Skip to content

Lagerway evokes ‘Moneyball’ to explain Brandon McDonald’s acquisition

Jul 17, 2013, 8:21 PM EST

FC Dallas v DC United Getty Images

Brandon McDonald was a major part of D.C. United’s success last season, but amid the downturn at RFK this season, he lost his spot. Before this morning’s trade, the former LA Galaxy and San Jose Earthquakes defender hadn’t played a Major League Soccer game since June 15. Even on the league’s worst team, McDonald had become expendable.

That Real Salt Lake, a team sitting at the opposite end of the Supporters’ Shield standings, took a chance on McDonald was the surprise. Though RSL’s dealing with some injuries at the back (Aaron Maund, Carlos Salcedo, and Chris Schuler out), they have enough to scratch through Saturday’s visit from Sporting Kansas City without adding McDonald to the roster.

But instead of waiting that out, general manager Garth Lagerway’s giving up a third-round pick (2014) and a conditional choice (2015) for the 27-year-old.

“The basic premise of ‘Money Ball’ (sic) is that you try to acquire undervalued assets,” was Lagerway’s curious explanation for a player with a $235,000 base salary. “We’ve had a long track record of picking up pieces that other people don’t want anymore and cultivating their talents …”

That’s indisputable. Lagerway and head coach Jason Kreis consistently take other teams’ cast offs are turn then into valuable depth, with Kwame Watson-Siriboe, Lovel Palmer, Joao Plata, Ned Grabavoy, Khari Stephenson, Abdoulie Mansally and Josh Saunders all giving Kreis meaningful minutes this season. With that track record, RSL deserve the benefit of the doubt with McDonald.

How much of a benefit they deserve all comes down to length of McDonald’s contract. Because terms of the extension he signed in 2011 weren’t disclosed, we don’t know how long McDonald has left on his deal. If his contract runs beyond this season, this is a bad deal for an RSL team who will have to carry that cap hit into 2014. If, however, McDonald is in the final year of his deal, Lagerway may have decided the less than $100,000 the team owes McDonald is the best use of their remaining cap space.

If that’s the case, this does have the look of a Billy Beane-esque deadline deal, looking beyond what would otherwise be a bad contract to see the short-term benefits. And if short-term benefits are the only things RSL have to absorb from this deal, McDonald may prove more valuable than the throwaway picks it cost to get him.

  1. wyrm1 - Jul 18, 2013 at 7:09 AM

    I think it is probably a good deal for RSL. McDonald is a perfectly decent 2nd/3rd CB, albeit with a great deal of variability in his play, but was just ridiculously overpaid for what he was. He wasn’t playing for DC because they want to see what their younger players can do, so getting something for him was better then nothing (I guess).

    Also, United fans are assuming that we are paying some of his salary to get him off the team, and if that is the case, it’s even a better deal for RSL.

    I’ll miss McDonald, because for whatever his flaws, he is passionate about his team and played hard.

  2. wesbadia - Jul 18, 2013 at 9:45 AM

    Firstly, it’s been assumed by many that much of MacDonald’s salary will be eaten by DC. And let’s not forget that RSL is still sitting on a sizable pile of allocation money to buy down the salaries. I don’t think, from a financial/salary cap perspective, that this is a bad deal at all. If he flops in Sandy, RSL can turn around and loan or sell him to someone else and reap the profits over what they’re paying on his salary.

    Secondly, Maund is not injured. Salcedo is out for a week with gallbladder surgery, Schuler is still nursing that leg injury, and Waston-Siriboe will be out for the season due to surgery as well. Maund and Borchers are their only healthy CB’s, and both will probably start on Saturday against SKC. MacDonald is pure backup right now.

  3. charliej11 - Jul 18, 2013 at 2:48 PM

    The well run teams win. Oakland in first in baseball, do the Angels has 2 or 3 times the salary ?…11 games back.

  4. talgrath - Jul 18, 2013 at 2:56 PM

    If DC isn’t paying much of McDonald’s salary, this could be a case of decent/good talent that RSL overpayed for. If DC paid most of McDonald’s salary, this could be a very smart move. Really, the question is whether we see last season’s McDonald or this season’s McDonald, that won’t be evident until McDonald gets a few games under his belt at RSL.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

PST Extra: Top 4 showdowns on Sunday