nothing to justify their faith.

His team came out flat, as if not grasping the occasion. To a certain extent, that happened two years ago, too, when a second half goal from Yaya Touré gave City a 1-0 FA Cup final win over Stoke City. But Touré, City’s hero over the last two years, hasn’t donned the cape year, and without that kind of mistake-erasing presence, the margins were always going to be thinner. Mancini should have used the last final’s lesson as a reason to have his team primed to play.

In the face of a Wigan team already setup to exploit the City, the lack of preparedness could have sent Mancini’s side down early. With Shaun Maloney falling back onto Touré and neither Samir Nasri nor David Silva positioned to help on Wigan’s wide man, City were always going to be exploited down the flanks. Add in a lack of energy from most of the team, and fullbacks Pablo Zabaleta and Gael Clichy were always going to have trouble, especially once Wigan left wingback Roger Espinoza showed so much aggression charging up his flank. Keep more of the ball, work harder when you lose it, and yes, City could have offset the tactics. But they weren’t of the mindset to do so.

City survived until halftime, when it seemed like Mancini would make a change. With James Milner warming up during intermission, it looked like Clichy would get some help containing MacManaman, who was having his way down the right. But when Milner came on for Samir Nasri, he was deployed on the opposite flank, and while City also needed to give more consideration to Koné, Milner was cast above Zabaleta. Clichy was in serious need of help.

That Milner wasn’t in the starting lineup to begin with hints Mancini didn’t grasp the Latics’ threat. That, or though his faith in Samir Nasri, he is so intent on salvaging what’s been a poor season from his starting winger that he let the French international try to redeem himself with silverware on the line. Instead of playing Milner – his best wide defender and one player you could count on to bring the right intensity from minute one – Nasri was again given the starting nod.

The next sub, midway through the half, also displayed a degree of stubbornness. Just as he was willing to stay with Nasri despite a lackluster campaign, Mancini defaulted to his favorite tactical trick: His continued dalliance with a three-man defense. Jack Rodwell was on and Carlos Tévez, of all people, was brought off. Never mind that score was still 0-0, and never mind Tévez has the ability to take any ball sent out of the back and make it into a goal. And disregard the fact Marcini was, in moving to a scheme that’s had marginal success this year, positioning his side to start going almost like-for-like against Wigan. Tevez was still making way for Rodwell.

Given that dissonance, it’s perhaps appropriate that Rodwell was beaten for the goal, with Ben Watson cutting in front of him at the near post before flicking past Joe Hart. One of a slew of offseason signings that never worked out (along with Javi Garcia, Scott Sinclair, Maicon), it was poetic justice that the man bought on to enable the three-at-the-back dream was beaten to complete Mancini’s nightmare.

That nightmare started yesterday, when reporting in Spain linked Pellegrini with Mancini’s job. It will continue over the next seven days, with the final week of Mancini’s season sure to be dominated by news of a possible departure. With nothing to play for next week, Mancini could sleep walk through the turmoil with no effect on his squad. He could also crack, as he did before leaving Inter Milan, where at one point in 2008 he hastily announced his eventual departure, decided to stay on, and was fired three months later.

On Saturday, City played like a team overwhelmed by the gossip, but it’s a manager’s prepare a squad that isn’t derailed by tabloid headlines and boardroom shenanigans. And if the speculation about Mancini’s job wasn’t a factor in City’s performance, there are even fewer excused for why one of the world’s most expensive squads lost a major title to a relegation candidate.

Manchester City fans sang their support of Mancini during the final’s opening moments, but after a tepid display on one of the biggest stages, you wonder if they’ll change their tune. And if those fans don’t think another man could do better after watching today’s loss, will they ever concede their team’s made for more than this?

Latest Posts
  1. Everton win Europa League group, qualify for knockout round

    Nov 27, 2014, 4:09 PM EST

    Toffees seal spot in Europa League knockout rounds after terrific away day display.

  2. Five investigated, including three FIFA execs, in World Cup corruption probe

    Nov 27, 2014, 3:17 PM EST

    64th FIFA Congress 64th FIFA Congress

    Three FIFA ExCo members and German legend latest to be under the spotlight.

  3. Pele moved to “special care” unit as treatment continues

    Nov 27, 2014, 2:05 PM EST

    Edson Arantes do Nascimento, Pele AP

    Brazilian legend hospitalized for second time this month.

  4. English FA charge Dave Whelan after anti-Semitic, racist comments

    Nov 27, 2014, 1:15 PM EST

    Barnsley v Wigan Athletic - Sky Bet Championship Getty Images

    Whelan charged by FA over accusations of anti-Semitic, racist remarks.

  5. VIDEO: PST Extra examines huge top four showdowns in Premier League

    Nov 27, 2014, 10:55 AM EST

    Hull City v Tottenham Hotspur - Premier League Getty Images

    Can Spurs and Everton make a top four charge? Will Saints stun Man City?

  6. Huge blow for Arsenal as Jack Wilshere is out for three months

    Nov 27, 2014, 9:13 AM EST

    Wilshere AP

    Wilshere has surgery on left ankle, as young midfielder set for another lengthy spell on the sidelines.

  7. Bob Bradley talks Stabaek, job offers, offseason plans and more

    Nov 27, 2014, 8:51 AM EST

    Bradley, Stabaek

    Bradley opens up about his first season at Stabaek, his future in Europe and much more.

  8. USA drop five places in latest FIFA world rankings; England on the up

    Nov 27, 2014, 7:28 AM EST

    Ireland US Soccer AP

    Klinsmann’s men drop further in FIFA’s latest rankings.

  9. Arsene Wenger hails his team’s attitude, Sanogo and the path forward

    Nov 26, 2014, 10:30 PM EST

    FBL-EUR-C1-ARSENAL-ANDERLECHT-TRAINING Getty Images

    Wenger was in good spirits following his side’s victory that put an end to his two-match losing skid.

  10. Ross Barkley Divegate: Why Martinez defends him and what it means

    Nov 26, 2014, 9:50 PM EST

    Everton v West Ham United - Premier League Getty Images

    Yes, Barkley dove and yes, (news flash) Martinez is overly protective of his players.

  11. Cesc Fabregas claims he’s playing the best football of his life

    Nov 26, 2014, 8:32 PM EST

    Let's talk about Cesc... Getty Images

    “I feel that right now I am playing some of the best football of my career,” Fabregas said.

  12. Emile Heskey offers himself to Leicester City to help scoring woes

    Nov 26, 2014, 7:38 PM EST

    FBL-ENG-PR-DISCRIMINATION-HESKEY-SIN

    “It goes without saying, I’d love to come,” Heskey told BBC Radio Leicester.

  13. Franck Ribery lashes out at “politics” behind the Ballon d’Or

    Nov 26, 2014, 6:44 PM EST

    gareth_bale_franck_ribery AP

    Poor Franck. All fired up and not even on the 23-man shortlist.

  14. Despite their struggles, Liverpool’s season intact as spirit shines through

    Nov 26, 2014, 6:00 PM EST

    Can Liverpool build off this draw in Sofia? Their manager Brendan Rodgers has cause for optimism.

  15. Champions League roundup: Arsenal, Atletico Madrid through, tense elsewhere

    Nov 26, 2014, 5:21 PM EST

    All the action from the penultimate games in Groups A-D, as two teams booked their spot in the last 16.

  16. Paul Mitchell named Tottenham’s new head of recruitment

    Nov 26, 2014, 5:19 PM EST

    Paul Mitchell

    The raid on Southampton continues, as their recruiting guru heads to Spurs.

Featured video

PST Extra: Top 4 showdowns on Sunday