Skip to content

Amid allocation fun, one destination makes sense for Carlos Bocanegra’s return

Jun 30, 2013, 4:48 PM EDT

Bocanegra head shot

Get ready for some Allocation Order fun, because if Carlos Bocanegra is bound for Major League Soccer, it unlikely Toronto FC will be his final destination.

The Reds hold the first spot on the re-entry list by virtue of their league-worst finish in 2012. But for a player like Bocanegra – having ties elsewhere in the States, a history with another franchise, and likely coming home to close out his professional career – Toronto makes no sense.

It wouldn’t be surprising if Bocanegra’s situation starts to mirror Brian McBride’s, a player whose return from England came with the condition he wind up with the Chicago Fire. Toronto eventually worked out a deal, traded their pick’s rights to the Fire (for Chad Barrett and change), thus getting something out of the unfortunate situation. With Bocanegra, it could happen again.

There have, however, been whispers of an agreement between Toronto and Portland stemming back to this spring’s ill-fated Mix Diskerud pursuit. That agreement, said to be born out of the trade that sent Ryan Johnson to Portland, would have TFC pass on a player of Portland’s liking, allowing the Timbers to select the player with the number two pick acquired from Chivas USA.

Beyond that National Enquirer stuff, it’s worth asking the extent to which Bocanegra would fit with Toronto. For a TFC team that has Doneil Henry, Darren O’Dea pushed to left back, and are looking to firm up a deal for Birmingham City loanee Steven Caldwell, does a commitment to Bocanegra even make sense? Without knowing the money that’d be committed to the former Fire star, it’s impossible to say, but there may be some justification to TFC either trading or passing on the pick.

That leaves Portland at number two and Seattle at number three. With the Timbers’ central defense infirmary, it’s difficult to see them passing on Bocanegra, while Seattle may look to make room for the former UCLA man, possibly at the expense of Jhon Kennedy Hurtado.

Still, you wonder if a situation closer to home might make sense for Bocanegra, with a team that prizes its veterans looking to add a player who would help compensate for an impending loss. At this point in his career, Bocanegra may covet a chance to sacrifice a more lucrative contract in exchange for a chance to play for the LA Galaxy.

And with Omar Gonzalez iffy to be on the roster come 2014, the situation makes sense from LA’s point of view. The veteran would start to Gonzalez’s left for the remainder of this season, giving Bruce Arena a chance to move A.J. DeLaGarza out right and Sean Franklin into midfield. Come 2014, Bocanegra and A.J. DeLaGarza would be the first choices in the middle.
Would all the be worth it in exchange for, say, Michael Stephens? At this point in the season, Toronto’s getting close to a something-or-nothing situation with that pick.

It’s all speculation, but in the wake of what we saw transpire with McBride, it’s important to remember: Some players have a way of landing where they want. Bocanegra is a California guy who could be flexible to LA’s salary cap constraints, while the Galaxy are always looking for the next veteran presence that can help line the trophy cabinet.

Regardless, expect more Allocation Order fun if Carlos Bocanegra agrees to come back to Major League Soccer.

  1. talgrath - Jul 1, 2013 at 2:30 AM

    Unless the rumor about Portland and Toronto is true (I rather doubt it) I would expect that Toronto will pick him up unless someone offers them a trade; he’s too good to pass on his rights in the re-entry draft for a team which major defensive problems like Toronto.

  2. mvktr2 - Jul 1, 2013 at 3:58 AM

    No need for all the proposed movement of players put forth in the piece. Simply insert Boca and AJ/Franklin battle it out for the RB spot. That is unless one man named Arena wants to push Franklin into the midfield again (please NO) in an effort to get Donovan pushed up top (very open to this) with Keane to get the goal scoring going.

  3. overtherepermanently - Jul 1, 2013 at 4:07 AM

    Anywhere but Chivas.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

Week 4: Saturday recap