Skip to content

LA-RSL Man of the Match: Nat Borchers? Or Chris Schuler?

Nov 3, 2013, 11:49 PM EDT

FC Dallas v Real Salt Lake Getty Images

With Real Salt Lake making the surprise move to put two defensive midfielders in the starting lineup, central defenders Nat Borchers and Chris Schuler looked like they were going to be protected. On Sunday, they were anything but.

On a night that started with duo clearing passes across the six and ended with the pair trying to stand up to LA’s counter attack, RSL’s central tandem were constantly tested. They bent and even broke a couple of times, but come full-time, the only score of a 1-0 game wasn’t on them. They couldn’t be expected to stop Sean Franklin’s blast from well outside the penalty area.

[MORE: Franklin blast all that separates LA Galaxy, Real Salt Lake after leg one]

It’s no exaggeration to say another central pair would have conceded a couple of goals, leaving RSL with little hope ahead of Thursday’s second leg. But with players like Borchers and Schuler, Jason Kreis could afford to take some chances. That those risks didn’t come back to hurt RSL almost demands one of the team’s central defenders claim Man of the Match honors. Their performances had the greatest impacts on tonight’s result.

Schuler had some memorable moments — most notably, clearing a first half cross in the six-yard box before Landon Donovan could convert — but the pure quantity of Nat Borchers’ contributions wins him our honor. Borchers made 11 successful clearances (six more than his partner), added four interceptions, and recorded game-high three blocked shots – number that quantify the ever-present feel of his performance.

His key contribution, however, is difficult to separate from Schuler’s. As Real Salt Lake opened up late in the second half, seemingly willing to press for an equalizing goal, Borchers and Schuler found themselves isolated against a counterattack that’s been the key factor in claiming the two straight titles. Yet as Landon Donovan bore down on them and Robbie Keane tried to drag the defenders into confusion, RSL’s duo looked more comfortable than any central tandem we’ve seen try their hand against LA’s transition. No, they didn’t win every battle, but they won enough to keep LA from pulling away. They knew exactly what they wanted to do against the Galaxy’s biggest threat.

Man of the Match could go to either guy. If you thought Schuler’s great first half clearance should get some extra credit, he’ll be your guy for this honor. But on this occasion, we’re going with quantity, and as the most-prolific man cleaning up in RSL’s area, Nat Borchers wins PST’s acclaim.

  1. drewvt6 - Nov 4, 2013 at 12:45 AM

    Not sure how you can pick anyone but Donovan or Keene as MotM. Only the fact that they didn’t finish well allowed RSL to be in the game. If those guys finish this game is 4-0 or worse. They totally ran circles around the RSL defense.

    • Richard Farley - Nov 4, 2013 at 12:48 AM

      Not sure how you can pick anyone but Donovan or Keene as MotM.

      I see what you’re saving, but saying they were MotM except for their finishing (or creating better chances) seems like saying a goalkeeper should be MotM … except for their inability to prevent goals. It’s not their only job, but it’s by far and away their most important one.

      LA had two shots on goal the whole night. I can’t give it to Keane or Donovan, even if on other nights their play produces more.

  2. overtherepermanently - Nov 4, 2013 at 6:51 AM

    I can’t tell if Borchers is a fierce competitor or a first class jerk, but this guy has the most angry, condescending facial expressions you’ll ever see on an MLS pitch.

  3. drewvt6 - Nov 4, 2013 at 12:59 PM

    The rsl defense was lucky. Not good, or motm material. They were lucky that Donovan and Keene weren’t hitting on their normal accuracy because they were getting shredded time after time. If nothing choose Zardes as man of the match since he dominated his side of the field. Or choose Gonzalez, Sarvas, Juninho since they didn’t allow rsl’s high powered offensive unit even a sniff on goal till the ~80′.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

Week 3: Saturday Premier League recap