Skip to content

Quick Six: Top stories from the Premier League weekend

Oct 28, 2013, 2:41 AM EDT

1. STUNNING ERROR COSTS MANCHESTER CITY AT CHELSEA

We know Joe Hart‘s made worse mistakes this season, a perspective that leaves us looking for other answers after happened on Sunday. That’s when, near full time at Stamford Bridge, the England international came sprinting out of his box to play a ball near the edge of his penalty area. But with his Matija Nastasic on the scene, there was no need for him to come.

True, the Serbian international should have seen Hart coming and directed his header elsewhere, but City’s keeper shouldn’t have come.  Hart should have been waiting to receive his defender’s back-pass. Instead, he abdicated his goal ahead of Fernando Torres‘s winner.

During NBC’s broadcast, Tim Howard was diplomatic about the error, placing blame on Hart but explaining it as a basic communication error that could happen to anybody. That seems too generous, perhaps a function of that implied goalkeepers’ fraternity that keeps number ones from being overly critical of each other. While that mistake could have happened to anybody, it would have been equally inexcusable from everybody, with the ability to correctly read the game in front of you a reasonable expectation of any Premier League goalkeeper.

Hart cost City a point at Stamford Bridge, giving a title rival two they would have otherwise been without. Would Costel Pantilimon have done the same? Or perhaps he would have be been worse in other areas – areas where Hart was fine on Sunday?

These are the basic questions Manuel Pellegrini needs to answer ahead of the January window, because even if he thinks Hart’s better than Pastilimon, England’s number one may not be better than another player City could get on the open market.

2. SUÁREZ STRENGTHEN’S CLAIM AS PREMIER LEAGUE’S BEST

This is why Luis Suárez‘s transgressions spur so much discussion. He’s more than a troubled soul lashing out with a forked tongue and carnivorous intent. With Gareth Bale in Spain, Suárez is in a one-man discussion as the league’s most dangerous player, possessing an unmatched ability to single-handedly turn games.

Saturday was a perfect example. The Uruguayan international embarrassed Jonas Olsson on the first goal, nutmegging the Swede before beating Boaz Myhilll. His second was a perfectly played header from near the edge of the box, a snap decision that seemed to catch the West Brom keeper off guard. The third, a perfectly flicked header off a second half restart, was more defensive error than individual brilliance, yet it still highlighted an rarely discussed part of Suárez’s arsenal. At 5’11” (perhaps a generous listing), Suárez is an underappreciated asset in the air.

He’s like Sergio Agüero, except more explosive. He’s more relentless than Robin van Persie; more consistently lethal than Wayne Rooney. Second on the circuit in goals with only four games played, he is the Premier League’s best striker, with comparisons between him, Mesut Özil, and Yaya Touré coming down to esoteric arguments about positional value.

On Saturday, Suárez showed the value of having the league’s biggest threat, the kind of tactics-defying virtue you also see from the likes of Messi, Ronaldo, and Ibrahimovic. Perhaps Suárez isn’t quite in that class, but in the Premier League, he’s in a class by himself.

3. RIVALS PROVIDE ANOTHER REPRIEVE FOR SUNDERLAND

When spring doubts about Paolo Di Canio were echoing through Wearside, the short-lived Sunderland boss got a win over Newcastle. The 3-0 victory at St. James last April not only proved vital to the Black Cats’ survival but helped temporarily consolidate Di Canio’s position. Hindsight may see that as a steep price of a year’s survival, but it illustrates the power of the Tyne-Wear Derby. One win will gloss over a slew of evils.

Gus Poyet is riding that wave today, his second half sacrifice of Adam Johnson for Fabio Borini paying off when the Italian attacker fired home a late game-winner, giving Sunderland their first win of the year (2-1 over Newcastle). Only the second goal of his Premier League career, Borini rewarded Poyet’s risky move, the new Black Cats boss electing to play Borini, Steven Fletcher and Jozy Altidore together. But having seen Johnson’s defensive error lead to Newcastle’s only goal, perhaps the former Brighton boss felt there was nothing to lose.

It’s not unlike the broader state Poyet’s inherited. If he fails, people will blame Di Canio. If he succeeds, he’ll be viewed as a savior. He has nothing to lose, and given the depths to which Sunderland has descended, the new boss may be wise to take these kind of chances.

For the kind of momentum that can be claimed in a debry? It’s certainly worth it.

