Skip to content

Romelu Lukaku situation shows need for Premier League concussion policy

Sep 26, 2013, 4:30 PM EDT

After Romelu Lukaku scored the winning goal in Everton’s 3-2 win over West Ham, he admitted he could not remember anything about the play.

“Nothing,” he said. “I didn’t even know that I scored. … I didn’t remember what happened for a couple of seconds, and then I woke up, and they said I scored.”

If Lukaku was unconscious, that makes the decision to put him back on the field that much more irresponsible. Everton had used all three of its substitutes at the time of his injury, and taking him off would have meant playing a man down with a slim lead in the dying minutes away from home.

The 2013-14 Premier League Handbook outlines the thinnest definition of a head injury policy:

Any Player, whether engaged in a League Match, any other match or in training, who having sustained a head injury leaves the field of play, shall not be allowed to resume playing or training (as the case may be) until he has been examined by a medical practitioner and declared fit to do so.

That’s all there is to it: No definition of “medical practitioner” or clarification of what constitutes an examination or what it means to be “declared fit.” Athletic trainers and physiotherapists have some level of understand of concussions, but their knowledge doesn’t run as deep as a medical doctor’s, and an examination on the side of a field in a noisy stadium is not the same as a thorough evaluation in a quiet room.

This is one aspect that Major League Soccer gets right. Every club puts its players through baseline testing before the season begins, and even after they are symptom-free following a head injury, they have to see a neuropsychologist for more strenuous testing before being allowed to return to any activity, let alone full training.

The current MLS concussion protocol came into effect in 2011, and baseline testing began to be a routine measure in 2007.

As for Lukaku, not only did he finish the match against West Ham on Saturday, but he also played 90 minutes in a 2-1 League Cup loss to Fulham on Tuesday. Had he suffered another blow to the head in those approximately 95 minutes or in training between the original injury and the (now extended) time until he makes a full recovery, the situation would only get worse.

Coming back too early from a concussion can have long-term cognitive effects in adults, and it is downright deadly for children. Just ask Taylor Twellman, the outspoken ESPN analyst and former New England Revolution forward whose promising career was cut short by concussion-related symptoms.

The Premier League’s 54-word, one-sentence policy on head injuries is simply not enough.

Latest Posts
  1. League Cup preview: Five all-Premier League ties await in third round

    Sep 22, 2014, 2:15 PM EDT

    Arsenal v Southampton - Premier League Getty Images

    Gunners and Saints clash, as the third round of the League Cup takes place this week.

  2. FIFA Executive: “The 2022 World Cup in Qatar will not happen”

    Sep 22, 2014, 1:38 PM EDT

    Theo Zwanziger AP

    Zwanziger: “Medics say they cannot accept responsibility with a World Cup taking place under these conditions.”

  3. VIDEO: Men In Blazers analyze the many faces of Louis van Gaal

    Sep 22, 2014, 1:10 PM EDT

    Men In Blazers - Sept. 22

    Joining the NBC Sports crew from the crap part of SoHo, the MiB break down van Gaal’s topsy-turvy day.

  4. Criminal? FIFA’s report into alleged 2018, 2022 World Cup corruption not public

    Sep 22, 2014, 12:30 PM EDT

    Sepp Blatter AP

    A report documenting FIFA’s internal investigation into alleged World Cup bidding corruption will not be published.

  5. Arsenal defender Mathieu Debuchy out for three months

    Sep 22, 2014, 11:28 AM EDT

    Debuchy Getty Images

    Gunners defensive woes compounded as Debuchy will be out for over three months.

  6. Premier League Playback: Legendary Lampard strikes, United’s shambolic implosion

    Sep 22, 2014, 10:30 AM EDT

    Lampard Getty Images

    PST’s Lead Writer and Editor takes an in-depth look at the incredible storylines from the PL during Week 5.

