Skip to content

Premier League transfer window grade: Crystal Palace

Feb 2, 2014, 6:00 PM EDT

BIRMINGHAM, ENGLAND - DECEMBER 26: (L-R) Crystal Palace manager Tony Pulis and Aston Villa manager Paul Lambert talk before the Barclays Premier League match between Aston Villa and Crystal Palace at Villa Park on December 26, 2013 in Birmingham, England. BIRMINGHAM, ENGLAND - DECEMBER 26: (L-R) Crystal Palace manager Tony Pulis and Aston Villa manager Paul Lambert talk before the Barclays Premier League match between Aston Villa and Crystal Palace at Villa Park on December 26, 2013 in Birmingham, England.

Window Shopping: Tony Pulis spent two months looking at Ian Holloway’s knick-knacks and decided to clear the shelf, allowing 12 players to leave Crystal Palace by the end of the January window. Eight of those players will return in June, but for players like Kevin Phillips and Jimmy Kébé, the arrival of a new boss has meant playing time must be found elsewhere. Kébé will spend the next month searching for it through the growing muck at Leeds United, while Phillips has pulled what we like to call ‘The Kevin Phillips’ – dropping down to the Championship by joining Leicester City.

Arriving at Selhurst is a diverse collection of talent parts that should allow Pulis to craft a spot in next season’s Premier League. Tom Ince is the headliner, with the celebrated attacking midfield prospect electing to move on loan from Blackpool. Jason Puncheon provides some added scoring punch. Scott Dann may be able to rekindle his former Premier League self under Pulis, while Joe Ledley’s move away from Celtic provides another reminder of how far the Scottish league has fallen.

Even after Sunday’s loss to Arsenal, Palace is out of the drop, but there are enough parts here to provide Pulis with some needed options as he tries to avoid his first relegation. From attack to midfield, defense to goal (with former Wolves’ keeper Wayne Hennessey), Palace has bolstered. At worst, there’s now enough depth to preclude one or two injuries from derailing their survival hopes.

Players In: Jason Banton (MK Dons, return from loan), Wayne Hennessey (Wolverhampton, undisclosed), Scott Dann (Blackburn, undisclosed), Joe Ledley (Celtic, undisclosed), Jason Puncheon (Southampton, undisclosed), Tom Ince (Blackpool, loan)

Players Out: Jerome Williams (Forest Green, loan), Jason Banton (Plymouth, undisclosed), Jimmy Kébé (Leeds, loan), Alex Wynter (Sutton United, loan), Ryan Inniss (Luton, loan), Kevin Phillips (Leicester City, free), Matthew Parsons (Plymouth, undisclosed), Kwesi Appiah (Notts County, loan), Jack Hunt (Barnsley, loan), Florian Marange (Sochaux, free), Stephen Dobbie (Blackpool, loan), Jose Angel Campaña (Nürnberg, loan)

RECAP: All the deals on deadline day

Grade: B

If the new Eagles’ boss entered January hoping to make room and bolster, he accomplished both. Finding homes for 12 players, four leaving on permanent moves, Pulis has done his spring cleaning in winter, with the players being brought in all looking like useful parts.

In that way, this wasn’t just shuffling the deck. In Ince and Ledley, Pulis brought in the type of players he didn’t have at his disposal. There’s an upside to Dann that could make him a value buy (assuming that undisclosed fee is reasonably low). Puncheon provides the goals that Cameron Jerome has been unable to find, while Hennessey gives the team depth should anything happen to Julian Speroni.

It wasn’t spectacular, but Crystal Palace’s January window was eminently solid. It was the Tony Pulis of transfer windows.

 

Featured video

PST Extra: Can United beat Chelsea?