Skip to content

Even solid All-Star squad comes with question marks

Jul 15, 2013, 5:58 PM EDT

DeAndre Yedlin

It’s difficult to take too many exceptions with the 20-man, game day squad Major League Soccer has named for July 31’s All-Star Game. Across all sports and all formats for these kind of exhibitions, we’re used to the type of glaring mistakes that are often the product of these exhibitions. Whether it be baseball’s bloated rosters, basketball’s former positional constraints, or football’s pure ‘who cares’ attitude toward their event, the teams that are selected often reflect the weird context that surrounds their games.

The team Peter Vermes helped select is relatively free of those types of obvious errors, which is not to say there aren’t places we can nit pick. Here’s the full game day squad, with Vermes’ seven picks in bold, Don Garber’s two commissioner’s picks in italics:

Goalkeeper: Raúl Fernández (FC Dallas), Nick Rimando (Real Salt Lake)

Defenders: Corey Ashe (Houston Dynamo), Matt Besler (Sporting Kansas City), Tony Beltran (Real Salt Lake), Aurélien Collin (Sporting Kansas City), Omar Gonzalez (LA Galaxy), DeAndre Yedlin (Seattle Sounders FC)

Midfielders: Kyle Beckerman (Real Salt Lake), Patrice Bernier (Montreal Impact), Tim Cahill (New York Red Bulls), Brad Davis (Houston Dynamo), Will Johnson (Portland Timbers), Mike Magee (Chicago Fire), Graham Zusi (Sporting Kansas City)

Forwards: Marco Di Vaio (Montreal Impact), Thierry Henry (New York Red Bulls), Robbie Keane (LA Galaxy), Camilo Sanvezzo (Vancouver Whitecaps FC), Chris Wondolowski (San Jose Earthquakes)

Some of Vermes picks address positional concerns. Others are no brainers. Ashe and Beltran were picked because the roster needed fullbacks, and while they may not be your personal favorites at the positions, it’s difficult to make a rock solid case against either veteran. In midfield, Vermes added the season’s two best holders to a holder-less roster, while it’s unclear anybody had better cases for the rest of the spots then Keane and Sanvezzo. Overall, Vermes is close to beyond reproach.

Garber’s picks are a bit weird, though. Yedlin (pictured) is a great prospect, but it’s hard justify this selection. Is the buzz around him really enough to justify giving the 20-year-old a spot in Kansas City? You could make the case he’s the third-best starting right back in Cascadia. Although it’s at a different position, Jack McInerney would have been a better choice if you’re looking for a young buzz-generator, and if you want the huge Seattle market behind the game, overlook Osvaldo Alonso’s recent absence and pick only to the league’s best players.

Cahill’s case is a bit stronger, but he still has not had an All-Star caliber season (or, season-plus, since joining Major League Soccer). While the former Everton star is a renown player, he’s not the type of star that’s going to add any glamour to the event. Somebody like Federico Higuaín may have been a better choice, if you’re looking to add an extra storyline to the game. With the Columbus star also unlikely to significantly move the needle, it might have been best to honor a veteran or go with the best player available.

Again, these are relative concerns. As far as All-Star rosters go, this one’s reasonably solid. Go through the league’s squads, and it’s difficult to find somebody whose claim for Kansas City is so compelling that their play should overwhelm the myriad other factors that go into picking this roster.

Latest Posts
  1. Brendan Rodgers takes “full responsibility” for Liverpool’s season-ending disaster

    May 24, 2015, 1:04 PM EDT

    Rodgers Getty Images

    The Liverpool manager knows he could have hurt his position today with a 6-1 thumping at the hands of Stoke City on the season’s final day.

  2. VIDEO: John Terry lifts Premier League title as Chelsea’s celebrations begin

    May 24, 2015, 1:03 PM EDT

    Chelsea v Sunderland - Premier League Getty Images

    The Blues hoist the trophy in front of their own fans in west London.

  3. ‘Exhausted’ Bruce after Hull relegation: “My future is for others to decide”

    May 24, 2015, 12:45 PM EDT

    during the Barclays Premier League match between Hull City and Manchester United at KC Stadium on May 24, 2015 in Hull, England. Getty Images

    Hull spent on Abel Hernandez and others in a relatively splashy summer, but still sink into the second tier.

  4. Newcastle’s Carver: “I want a summer where I can bring in the players I want”

    May 24, 2015, 12:36 PM EDT

    Newcastle United's Argentinian midfielder Jonas Gutierrez (R) celebrates after he scores with Newcastle United's English head coach John Carver (L) during the English Premier League football match between Newcastle United and West Ham United at St James Park, Newcastle-Upon-Tyne, north east England on May 24, 2015. Newcastle won the game 2-0 to avoid relegation. AFP PHOTO / IAN MACNICOL

RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE. NO USE WITH UNAUTHORIZED AUDIO, VIDEO, DATA, FIXTURE LISTS, CLUB/LEAGUE LOGOS OR LIVE SERVICES. ONLINE IN-MATCH USE LIMITED TO 45 IMAGES, NO VIDEO EMULATION. NO USE IN BETTING, GAMES OR SINGLE CLUB/LEAGUE/PLAYER PUBLICATIONS.        (Photo credit should read Ian MacNicol/AFP/Getty Images) Getty Images

    A resilient John Carver, buoyed by Newcastle United avoiding the drop, has reiterated his desire to lead the Premier League club.

  5. Aston Villa 0-1 Burnley: Ings ensures Clarets finish with a win

    May 24, 2015, 12:35 PM EDT

    Aston Villa v Burnley - Premier League Getty Images

    Clarets sign off with a win as Villa go into FA Cup final on the back of two-straight defeats.