4. MOYES SUMMONS FERGUSON MAGIC IN UNITED’S WIN

Last week he was the anti-Ferguson, David Moyes seeing his team allow Southampton to come back and take a point at Old Trafford. Mid-week in Champions League, Manchester United tried to reproduce that result, though Real Sociedad never played their part. Between two close matches and their former manager’s naval-gazing book tour, it was another week that reminded Red Devils fans of what once was.

That’s why Saturday’s was such a breathe of fresh air. Instead of a day that reminded fans their team’s best performances can’t put teams away, the Red Devils came back from 2-1 down, rekindling hope some of Alex Ferguson’s mentality lingers in their DNA. If the squad can still turn water into wine, there may be hope for a title push.

It goes without saying that a team of United’s talent shouldn’t have this much trouble with Stoke City, particularly at home, but all clubs have off days. Whether this was a momentary downturn or part of a larger pattern is a bigger, more murky debate, but in isolation, the result wasn’t that bad. Three points rarely is.

Coming off a mid-week match in Champions League, United had more trouble than expected at home. They needed a late comeback to salvage a performance where they didn’t look themselves. If you had a nickle for each time that description could be applied in the Ferguson era, you’d might have enough money to buy his latest book.

5. ENDS JUSTIFY THE MEANS AT NORWICH

Saturday saw a Premier League goal disallowed despite no justification from the game’s laws, yet nobody seems concerned. It was a blatant abuse of an official’s power — the game’s lead arbiter taking it upon himself to fill a gap in the rules — yet the offended manager only made a minor complaint. Letter of the law, Chris Houghton’s Norwich City should have won on Saturday, Leroy Fer‘s 94th minute shot into an empty net giving the Canaries a 1-0 win.

Thankfully, Mike Jones didn’t let that happen. Although the match’s lead official had no codified justification for his decision, the ends justified his means. WIth Cardiff City expecting the ball back after an injury saw them intentionally play the ball into touch, Jones wasn’t going to stand for Fer hitting Ricky Van Wolfswinkel‘s throw-in into David Edwards’ open net. Helping to quell a potential melee at Carrow Road, Jones simply made it so Fer’s indiscretion never happened. The throw-in was retaking with the understanding Jones would have no part in Fer’s errant passes.

Putting aside Fer’s intent, the more interesting debate centers on the man in the middle. The injury pact between teams that sees possession restored after playing into touch is an implied agreement. If one team doesn’t want to be part of it, that should be within their right. It’s rude, obnoxious, potentially dangerous and counter productive, but so is Joey Barton, and we haven’t banned him. There’s a wide range of behaviors that are both possible and allowed by the rules.

Still, if I were in Jones’s shoes, I wouldn’t have done the same thing, though I wouldn’t be certain it was the right thing to do. I would wonder if a more nefarious official would abuse that discretion. Regardless, at some point, teams should be permitted to do what’s allowed within the rules.

Yet as long teams are expected to maintain this gentleman’s agreement, it’s nice to have a few Mike Joneses around.

6. SOUTHAMPTON CONTINUES FLASHING CONTENDER’S METTLE

Last week we highlighted Arsenal’s dominance of Norwich City as a sign of their maturation. In the same light, Southampton’s control of Fulham can be seen as a meaningful benchmark of their progress, even if the result wasn’t unexpected. If Arsenal’s ability to steer clear of potential pitfalls can be lauded, Saints’ ability to put the likes of Fulham out of reach can also be seen as a sign of the staying power.

It’s one thing to motivate yourself for derbies, and if you’re a middling side, getting up to face the league’s contenders is never a problem. But having the quality to consistently transcend the reach of the league’s talented-but- lesser teams is rare. While a team like Aston Villa can occasionally take down an Arsenal, they still stumble against the league’s mere morals.

With their win, Southampton’s now unbeaten in six, winning four in that span while climbing to fifth in the Premier League. Although they also posted multiple-goal victories over Swans and Palace, those results didn’t come after Saints claimed a result at Old Trafford. After getting an unexpected point on the road, Southampton didn’t hiccup. They kept on keeping on.

By now, their loss at Norwich seems so long ago. So does their draw with Sunderland. While those blemishes to relegation candidates are alarming, they’re also from August. Since, Southampton’s moved on. And up.

Featured video

PST Extra: Can United beat Chelsea?