Skip to content

Why there’s so much difficulty understanding Mancini, Benitez’s plights

May 15, 2013, 11:57 PM EDT

Manchester City manager Mancini walks onto pitch before their English Premier League soccer match against Manchester United in Manchester Reuters

If there’s a commonality between Manchester City’s FA Cup failure and Chelsea’s Europa League success, it’s the empty, futile call to support managers who clearly not longer (or never did) fit their clubs – the appeal for stability in the wake of modest accomplishment, an argument that rest more on nostalgia than the realities of the modern soccer world.

When news broke of Roberto Mancini’s impending dismissal at City, the general reaction was surprise that a man, one year removed from winning a Premier League title, were to be let go. Manchester City needed stability, the chorus sang as Txiki Begiristain affixed the brooches. And with Rafa Benítez, the addition of another major trophy has already lead to main stream coverage’s reflections on whether the former Liverpool man has earned the permanent job at Stamford Bridge.

There’s a strange element of contrarianism in both these views, as on the surface, it seems pretty clear why both Chelsea and City would be willing to move on. Or, put another way, it’s unclear why either Mancini or Benítez would be good bets to meet their clubs’ 2013-14 ambitions, whether you judge their capabilities on current or historic results. Going back to Inter, Mancini’s results have always been those of a well-supported man who can win when things when fortune broke his way. Benítez, at both Valencia and Liverpool, proved capable of challenging for big things, but he’s so far removed from those accomplishments, it’s almost as if the current visage is completely different coach – an insecure performer unable to adapt after a crowd figures out his only trick.

The commonality between the pro-Mancini and pro-Benítez views is an inability to come to grips with modern-day soccer – a state of play in which, much to the chagrin of many who follow the game, players, managers, and executives are held to a standard commensurate with the outlay of their owners. Perhaps supporters of Benítez and Mancini see a world where absolute accomplishments are sufficient, in which case a second place Premier League finish and a Europa League trophy are good enough for any manager. But Sheikh Mansour didn’t this so much money into City to see the Citizens fail to threaten Manchester United. And Roman Abramovich’s ambitions need no explanation. Their managers will always be evaluated relative to their owners’ ambitions, and in that respect, there’s little wonder why Manuel Pellegrini will be hired by City, just as José Mourinho will rejoin Chelsea.

At some point, people who follow (and cover) Chelsea, City – or, for that matter, Real Madrid, Barcelona, Paris Saint-Germain, or any team who can keep up with the world’s other huge spenders – need to adjust their world views. When you’re spending enough to have one of the most talent teams in the world, it’s nowhere near good enough when your team doesn’t perform to that level. ‘Why didn’t you compete for the league title? Why didn’t you go better in Europe?’ If there aren’t good answers to these questions, you’re likely gone.

And rightfully so. It’s not that you need to win everything. No owner’s that naïve. But you need to have the squad performing to its capabilities. You need to have trophies taken from you, not given them away. So when City’s boardroom sees their squad never threaten Manchester United, or Abramovich sees his team fighting to stay in the top four rather than threatening for first, they can’t help but wonder: Could somebody else do better?

Pellegrini? He probably can. Mourinho? He’s proven he will.

But this isn’t about comparing managers or the tough decisions boardrooms have to make. It’s about the narratives sounding these managers. The reality is that both Benítez and Mancini, despite their accomplishments at their jobs, have failed to get their immense talent to perform commensurate with expectations. They knew the expectations doing into their jobs, and as they Eastland and Stamford Bridge, their heart of heart will know they’ve failed to meet their chairmans’ goals. And just as acutely, they’ll know other coaches with better resumes are ready to take over their jobs.

If they want, pundits can go on and on about stability and the need to give a manager time, but Pep Guardiola won Champions League in his first season at Barça. Mourinho won in his second year at Inter. Roberto Di Matteo was an interim when he won Champions League, and Jupp Heynckes is only in his second season at Bayern.

At some point, everybody needs to accept the realities of the modern world are not motivated by nostalgia. If I’m paying for a title contender and you say you can give it to me, you’re damn right you’re going to be fired if you come up short.

Latest Posts
  1. Wayne Rooney after Euro qualifying win over Lithuania: Other nations ‘frightened’ of England

    Mar 27, 2015, 8:20 PM EDT

    Scotland v England - International Friendly Getty Images

    England trounced Lithuania 4-0 in a Euro qualifier for their seventh-straight win since the World Cup, and captain Wayne Rooney likes what future lies ahead for his country.

  2. Young Mexican-American Ventura Alvarado picks USMNT over El Tri

    Mar 27, 2015, 6:42 PM EDT

    Pumas UNAM v America - Clausura 2015 Liga MX Getty Images

    22-year-old Ventura Alvarado asserts that he would like to play for USMNT in the long term.

  3. Wales manager Chris Coleman defends Gareth Bale after criticism from Real fans

    Mar 27, 2015, 6:00 PM EDT

    Wales v Cyprus - EURO 2016 Qualifier Getty Images

    Manager Chris Coleman say Gareth Bale is only focused on the Wales’ “job in hand.”

