Skip to content

John Anthony Brooks has to “become an adult” after another early subbing at Hertha Berlin

Dec 16, 2013, 11:45 AM EDT

Austria v USA - International Friendly Getty Images

“We are in the Bundesliga. Brooks needs to grow up,” reads the translated headline from Berliner Morgenpost.

It’s been a year of tumult for German-American phenom John Anthony Brooks, particularly during his time at his Bundesliga club Hertha Berlin.

The 20-year-old Brooks, who has made two appearance for the United States this year, was removed after just 32 minutes of Hertha Berlin’s 3-2 win over Werder Bremen for not approaching the game with appropriate energy (and also, surely, for making critical errors on both Bremen goals).

It was the second time he’s been pulled early this season and his manager Jos Luhukay was not shy in his criticism, comparing him to partner in center defense, Swiss back Fabian Lustenberger:

“I don’t think he challenged one duel while he was in, Lustenberger had 15-20 – that’s not gonna work,” Luhukay said. “People are going to grow from such moments. In the Bundesliga, it’s a harsh reality. John started yet another match without enough motivation. He’s not active enough, so I have to react. He needs to shake off this youthfulness and become an adult.

“If he has character, he’ll learn. This was not the first time. He needs to learn it himself – it can only come from him. Otherwise, this won’t be the last time I pull him early.”

Brooks was also pulled after 23 minutes of an August match. Even taking into account his youth, the attitude issues will be troubling for Jurgen Klinsmann as he prepares the U.S. through 2014 and beyond.

  1. dfstell - Dec 16, 2013 at 11:56 AM

    This is why its hard to put much faith in kids. I mean, I did all manner of dumb things when I was 20 and certainly didn’t always approach my work in the most professional manner. Sometimes I did, sometimes I had bad days.

    He’ll either turn out well or he won’t. There’s nothing we can do to influence it, so it’s not worth worrying about.

    • bear06 - Dec 17, 2013 at 3:45 AM

      Yeah, it’s not surprising considering he’s still 20. He will grow from this experience.

  2. hildezero - Dec 16, 2013 at 1:10 PM

    Only 23 minutes? Damn! What the hell did he do in that game? Own goal or what?

    • bear06 - Dec 17, 2013 at 3:43 AM

      No, the manager thought he didn’t look good and wasn’t physical enough so he took him out of the game. He suffered an injury in practice before the game which is weird why the manager is being too harsh.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

PST Extra: Analyzing transfer deadline day