Skip to content

Will last year’s Supporters Shield winners make this year’s MLS playoffs?

Sep 20, 2013, 9:02 PM EDT

San Jose Earthquakes v Houston Dynamo Getty Images

Major League Soccer has always tended to be unpredictable, even ranging into the completely unstable in terms of how things play out in random, inexplicable or even incalculable ways.

But as I studied some history and looked at San Jose’s chances of getting past this year’s playoff velvet ropes, even I was surprised to see how many times the reigning Supporters Shield holders have completely crashed out of post-season pursuits just one lousy year later.

Heck, a couple of clubs won Supporters Clubs and didn’t even come back – as in, they were gone completely!

D.C. United was the last to drink from this tainted cup of ignominy, winning Supporters Shield in 2007 and then falling over the cliff a year later under Tom Soehn.

San Jose won in 2005 – and then hightailed it down south to Houston.

That wasn’t as bad as in 2001, when that great Miami Fusion team (with the young likes of future U.S. internationals Nick Rimando, Pablo Mastroeni and Kyle Beckerman) claimed the shield awarded to the club with the best regular season record. Then the team folded.

Overall, six Supporters Shield winners in 17 previous seasons have failed to make the playoffs the following year.

So, what of San Jose this year? This recent, thorough piece from the Quake Rattle and Goal blog does all the heavy lifting, but I can make it simple for you: Probably not.

San Jose has five matches remaining and probably needs to go 4-1 just for a chance.

It’s a tall order. It gets tougher if Chris Wondolowski and Co. cannot get at least a point at RSL this weekend – and that is a tough point to chase, especially considering RSL is coming off a poor night, and manager Jason Kreis is sure to have his team at full rev. After that, the Earthquakes’ schedule isn’t bad, with three of the last four checking the box under “potentially winnable contests.”

Still, there’s just so little room for error. Considering that San Jose is in eighth place, three spots out of playoff grace, I think we’ll be adding No. 8 to the list of Shield winners that couldn’t get there a year later.

Latest Posts
  1. Premier League Preview: Chelsea vs. Leicester City

    Aug 23, 2014, 1:09 AM EDT

    cesc_fabregas Getty Images

    The Blues are heavy favorites to stay perfect through two rounds.

  2. WATCH: José Mourinho discusses virtues of light early schedule

    Aug 23, 2014, 12:41 AM EDT

    Jose Mourinho AP

    With one game per week, Chelsea’s players have a chance to settle into their roles.

  3. MLS Snapshot: FC Dallas 2-1 Real Salt Lake

    Aug 23, 2014, 12:05 AM EDT

    fabian_castillo Getty Images

    Two goals while playing with 10 send Dallas joint-top of the Western Conference.

  4. WATCH: Previewing the Premier League’s six-match Saturday

    Aug 22, 2014, 9:51 PM EDT

    Roberto Martínez has exceeded early expectations at Everton, his "transition period" seeing the Toffees drop just one of their first 15 league games. (Source: Getty Images.) Getty Images

    The league’s second round kicks off at Villa Park and ends with the main event on Merseyside.

  5. Cristiano Ronaldo threw some punch-like thing at Diego Godín

    Aug 22, 2014, 9:12 PM EDT

    cristiano_ronaldo AP

    List of things Cristiano Ronaldo can’t do: Throw a proper punch.

  6. WATCH LIVE: FC Dallas and Real Salt Lake kick off MLS weekend

    Aug 22, 2014, 8:20 PM EDT

    Matt Hedges, Olmes Garcia AP

    Dallas is undefeated since May, while RSL has a chance to temporarily move clear atop the Western Conference.

  7. MLS Weekend Preview: Trio of marque marquee matches begins Friday in Frisco

    Aug 22, 2014, 7:17 PM EDT

    fabian_castillo Getty Images

    Dallas versus Real Salt Lake, Sporting hosting D.C. see the conferences’ best go head-to-head.