  4. Luis Suarez believes FIFA treated him like a ‘hooligan’ following bite incident

    Mar 27, 2015, 4:50 PM EDT

    FC Barcelona v Rayo Vallecano de Madrid - La Liga Getty Images

    Suarez doesn’t think he could be classified as hooligan after his biting incidents.

  5. New England Revolution’s early season struggles not hugely concerning

    Mar 27, 2015, 3:45 PM EDT

    New York Red Bulls v New England Revolution - Eastern Conference Final - Leg 2 Getty Images

    The New England Revolution have been on the losing end early in the season before.

  6. England lineup: Danny Welbeck starts; Harry Kane awaits first cap from the bench

    Mar 27, 2015, 3:00 PM EDT

    Harry Kane, England Harry Kane, England

    No first cap just yet for Kane, though he’s expected to come off the bench in the second half.

  7. U.S. U-23 MNT hammers Bosnia-Herzegovina U-23s, 5-2, in tune-up for Olympic qualifying team

    Mar 27, 2015, 1:27 PM EDT

    Jordan Morris, USMNT Getty Images

    A resounding result for the 2016 Olympics hopefuls, away from home.

  8. Mark Hughes signs contract extension with Stoke City through 2019

    Mar 27, 2015, 12:18 PM EDT

    Mark Hughes, Stoke City FC Getty Images

    Stoke City are on the verge of their first-ever top-10 finish in the Premier League, and Mark Hughes has been rewarded for his success.

  9. Juventus MF Claudio Marchisio tears ACL, will miss Champions League QF, 6-8 months

    Mar 27, 2015, 11:04 AM EDT

    Claudio Marchisio, Juventus FC Claudio Marchisio, Juventus FC

    Another bitter injury blow for Juventus, who now have just one fit, first-team central midfielder.

  10. Frank Lampard is in New York City to watch NYCFC play this weekend

    Mar 27, 2015, 10:11 AM EDT

    Frank Lampard, Manchester City FC Getty Images

    Lampard is in the Big Apple, where he’ll spend time with his future teammates and watch them play Sporting KC.

  11. Eden Hazard says Chelsea’s Champions League exit was a “blessing in disguise”

    Mar 27, 2015, 8:25 AM EDT

    Eden Hazard, Chelsea FC Getty Images

    With a six-point lead in the league (and a game in hand), do Chelsea really need a “blessing in disguise” to win this year’s Premier League title?

  12. MLS preview: FC Dallas vs. Sounders, Whitecaps vs. Timbers headline Week 4

    Mar 27, 2015, 8:03 AM EDT

    Obafemi Martins, Seattle Sounders FC Getty Images

    A star-depleted (international duty) Week 4 of MLS should still provide lots of entertainment and quality.

  13. Scholes: Gareth Bale is a “perfect fit,” could lead Manchester United back to titles

    Mar 26, 2015, 11:30 PM EDT

    Gareth Bale, Tottenham Hotspur FC Getty Images

    If punditry doesn’t work for Scholes, sign him up as Man United’s top player recruiter. At least he aims high.

  14. WATCH: Time-lapse video of San Jose Earthquakes’ Avaya Stadium construction

    Mar 26, 2015, 10:00 PM EDT

    Chicago Fire v San Jose Earthquakes Getty Images

    Watch in 90 seconds the construction of Avaya Stadium, from Day 1 to Game 1.

  15. International roundup: Neymar, Willian star as Brazil thump France, 3-1, in Paris

    Mar 26, 2015, 8:59 PM EDT

    Neymar, Brazil Neymar, Brazil

    Neymar is 23 years old, and he’s already scored 43 goals for Brazil. If that seems like a lot, it’s because it is.

  16. Report: Liverpool’s Daniel Sturridge to miss a month with hip injury

    Mar 26, 2015, 7:17 PM EDT

    Daniel Sturridge, Liverpool FC Getty Images

    Another month out for Sturridge, just when Liverpool’s top-four dreams rest on his shoulders the most.

  17. UEFA fines Malmo $110,000 for “poor pitch” in Champions League, but racism still only worth $11,000

    Mar 26, 2015, 6:54 PM EDT

    Swedbank Stadium, Malmo FF Swedbank Stadium, Malmo FF

    You couldn’t get this one anymore wrong, UEFA. 10-times worse than racism? Not OK.

  18. Hope Solo says she entered therapy during 30-day suspension from USWNT

    Mar 26, 2015, 5:54 PM EDT

    Hope Solo, USWNT Hope Solo, USWNT

    Solo said her 30-day suspension was full of therapy, apologies to her teammates and getting herself right for this summer’s World Cup.

  19. EURO 2016 preview: Qualifying resumes for England, Spain, Germany, Italy

    Mar 26, 2015, 5:04 PM EDT

    EURO 2016 EURO 2016

    This weekend’s EURO 2016 qualifiers marks the halfway point of the group stage, which means it’s do-or-die time for a few hopefuls, and some giants.

Featured video

Week 30: Headline PL moment