  6. West Ham announce Sam Allardyce will not return as manager

    May 24, 2015, 12:27 PM EDT

    Allardyce Getty Images

    West Ham released a statement on Allardyce’s removal seconds after Sunday’s final whistle.

  7. Manchester City 2-0 Southampton: Lampard, Aguero sink Saints

    May 24, 2015, 12:24 PM EDT

    Saints must wait for Europa League spot, as Lampard signs off in style.

  8. Hull City 0-0 Manchester United: Tigers go down after squandering chances

    May 24, 2015, 12:18 PM EDT

    150524-Bruce-Hull-lose

    Tigers relegated after throwing everything at United.

  9. Everton 0-1 Tottenham Hotspur: Kane’s early goal enough as Spurs seal fifth

    May 24, 2015, 12:15 PM EDT

    LIVERPOOL, ENGLAND - MAY 24:  Harry Kane of Spurs scores his team's first goal during the Barclays Premier League match between Everton and Tottenham Hotspur at Goodison Park on May 24, 2015 in Liverpool, England.  (Photo by Chris Brunskill/Getty Images) Getty Images

    Kane nodded home an Eric Dier cross to give Spurs a lead, and Tottenham controlled possession for most of the match in holding on for all three points.

  10. Crystal Palace 1-0 Swansea City: Chamakh goal marks otherwise friendly match

    May 24, 2015, 12:08 PM EDT

    Palace Getty Images

    Marouane Chamakh netted the only goal of a relatively friendly match before injuring himself shortly after.

  11. Leicester City 5-1 Queens Park Rangers: Foxes keep tails up as R’s officially end PL tenure

    May 24, 2015, 12:05 PM EDT

    LEICESTER, ENGLAND - MAY 24: Jamie Vardy (1st L) of Leicester City celebrates scoring his team's first goal during the Barclays Premier League match between Leicester City and Queens Park Rangers at The King Power Stadium on May 24, 2015 in Leicester, England.  (Photo by Dan Mullan/Getty Images) Getty Images

    Brand new England call-up Jamie Vardy scored in the 16th minute and fellow Foxes Marc Albrighton, Leonardo Ulloa and Esteban Cambiasso also scored in a 4-1 win.

  12. Arsenal 4-1 West Brom: Walcott hat-trick marks quick Gunners start

    May 24, 2015, 12:03 PM EDT

    Walcott Getty Images

    A perfect day for Theo Walcott in his return to the starting lineup saw the Gunners confirm their third place finish.

  13. Stoke City 6-1 Liverpool: Potters pummel Reds in Gerrard’s farewell

    May 24, 2015, 11:58 AM EDT

    Potters batter Liverpool as Gerrard’s final game ends on a sour note.

  14. Newcastle United 2-0 West Ham United: Sissoko, Jonas leave nothing to chance

    May 24, 2015, 11:54 AM EDT

    Newcastle United's French midfielder Moussa Sissoko celebrates scoring the opening goal of the English Premier League football match between Newcastle United and West Ham United at St James Park, Newcastle-Upon-Tyne, north east England on May 24, 2015. AFP PHOTO / IAN MACNICOL

RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE. NO USE WITH UNAUTHORIZED AUDIO, VIDEO, DATA, FIXTURE LISTS, CLUB/LEAGUE LOGOS OR LIVE SERVICES. ONLINE IN-MATCH USE LIMITED TO 45 IMAGES, NO VIDEO EMULATION. NO USE IN BETTING, GAMES OR SINGLE CLUB/LEAGUE/PLAYER PUBLICATIONS.        (Photo credit should read Ian MacNicol/AFP/Getty Images) Getty Images

    West Ham finishes 12th with 47 points, a far cry from their lofty early season pace. In an odd twist of fate, Newcastle finishes above its rivals at Sunderland.

  15. Chelsea 3-1 Sunderland: Champion Blues come back to finish what they started at home

    May 24, 2015, 11:52 AM EDT

    Chelsea Getty Images

    The Premier League champions finished off their last three points of the season at Stamford Bridge.

  16. VIDEO: Didier Drogba carried off the field in final Chelsea appearance

    May 24, 2015, 11:35 AM EDT

    Drogba Getty Images

    Didier Drogba made his 381st and final Chelsea appearance, and the players honored him as he came off a half-hour in.

  17. VIDEO: Frank Lampard scores on his final Premier League appearance

    May 24, 2015, 11:16 AM EDT

    FBL-ENG-PR-MAN CITY-SUNDERLAND FBL-ENG-PR-MAN CITY-SUNDERLAND

    PL legend signs off in style with a goal in his final game in England’s top-flight.

  18. VIDEO: Theo Walcott’s first-half hat trick will live in Boaz Myhill’s dreams

    May 24, 2015, 11:14 AM EDT

    Arsenal's English midfielder Theo Walcott celebrates after scoring their second goal during the English Premier League football match between Arsenal and West Bromwich Albion at the Emirates Stadium in London on May 24, 2015. AFP PHOTO / JUSTIN TALLIS

RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE. NO USE WITH UNAUTHORIZED AUDIO, VIDEO, DATA, FIXTURE LISTS, CLUB/LEAGUE LOGOS OR LIVE SERVICES. ONLINE IN-MATCH USE LIMITED TO 45 IMAGES, NO VIDEO EMULATION. NO USE IN BETTING, GAMES OR SINGLE CLUB/LEAGUE/PLAYER PUBLICATIONS.        (Photo credit should read JUSTIN TALLIS/AFP/Getty Images) Getty Images

    It was a trio for Theo, as Arsenal’s speedy Englishman helped the Gunners to a big halftime lead over West Bromwich Albion.

Featured video

PST Extra: Relegation drama on final day