Dec 6, 2013, 3:27 AM EST
Amongst MLS’s goalkeeping elite, Jimmy Nielsen and Nick Rimando can both claim places, each veteran number ones having held major sway on the league’s last two Goalkeeper of the Year honors. In 2012, the Sporting captain snared the award, while the Real Salt Lake veteran finished second to Portland’s Donovan Ricketts this season. Over the last two seasons, these may be Major League Soccer’s two best keepers.
They are, however, very different players, a divide that starts with their stature. At 6’3″ tall, Nielsen has the traditional size of a top flight keeper, while at 5’9″, Rimando’s height is more reminiscent of an outfield player. Yet whereas you’d expect the taller man to have the greater presence coming off his line, the opposite’s actually true.
Nielsen’s earned his nickname “White Puma” for his cat-like reflexes, attributes most often displayed while the 36-year-old stays between his sticks. With defenders like Aurélien Collin and Matt Besler patrolling the box, his strategy may be influenced by his teammates, but entering the final years of his professional career, it also serves a player whose athleticism continues to wane. At his best waiting and reacting, Nielsen rarely presses his luck off his line, something that can come back to haunt him on the rare occasion one of his central defenders is beat in the air.
Rimando is surprisingly strong in the air – an attribute that’s improved throughout his career. Though his size still works against him, Rimando’s quick, decisive reads on crosses allow him to beat opposition players to the ball, his ability to read the game seeing him evade most physical challenges. Particularly on deep crosses, Rimando distinguishes himself from his peers, with his performance in the 2012 conference semifinals at Seattle standing out as one of the best games from a goalkeeper in MLS postseason history.
Rimando’s other obvious edge on Nielsen is in his distribution. Whereas the Real Salt Lake keeper is thought to be one of the best in the league putting the ball back into the field, Nielsen’s kicking game isn’t considered a strength. His play on the ball is another area where the more well-rounded Rimando makes up for his six-inch height disadvantage.
But being well-rounded doesn’t make you a better keeper any more than having a more versatile skill set automatically makes a midfielder better than a pure goalscorer. The overriding principle: How do you influence the bottom line? Rimando can be the most well-rounded goalkeeper in the world, but if he isn’t preventing more goals than Nielsen, he’s probably not the better keeper.
Though Rimando probably was the better keeper in 2013, the gap between Saturday’s keepers isn’t so big that one game’s variables couldn’t shift the scales. Particularly against an RSL team unlikely to persistently challenge with crosses (16th in MLS in crosses per game), Nielsen’s weaknesses will be masked. Likewise, Sporting’s become less apt to use their strikers as target men (13th in crosses), meaning Rimando’s unlikely to replicate last year’s performance in Seattle.
If it’s a battle of shot stoppers, Nielsen’s ability to cover more of the goal may give him the edge, but given the razor-thin nature of that advantage, you’ll forgive us a slight cop-out:
EDGE: Basically even
MORE ProSoccerTalk MLS CUP COVERAGE
- Real Salt Lake
- Sporting Kansas City
- MLS Cup general
- Inside Look, MLS Cup Playoffs: How Revs, Galaxy built very different one-goal leads 0
- Recap: LA Galaxy grab 1-0 lead over Seattle Sounders in Western Conference Championship 1
- Despite artificial turf, New York Red Bulls’ Thierry Henry says he’ll play next week at New England 1
- Recap: New England Revolution snatch 2-1 lead, two away goals from New York Red Bulls 6
- Video: Brendan Rodgers says Liverpool needs to “become a team” 1
- Crystal Palace 3-1 Liverpool: Bolasie carves up Liverpool defense 3