Skip to content

In defense of the current MLS All-Star format; Don’t change a thing!

Jul 31, 2013, 7:18 PM EDT

Sporting Park

KANSAS CITY – I know that Joe Prince-Wright has advocated a return to the old East-West format. But I suspect my PST colleague has an ulterior motive.

You see, if MLS went all “back to the future” on that one, Joe would probably have a reasonable chance of landing on one of the rosters! I mean, I hear he’s not too bad.

Long story short here, I love the current format. And when Don Garber asks me for my opinion – which is almost sure to happen; I’m a little surprised he hasn’t gotten around to it already – I’ll insist that it never changes.

The first reason, as noted above, is about protecting quality. I remember the former games and how so many performers were All-Stars only in the academic sense that they had secured an invitation to participate in an All-Star event.  But they weren’t All-Stars in the more typical use of the language, in the way we see best-and-brightest types.

(MORE: MLS All-Star preview vs. AS Roma)

In truth, there were too many participants who were too far from ‘something special’ quality. True, there are more teams MLS today, all with larger rosters than before. All of that serves to increase the selection pool, which can only elevate that overall standard of All-Star.

On the other hand, I just don’t see 40 MLS men today who look and feel like the difference maker a true All-Star should be. There will be something of a dropoff between the first and second MLS teams Wednesday at Sporting Park that I would put somewhere near “noticeable.”

Otherwise, I love the way this format distinguishes itself from others, importing a big brand from overseas or Mexico to challenge a team that best represents top-shelf MLS stuff.

The East-West formats are a bit stale, but what choice do these other sports have? Major League Soccer’s chosen format exploits an opportunity the NBA, NFL, NHL and MLB simply doesn’t have. It doesn’t need changing or improving.

Moreover, by including the likes of AS Roma, Chelsea, Manchester United, etc., organizers stand a chance of adding fans to the MLS brand, supporters of the game who otherwise might not tune into league action.

Believe it: anybody who watches enough of Wednesday night’s match may or may not emerge impressed with any MLS All-Stars, and fair enough. But if they aren’t a little moved by the amazing ground just outside Kansas City, then they aren’t fans worth having. Truly, Sporting Park (pictured) is a gem – and the money spent, about $200 million, should say something about the ongoing, passionate commitment.

That has to mean something.

Latest Posts
  1. Louis van Gaal hails Jose Mourinho, beams about close relationship

    Oct 25, 2014, 8:55 AM EDT

    van-gaal-mourinho Getty Images

    Van Gaal: “He’s very special but he is very special for me because we’ve continued our relationship.”

  2. VIDEO: Brendan Rodgers concerned about Liverpool’s defensive issues

    Oct 25, 2014, 8:25 AM EDT

    Just what is going wrong at the back for Liverpool? Brendan Rodgers has a theory…

  3. WATCH: Premier League online via NBC Sports Live Extra – Week 9

    Oct 25, 2014, 7:02 AM EDT

    Live Extra

    Where and how to watch every PL game during Week 9 live online or via the app.

  4. Mauricio Pochettino says Paulinho will stay at Spurs

    Oct 24, 2014, 11:30 PM EDT

    FK Partizan v Tottenham Hotspur FC - UEFA Europa League Getty Images

    The midfielder is yet to make a Premier League start this season as rumors surfaced that he could return to Brazil on loan.

  5. Chicago Fire 2-1 Houston Dynamo: Stoppage-time winner caps off Chicago comeback (VIDEO)

    Oct 24, 2014, 10:33 PM EDT

    Daniel Paladini, Markus Holgersson Getty Images

    Chicago ended their season with a win as Florent Sinama-Pongolle tallied in stoppage time to erase Houston’s first half lead.

  6. AT THE HALF: Houston lead Chicago 1-0 off Omar Cummings header (VIDEO)

    Oct 24, 2014, 9:22 PM EDT

    Sporting Kansas City v Chicago Fire Getty Images

    You can watch the match live on NBCSN or online via Live Extra.

  7. Report: 76ers owner close to buying Crystal Palace

    Oct 24, 2014, 8:51 PM EDT

    Crystal Palace v Chelsea - Premier League Getty Images

    Neil Warnock could be answering to a new boss if American billionaire Josh Harris purchases Palace.

  8. Major League Soccer suspends referee after arrest for fraud

    Oct 24, 2014, 8:00 PM EDT

    Chicago Fire v Colorado Rapids Getty Images

    Jose Carlos Rivero was charged with two felonies earlier this month but continued to work games for the MLS.

  9. WATCH: Red Bulls sign five-year-old with rare genetic disorder

    Oct 24, 2014, 7:27 PM EDT

    DC United v New York Red Bulls - Eastern Conference Semifinals Getty Images

    The New York Red Bulls made a young girl’s dream come true as she signed a one-day contract with her favorite team.

  10. Premier League Preview: Sunderland vs. Arsenal

    Oct 24, 2014, 6:20 PM EDT

    Arsenal v Sunderland - Premier League Getty Images

    Watch the Black Cats host the Gunners at 9:45 a.m. ET online via Live Extra.

  11. Serbia awarded win but docked points after melee against Albania

    Oct 24, 2014, 5:31 PM EDT

    FBL-EURO-2016-SRB-ALB Getty Images

    UEFA handed Serbia a 3-0 win but deducted points after their match against Albania was called off due to violence.

  12. Rio Ferdinand plans to retire after this season

    Oct 24, 2014, 4:43 PM EDT

    Queens Park Rangers v Sunderland - Premier League Getty Images

    The former England captain and Manchester United legend plans to retire after his season at QPR.

  13. Premier League Preview: Swansea City vs. Leicester City

    Oct 24, 2014, 3:54 PM EDT

    Swansea City v Newcastle United - Premier League Getty Images

    Watch as Leicester City travels to Liberty Stadium tomorrow live on NBC at 12:30 p.m. ET.

  14. Juventus agrees to new deal with Premier League transfer rumor mill mainstay Paul Pogba

    Oct 24, 2014, 3:04 PM EDT

    Italy Soccer Serie A AP

    Pogba broke through with 9 goals and 10 assists across all competitions for Juventus last season and a goal and assist at the World Cup.

  15. A coach tells a fan tells a ticket rep… How soccer fans and the Red Bulls created this adorable goal video

    Oct 24, 2014, 2:26 PM EDT

    newyorkredbulls.com newyorkredbulls.com

    It’s a little dusty in here. Godspeed, Irelyn. May a cure be found in short order!

  16. Still defending racial incident, seething at bite talk, Suarez returns for Barcelona

    Oct 24, 2014, 2:01 PM EDT

    Luis Suarez, Neymar AP

    It’s going to be ugly and we’re going to shake our heads. Some will feign shock. And the whole cycle will repeat itself again at Barcelona.

  17. Prince-Wright’s Premier League picks – Manchester United, Arsenal, Liverpool

    Oct 24, 2014, 1:20 PM EDT

    DiMaria Getty Images

    Here’s how PST’s editor and lead writer sees things panning out this weekend.

  18. Americans Abroad preview: Eyes on BuLi – Green, Brooks, Johnson tested

    Oct 24, 2014, 1:00 PM EDT

    Fabian-Johnson-Borussia-Moenchengladbach-Getty-Images Getty Images

    Perhaps a respite for Tim Howard and Brad Guzan, as their clubs face lesser competition this week in Burnley and QPR, respectively.

  19. WATCH: Premier League TV schedule – Week 9

    Oct 24, 2014, 12:25 PM EDT

    PremierLeagueNBC

    Where and how to watch every game during Week 9 of the PL.

Featured video

PST Extra: Can United beat Chelsea?