Sep 16, 2013, 6:33 AM EDT
Following several controversial incidents surrounding Ashely Young in Manchester United’s 2-0 win over Crystal Palace on Saturday, the England international has been widely criticized for excessive simulation.
Midway through the first half against Palace, Young clearly dove to try and gain a penalty kick by flicking out his leg and kicking Crystal Palace midfielder Kaisho Dikgacoi before flopping to the ground. Referee John Moss didn’t hesitate in handing Young a yellow card for simulation and Young’s long-standing relationship with diving in the box had yet another exhibit to back it up.
And just minutes before half time Young and Dikgacoi were again involved in a clash, as the Palace man clumsily took down Young on what appeared to be the edge of the box. Young fell forward and despite the original contact being outside the box, Moss gave a penalty kick and sent Dikgacoi off as he was the last man.
Palace felt hard done by and rightly so. But the main storyline to come out of Old Trafford on Saturday was Young’s diving.
I was sat in the press lounge at Sunderland’s Stadium of Light on Saturday watching the United game on television with a bunch of other journalists. Several of them, including myself, turned away in disgust as Young’s dive was replayed to the billions of television viewers across the world.
But this isn’t something we haven’t seen from the 28-year-old winger before.
When Sir Alex Ferguson was in charge of United he warned Young about his tendency to go down easily — watch the incident below against Aston Villa back in 2012 which was almost identical — and now David Moyes has had to do the same following Saturday’s game.
Young’s actions are sure to divide opinion.
On one hand we have those who accept diving is part of the modern game and lambast anyone who criticizes a player for going down easily after minimal contact. Then on the other side of the coin we have those who deplore diving and see it as a disease eating away at the beautiful game.
Okay, here’s an example of my why I am with the latter school of thought. Personally, despite all of their beauty and poise on the ball, I have stopped watching Barcelona in the same fondness I once did. The constant diving, simulation and underhand tactics they deploy don’t sit well with me. I’m not saying Barca are the only team that does this, but they have one of the most talented squads in world soccer, ever, so why do top international players and teams feel the need to dive, cheat and con referees?
It’s all about that extra 1 percent advantage. If Young takes a tumble in the penalty box ten times, he will probably get a PK on two or three occasions. So he’s willing to take the risk of bring tarnished as a ‘diver’ and a ‘cheat’ as he has done, in order to help his team score goals and grab points.
How can we stop this epidemic from ruining the game we all love so much? Red cards.
A straight-red for any diving will certainly help to eradicate this despicable form of gamesmanship. You only have to look at the outlawing of the tackle from behind to see that it can work. A few years back there was suddenly a zero-tolerance policy on a dangerous tackle from behind, which saw red cards brandished readily but now that tackle is hardly seen in the modern game.
It has worked, people got the message. The same needs to happen with diving. It’s a drastic step but if players face getting sent off, just see how quick Young and others stop throwing themselves to the ground like a sack of potatoes every time a defender gets within two feet of them.
Needless to say, the simulation situation has got out of hand. Now it’s time for the officials and governing bodies to take a stance. Enough’s enough. Diving and cheating is not okay and quite frankly, I’m sick of it.
- MLS Snapshot: Real Salt Lake 2-1 Toronto FC 0
- EURO 2016 qualifying roundup: Germany back on track; Portugal beat Serbia, go top 0
- Report: Aston Villa owner Randy Lerner set to sell team to UK group 0
- MLS roundup: Whitecaps, D.C. United win late ones; FCD, Sounders in disappointing draw 1
- MLS Snapshot: FC Dallas 0-0 Seattle Sounders 0
- MLS Snapshot: Vancouver Whitecaps 2-1 Portland Timbers 2