  7. Men in Blazers podcast: A Night of 1,000 Stars

    Sep 22, 2014, 9:40 AM EDT

    IMG_9209_edit_facebook

    Rog and Davo welcomed guest after guest for a very special pod.

  8. Manuel Pellegrini accuses Chelsea of being a “small team”

    Sep 22, 2014, 9:05 AM EDT

    Manchester City v Chelsea - Premier League Getty Images

    Pellegrini on City’s 1-1 draw with Chelsea: “I think we played 90 minutes against a small team trying to defend.”

  9. Report: Sami Khedira to seal $20 million Arsenal move in January

    Sep 22, 2014, 8:32 AM EDT

    sami_khedira Getty Images

    German midfielder would be exactly what Arsenal need. Will he arrive in January?

  10. Report: West Ham join QPR in chase for Toronto’s Jermaine Defoe

    Sep 22, 2014, 7:53 AM EDT

    jermain_defoe Getty Images

    Will Defoe be heading back to England at the end of the 2014 MLS season? Reports suggest its likely.

  11. MLS Sunday review: Toronto FC ease to victory against lowly Chivas USA

    Sep 22, 2014, 12:37 AM EDT

    toronto_fc AP

    Toronto FC vs. Chivas USA was the only MLS match to occur on Sunday.

  12. La Liga and Serie A roundup: Real Madrid smokes Deportivo, Juve downs Milan

    Sep 22, 2014, 12:10 AM EDT

    cristiano_ronaldo AP

    Roundup of Serie A and La Liga matches from the weekend.

  13. Manchester City’s Zabaleta believes Diego Costa luckily escaped red card

    Sep 21, 2014, 10:09 PM EDT

    manchester-city-pablo-zabaleta Getty Images

    Manchester City defender Pablo Zabaleta thinks the referee let Diego Costa off without a red card during their encounter that spurred a red card for the Argentine.

  14. Barcelona stays undefeated with 5-0 drubbing of Levante

    Sep 21, 2014, 9:07 PM EDT

    FC Barcelona v SL Benfica - UEFA Champions League Getty Images

    Barcelona beat Levante 5-0 on Sunday to continue their winning streak in all competitions.

  15. Joe Hart’s Manchester City future in limbo, Liverpool may target the goalkeeper

    Sep 21, 2014, 7:02 PM EDT

    Can England start to churn out talents such as Joe Hart from SGP on a regular basis? Getty Images

    Manchester City goalie Joe Hart confirmed that he hadn’t discussed a new contract with the club, and Liverpool is a prime candidate for his services, according to the Metro.

  16. Merseyside police to explore racist comments at Mario Balotelli

    Sep 21, 2014, 5:48 PM EDT

    hi-res-133f09d31924ea9d682e1f1a8a3ffef1_crop_north Getty Images

    More racism was thrown at Mario Balotelli, but this time, it appears law enforcement will get involved.

  17. Mesut Ozil, Danny Welbeck brandish skills in 3-0 win over Aston Villa

    Sep 21, 2014, 5:09 PM EDT

    Mesut Özil returns for Arsenal as they attempt to reclaim the top of the Premier League table with a win over Stoke. AP

    Mesut Ozil and Danny Welbeck scored and assisted each other during the Gunners 3-0 win over Aston Villa.

  18. WATCH: Alessandro Florenzi embraces grandmother in stands after goal

    Sep 21, 2014, 4:30 PM EDT

    Unknown Getty Images

    Alessandro Florenzi hugged and kissed his grandmother in the Stade Olimpico stands following his goal in AS Roma’s 2-0 victory over Cagliari.

  19. Roberto Martinez on Crystal Palace loss: ‘We didn’t have that real drive about us’

    Sep 21, 2014, 3:34 PM EDT

    Martinez AP

    Everton manager Roberto Martinez laments loss to Crystal Palace, saying that his squad lost its drive for victory.

Featured video

Week 5: Top five Premier League goals