Mar 25, 2014, 4:23 PM EDT
Maybe I’m just trying to be different, because for the third week in a row, the league’s award has gone one way while ProSoccerTalk’s had gone another. Yet after taking a second look at all of Week 3′s matches, there was still (at least) one performance that was more influential than Bernardo Anor’s. Though the Columbus midfielder’s two goals in the Crew’s 2-1 win over Philadelphia garnered him the league’s honor, FC Dallas Fabian Castillo’s performance against Chivas USA earned PST’s Player of the Week.
If you boil it down to a one-on-one comparison (something that does a disservice to Anor’s teammate, Wil Trapp), the question is an easy one: Did Castillo do enough to make up for Anor’s long-distance bomb? Where each candidate scored one on a set piece, the big, broad stroke difference was Anor’s second goal. What did Castillo do to make up for that shot?
And let’s not just call it a shot, as if that fairly describes it. Anor’s was knuckling rocket from 34 yards – a shot that gave his team a valuable goal just before half time. It was a low percentage chance that came good through little effort but his own (again, we’re doing Trapp a disservice here). Instead of Columbus going into halftime up one, Anor’s blast two minutes into first half stoppage time gave Gregg Berhalter’s team the ability to sit on their lead. Ultimately, it was the game-winner.
Castillo, however, did his damage in what was probably one of the least-watched matches of the weekend. With Dallas hosting Chivas USA in a relatively late Eastern time kickoff, the Colombian attacker’s play before his 71st minute goal may have been overlooked. The fact that he was a part of of five different attacks before his goal (15′, 17′, 27′, 45+2′, 47′) didn’t come across in most highlights packages. Dallas may not have converted those chances, that wasn’t Castillo’s fault. On another day, Castillo would have had some assists to go with this opening goals.
As with any great night, Castillo had some help. With Blas Pérez dropping back from the defense, demanding Chivas’s attention, the Goats’ defense was ripe to be be beaten by Castillo and Je-Vaughn Watson’s pace. Mauro Díaz occupying the midfield’s eyes, giving Castillo all the room he wanted once he came in from the left flank. With the inexperienced Eriq Zavaleta starting in defense and midfielder Agustín Pelletieri suspended, Chivas was ready to be run over.
That’s the best argument for Anor. Whereas Castillo was doing his damage against a weakened Chivas, Anor was going up against a Philadelphia team that gave their third straight good performance. If you’re accounting for level of competition (which, of course we do), Anor has a great case.
That’s part of the reason why this week’s was the hardest decision of the season. The underlying question: Go you want the guy who scored twice, or do you want the guy who scored once and generated four or five other chances? Ultimately, we went with the latter, giving the honor to Castillo.
|PST Award||MLS Award|
|Week 1||Will Bruin, Houston Dynamo
2g, 1a vs. New England
|Nick Rimando, Real Salt Lake
8 saves, PK save at LA
|Week 2||Victor Bernardez, San Jose Earthquakes
2g, 1a vs. Real Salt Lake
|Jermain Defoe, Toronto FC
2 goals at Seattle
|Week 3||Fabian Castillo, FC Dallas
1 goal vs. Chivas USA
|Bernardo Anor, Columbus
2 goals vs. Philadelphia
- Real Madrid sign James Rodriguez for $107 million 2
- Xavi Hernández reportedly inching closer to New York City FC 10
- New report kicks off another round of Las Vegas expansion talk for MLS 5
- PST’s Major League Soccer Player of the Week: Sporting Kansas City’s Benny Feilhaber 0
- Qatar/Russia World Cup bidding investigation delayed until September 6
- Report: Bayern Munich confirms Julian Green on first team for US trip 10