Jul 15, 2013, 3:07 AM EDT
There are a couple of degrees of suspended incredulity required to assess this one. First, you have believe the original report from The Times of London that Clint Dempsey was being shopped. If you don’t, Lyle Yorks’ words are irrelevant. If, however, you put one and two together and see a few reasons Dempsey is being shopped to other clubs, you now need to ask yourself: Would his agent, Yorks, know if Spurs were merely discussing the possibility with potential buyers?
If you think yes, Yorks’ comments to Soccer By Ives will resonate. The agent of the U.S.’s highest profile international said he’s constantly talking to Tottenham, they haven’t said anything about Dempsey being sold, so that means nothing’s happening. That’s the only possible conclusion, right?
According to the site:
“I have been in constant contact with Tottenham and they are happy with Clint and he’s happy with the club,” Lyle Yorks, Dempsey’s agent, told SBI. “He’s reporting back shortly. He’ll be back there and will be in Hong Kong (for pre-sesaon) and everything’s good.
“Things could change obviously if a team came in with a big offer, but they are not actively trying to move Dempsey. …”
“There have been no meetings and no discussions. Not with Tottenham or with any other teams about Clint,” said Yorks, who recently completed Jozy Altidore’s transfer to Sunderland. “His focus right now is returning to the team and helping them qualify for Champions League.”
I’m not saying anything Yorks tells Ives is wrong, and rumor mongering among the British press can put any contrived rumor onto a front page, but there are scenarios where The Times’ reporting could be accurate and Yorks would provide the exact same quotes. Tottenham could be sounding out clubs without wanting to unsettle Dempsey, therefore not telling Yorks. The club could have told Yorks, but publicly — be it because the player doesn’t want to move or to preserve a negotiating stance — the agent wishes to deny it. Oh perhaps Yorks has just elected to deny everything for some other reason. Regardless, his comments don’t eliminate many possibilities.
Strangely, in light of these comments, Dempsey leaving Tottenham makes more sense for the player than team, given playing time ahead of the 2014 World Cup becomes a higher priority. But Dempsey also lives in London, has small children, and would presumably want to stay close (hence part of the reason for his move to Spurs from Fulham). Would a loan back to Fulham, or maybe to West Ham United, work?
From Spurs’ point of view, though, why would you move Dempsey if he wants to stay? He’s a good, versatile depth player for a team that will be in four competitions. He’s not expensive, but he also can’t garner the type of fee that will change any of your plans. He’s a good teammate, lives locally, and keeps himself in top shape. If he’s willing to battle for playing time — if he’s not insisting on starting somewhere ahead of Brazil 2014 — why move him?
That’s another reason Yorks’ words seem weird. Not only is it unclear that Tottenham would necessarily keep him informed of every little discussion they have, but if there is anybody who should want a deal, it should be the player, not the club.
Ultimately, while Yorks’ comments could be reassuring to Dempsey fans, they should probably be read an inconsequential. They’re too many scenarios to a possible transfer to know what Yorks’ motives might be. Let alone Tottenham’s.
Mar 9, 2014, 7:34 AM EDT
Two goals from players in their Major League Soccer debuts crack our first Top 5 list.
Mar 9, 2014, 7:02 AM EDT
Will Bruin, Federico Higuaín, and Kenny Miller each scored two goals as a cagey start transformed into fireworks.
Gastón Fernández pays immediate dividends for Portland, but don’t overlook a strong night from Philadelphia
Mar 9, 2014, 6:10 AM EDT
“La Gata’s” late heroics can’t overshadow a strong start for the new-look Union.
Mar 9, 2014, 5:25 AM EDT
MLS’s best forward had a very non-best night on Saturday, with his inability to convert a late penalty kick costing his team in Carson.
Mar 9, 2014, 4:02 AM EDT
The former Canadian international drew a late penalty in the Galaxy’s loss to RSL.
Mar 9, 2014, 12:18 AM EDT
Holding serve was enough in game one under their new coach, with Dallas’s big three threat delivering against the Impact.
Mar 8, 2014, 10:18 PM EDT
They finished last year at opposite ends of the East. On Saturday, D.C. and New York both stumbled in their 2014 openers.
Mar 8, 2014, 9:34 PM EDT
After a downturn in 2013, Houston’s main attacking threat has already bagged two.
Mar 8, 2014, 8:45 PM EDT
The 35-year-old, four-time Best XI midfielder is left looking for his fourth team in three seasons.
Mar 8, 2014, 7:33 PM EDT
CONCACAF Champions League mattered, Seattle will need more time, and Sporting plays to type in MLS opener.
Mar 8, 2014, 6:20 PM EDT
On his fifth team in five years, Barrett delivered Saturday for Seattle.
Mar 8, 2014, 5:33 PM EDT
Late match chaos produced 2014′s first point of drama, with the veteran journeyman giving Seattle a perfect start.
Mar 8, 2014, 4:21 PM EDT
Bayern dominated once again, scoring six against Wolfsburg, while Schalke proved they’re still able to dominate matches by scoring four.
Mar 8, 2014, 3:59 PM EDT
Four decades of soccer in the Pacific Northwest were celebrated at CenturyLink Field.
Mar 8, 2014, 3:06 PM EDT
The Rapids finally confirm the man who guided them through the preseason would replace Óscar Pareja.
Mar 8, 2014, 2:40 PM EDT
Big wins for Man United, Chelsea and Cardiff on a stellar Saturday of PL action:
Mar 8, 2014, 2:35 PM EDT
Sporting’s title defense begins at CenturyLink Field, with MLS’s first game of the 2014 season available on NBCSN and NBC Sports Live Extra.
Mar 8, 2014, 2:27 PM EDT
Goals from Eto’o, Hazard and Ba with two hands Chelsea crucial win, as title race intensifies:
Mar 8, 2014, 1:45 PM EDT
Barca could find themselves in third place by the end of the weekend, after losing 1-0 to Valladolid.
Mar 8, 2014, 1:22 PM EDT
American forward Johannsson does it again, scores beauty to put AZ ahead:
- WATCH: Saturday’s top 5 goals in Major League Soccer 0
- MLS roundup: Houston, Vancouver sit on top of their conferences after day one 0
- Rare bad night from Robbie Keane costs LA Galaxy against Real Salt Lake 0
- Atlantic crushed: D.C. United, New York open the season with three-goal losses 2
- Stoppage time goal gives Seattle 1-0 opening day win over Sporting Kansas City (video) 10
- Premier League Roundup: Chelsea clear at the top, Manchester United click, Cardiff bag huge win 0
- Dallas Manage 3-2 Win in Season Opener Against Impact
- Dynamo Shut Out the Revs as Bruin Scores a Pair
- Argentine Melodies Illuminate Rainy Night in Portland
- LA Galaxy Gift Real Salt Lake Three Points in Season Opener
- Berhalter Gets First Win as Columbus Downs D.C. United 3-0
- Colorado Rapids - 3 Hopes and One Fear
- NYRB Don't Know What Hits Them in Emphatic 4-1 Whitecaps Win
- John Terry Rules out International Return
- Aberdeen March on in Scottish FA Cup
- 2014 MLS Season: Rebuilding The San Jose Earthquakes