Skip to content

Chris Wingert’s hit on Kei Kamara wasn’t a red card, but it should have been

Jul 21, 2013, 3:40 PM EDT

Fast forward to 0:50 of the highlights, above, and you’ll quickly catch up on the issue: Chris Wingert’s “challenge” at the five-second mark of last night’s match in Utah

I put challenge in quotes not to inflame the discussion. I just don’t have a good word for what happened. We usually describe a defender’s attempt to dispossess an opponent as a challenge, and since those are some of the few times we see players coming together from opposing directions, we’re sometimes a little bit loose with the word. Any confrontation is a challenge, a rule that works most of the time.

But Wingert’s “challenge” had little to do with the ball. True, if Ike Opara doesn’t send a pass in the general vicinity of Kei Kamara, Wingert has no license to clean out the Sporting KC attacker. But Wingert’s not even moving in the direction of the ball when he makes contact. This hit looks like a free safety lighting up a tight end who’s feeling too comfortable coming over the middle.

But what purpose does that serve in a soccer match? This might be a case of Sporting’s reputation preceding them. It’s no secret Kansas City is considered one of the most physical teams in the league, and before San Jose surged to national attention last season, a lot of the discussions we have about the Earthquakes’ style of play took place in more muted tones around Peter Vermes’ team. With Roger Espinoza and Julio Cesar gone, it would be a mistake to assume the 2013 version of Sporting KC is as willing to rely on their physicality. But that doesn’t mean their reputation has died out. nor does it mean their philosophy is inherently different.

In that vein, it’s easy to see Wingert’s body block as a message-sender: We’re the home team. We’re the league leaders. You are not going to dictate the terms of this match. So if we have to take an early yellow card to send a message, so be it. One of our guys is going clean you out, and if it happens to be the veteran who will serve his accumulation suspension for our upcoming trip to Red Bull Arena, so be it.

Nobody’s going to confirm that’s what happened (I’m barely comfortable typing it out), so that scenario will remain somewhere between interesting and paranoid. But I just can’t answer this question in a way that doesn’t feed that paranoia: How does that hit happen at the point in the match, on that ball, with that intensity if it wasn’t in somebody’s mind before the opening whistle?

The big question Kansas City fans were asking post-match: Why wasn’t that a red card? Wingert launches himself, lowers his shoulder, and catches Kamara either in the upper chest or right under the jaw. Isn’t that serious foul play by use of “excessive force”? Perhaps the Disciplinary Committee will disagree with Matthew Foerster’s interpretation.

There seems little question that it’s excessive. FIFA guidelines define that as when a “player has far exceeded the necessary use of force and is in danger of injuring his opponent.” Blindsided, running at near full speed into his man, and hit unsuspecting, Kamara easily could have been hurt. At least, injury became a greater possibility than should otherwise be acceptable during an MLS match. And given the defender’s alternative (like, don’t level a guy that’s 12 yards away from the ball’s landing point), there’s no question Wingert’s hit exceeded the necessary use of force.

Alas, you’re rarely going to see a red card in the fifth second of a match. Referees just don’t want to do it. They don’t want to define matches, and while the inexperience of Foerster (officiating his 15th MLS match) was brought up after the match, that critique is more applicable to how the game was controlled than an unwillingness to reduce a team to 10 moments after kickoff.

Teams shouldn’t be given a zone at the beginning of games to stretch the rules, but that’s the reality of it. Maybe if Kamara had been hurt, we’d be having a bigger discussion about this, but for now, players are still going to have license to send messages like Wingert’s. It could be a reckless slide tackle, a borderline denial of a goal scoring chance, or a body block like Wingert’s. It’s still a rare official who wants to truly enforce the rules while the match is so young.

  1. creek0512 - Jul 21, 2013 at 4:33 PM

    Does Wingert miss the next 2 matches, for the red card and another for yellow accumulation?

    • takethelongview - Jul 21, 2013 at 6:56 PM

      He will miss a match for yellow card accumulation (five in a season). He will miss a match for a red card. And the second yellow card (six in a season) pushes him closer to the next accumulation suspension, which I believe occurs at 8. All of it counts.

  2. kingarthur900 - Jul 21, 2013 at 6:16 PM

    What a well written post. Thoughtful, insightful, interesting description of the challenge, interesting examination of the issues posed by the incident. Good stuff. Thanks.

    • takethelongview - Jul 21, 2013 at 7:02 PM

      I concur with kingarthur. That clip, taken out of context (game’s first 8 seconds), could be used at referee clinics to illustrate the concept of excessive force. Referees are always mindful that they not become the story, but if players do something stupid, referees should not hesitate to respond accordingly. The only angle Farley missed was in Kreis’s postgame discussion regarding Wingert’s second yellow, which Kreis felt was soft. Soft it may have been, but perhaps the player had used up all his leeway with this mugging in the beginning.

      • schmittydidit - Jul 21, 2013 at 11:17 PM

        Kreis missed this. The AR game Wingert the yellow card. He clearly pats his badge after raising the flag for the foul. Also clear yellow card. The idea that you only lightly grab he player on a breakaway isn’t a yellow card is absurd.

  3. bobinkc - Jul 21, 2013 at 9:40 PM

    I will admit to being prejudiced (hence, the posting moniker). However, I have wondered aloud and on this blog as when a season-ending injury would occur due to lack of control by an officiating crew. Last night came very close IMHO. Wingert was allowed to mug Kamara and came very close to said injury.

    Unfortunately, MLS does not include concussion testing for head injuries, but RSL came close to dishing out several of those last night. The first was obviously cracking Kamara and laying him out for 2 minutes on the pitch. Another was when Collin was upended while attempting a header. Another was when Myers was upended and landed flat on his back (I’m referring to the end of the attack when his head bounced on the pitch).

    Some of the rowdier MLS players seem to have misapprehended the idea that “stout defense” is includes hurting people in the process. After watching a number of European game, the idea of terminally mugging a player with the deliberate intent to injure the opponent doesn’t seem to exist. The players seem to be more intent on skill than on hitting someone hard enough to put them out of the game.

    As far as yellow card accumulation goes, first missed game occurs at 15. After 15, the player misses a game for every second additional yellow. Don’t know about counting the red as another yellow. I’ll have to defer to an official on that point.

    • wfjackson3 - Jul 21, 2013 at 11:10 PM

      I agree with you Bob. Good luck convincing any RSL fans of that though.

    • bulldogslc - Jul 22, 2013 at 1:24 PM

      RSL fan here and I agree with you somewhat. Wingert did deserve a red card for that first challenge. No play at the ball and the sole purpose was going at Kamara. However, the ref let it get way too physical for both sides. Giving yellow cards for one team and not even calling a foul for the same offense for the other team. Way too consistent. Both teams could’ve easily been down to 9 men IMO. It was an ugly game played by the two teams that play good soccer. The referee never had control of the match.

  4. talgrath - Jul 22, 2013 at 2:33 PM

    Once again, an MLS referee misses a call; that is a downright ridiculous foul and Wingert should have been shown the red immediately, 5 seconds in or not. I hope the committee hands out something far more than a mere red, that could have put Kamara out for the season.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

MOTD: United's offensive struggles