  8. Early Mandzukic goal sees Atlético defeat Real Madrid, claim Spanish Super Cup

    Aug 22, 2014, 6:50 PM EDT

    mario_mandzukic Getty Images

    Early Mandzukic goal gives Atlético its fifth trophy under Simeone.

  9. Top five storylines heading into Week 2 of the Premier League

    Aug 22, 2014, 5:10 PM EDT

    Howard rushed off his line to great effect in the first half to thwart Arsenal's offense. Getty Images

    Toffees and Gunners clash, Liverpool head to Man City, London derby time and much more.

  10. Robben dominance, Malanda miss give Bayern opening match win over Wolfsburg

    Aug 22, 2014, 4:59 PM EDT

    arjen_robben AP

    Goal, assist from Dutch star helped deliver Bayern three points to open the Bundesliga season.

  11. Premier League Preview: Aston Villa vs. Newcastle United

    Aug 22, 2014, 4:03 PM EDT

    Andreas Weimann AP

    Can Villa continue their good start to the season? Watch live, Saturday 7:45 a.m. ET on NBCSN.

  12. Report: Stoke City seeks European loan for Brek Shea; Many interested

    Aug 22, 2014, 3:17 PM EDT

    Burton Albion v Stoke City - Pre Season Friendly Getty Images

    Birmingham City, 1860 Munich, Millwall, Nurnberg… it seems Brek Shea is a man in demand when it comes to his loan from Stoke City.

  13. Bundesliga season preview, predictions: Bayern on top? Sure, but then who?

    Aug 22, 2014, 2:48 PM EDT

    Germany Soccer Cup AP

    The Bavarians added Robert Lewandowski, and look poised to lead again. Who are the favorites to emerge in the race for second?

  14. Prindi’s Premier League Picks: United to get it right, Arsenal to stumble

    Aug 22, 2014, 2:29 PM EDT

    Ryan Giggs, Louis van Gaal AP

    Matchweek 2 brings a few killer games including Everton v. Arsenal on Saturday and Manchester City v. Liverpool on Monday.

  15. Profile: The life and times of Mario Balotelli

    Aug 22, 2014, 2:20 PM EDT

    Italian forward Mario Balotelli celebrat

    From the early days in Italy, to the craziness of Man City and then back to AC Milan, here’s the timeline of Balotelli’s life so far.

  16. Julian Green gets bench nod for Bundesliga opener, could make league debut

    Aug 22, 2014, 2:03 PM EDT

    Bayern Munich's Julian Green fights for the ball with Al-Merrikh's Ramadan Ajab during their friendly soccer match in Doha Reuters

    The 19-year-old American attacker’s only senior appearance for Bayern was a Champions League sub. That could change today.

  17. La Liga season preview, predictions: Can anyone outlast Real Madrid?

    Aug 22, 2014, 1:31 PM EDT

    Cristiano Ronaldo AP

    Probably not, but with Sevilla and Barcelona strengthening while Atletico deals with roster tumult, look for some changes near the top.

  18. PSV enlists water cannons in next-level ALS Challenge (video)

    Aug 22, 2014, 12:46 PM EDT

    Screen Shot 2014-08-22 at 12.40.31 PM

    PSV Eindhoven called the police, upping the ante on the ALS Ice Bucket Challenge.

  19. WATCH: Premier League TV schedule – Week 2

    Aug 22, 2014, 12:33 PM EDT

    PremierLeagueNBC

    Where and how to watch every single PL game in Week 2, right here.

  20. Friday transfer rumor roundup: Manchester Utd mid search, Remy a Spur?

    Aug 22, 2014, 11:57 AM EDT

    1408716222483_wps_1_CRICIUMA_BRAZIL_AUGUST_9_ Getty Images

    A young Brazilian is the newest name linked with Louis van Gaal, while Manchester City could be selling a top young defender

Featured video

Week 2: Saturday PL preview