Skip to content

Report: Manchester United players rumbling (again) about David Moyes

Mar 27, 2014, 5:40 PM EDT

Last season, Manchester United last three games at home en route to the Premier League title, and while few expected David Moyes to replicate the success the Red Devils experienced under Alex Ferguson, United have last four of their first 10 games at Old Trafford this season. (Photo: Getty Images) Getty Images

Wins against Olympiakos and West Ham led to a brief lull, but after Manchester City’s easy win over the Red Devils on Tuesday, the rumbling of discontent around Manchester United have resumed, with new reports out of England suggesting the management team that has steadfastly refused to reconsider David Moyes‘ appointment is ready to reevaluate their decision this summer.

Mark Ogden at The Daily Telegraph has consolidated all the misgivings. According to his reporting, concerns about conservative tactics and training that overly emphasizes shape and organization have troubled a squad that sees the methods as undermining United’s attacking potential. Whereas management previously saw those critiques as embittered complaints from United’s aging, outgoing core, seven losses in the team’s last 18 games has Ed Woodward and the Glazer family reconsidering plans. Though ownership is still inclined to let their manager continue his rebuild this summer, the final seven games of the Premier League season may determine Moyes’s fate.

From Ogden’s post:

Having grown accustomed to ball-related training under Ferguson and coaches Rene Meulensteen and Mike Phelan, there is less enthusiasm for Moyes’s preference for more structured sessions centred on team shape and organisation and concern has also been expressed about a lack of continuity in team selection – highlighted by the surprise recall of Ryan Giggs to the team against Olympiakos last week and his subsequent absence from the squad in the following games against West Ham United and City …

Exasperation has grown, however, and Moyes is regarded as having few allies in the dressing room as he approaches the final seven league games of the season. But despite the concerns within the squad, Woodward and the Glazers believe that the current problems on the pitch are proof of the need to rebuild the team this summer – a job which they are backing Moyes to undertake.

(MORE: Manchester United fans to fly “Wrong One-Moyes Out” banner over Old Trafford on Saturday)

The critiques run parallel to what many United fans have been saying since late fall. Moyes’s approach is too conservative, particularly given where talent is distributed within his squad. He still manages like somebody who needs to limit opportunities and rely on opportunism and opponents’ errors.

Under Ferguson, United seemed to create as many errors as they were given, something that made better use of one of the most talented attacks in the Premier League. It also left them better situated to manage the big games Moyes has been so woeful in contesting this season. Carrying over a lack of success that kept Everton from winning at Arsenal, Chelsea, Liverpool or United under his watch, Moyes remains unable to find ways to beat the Premier League’s top competition.

The Red Devils can wait for Moyes to get new players in, but management must also ask: How likely this leopard is to change his spots? After 14 years of management, we have a pretty clear idea of what Moyes is. After seven months of this season, we also have a better idea of what he is not. Woodward and the Glazers should get some commitment to change before they persist with their commitment to Moyes.

(MORE: Manchester United stars reach deal to buy Salford City FC)

  1. navyeoddavee9 - Mar 27, 2014 at 8:04 PM

    Moyes has always played the conservative game, it’s his DNA.

  2. Ian's Rushtache - Mar 27, 2014 at 8:20 PM

    This whole season for MU makes up for the abuse that I had to endure during the end of the Hicks/Gillette regime and into the Hodgson debacle from my friends who are MU fans. Having experienced what ir is like to see your team struggle mid table for a few years, I can only say that I wish this to continue for years to come. Sir Bully Baconface’s appointment falling on his face is the gift that keeps on giving.

  3. Jarred Alexandrov - Mar 27, 2014 at 10:33 PM

    Just fire this guy already. Doing less with more than the team who ran away with the title last season.

  4. dfstell - Mar 28, 2014 at 9:56 AM

    There is just no reason to keep the guy. The problem is blindingly obvious. Haven’t any of these Moyes defenders gotten a lousy new boss at work? You know: A boss with reasonable credentials, but nothing spectacular. Kinda annoying. Doesn’t inspire anyone on the team. Demands that you change what you’re doing even though you’re really good at your job. Tells you to do stupid things when YOU know what you’re doing and HE doesn’t.

    I mean….this happens all the time in the world. The workers don’t work for the new boss. I know there are some people who say that the workers should do whatever the boss says because the boss is the boss…..but I just assume those people are morons with no exceptional skill in their profession. Now days, the proper manager basically makes an assessment of whether his people are any good (and United’s players ARE good, perhaps not all world class, but pretty good) and then inspire them to perform. Trying to instruct Juan Mata how to play on the wing is stupid. The man isn’t a U-12 player.

  5. scrummymustard - Mar 28, 2014 at 10:54 AM

    This team could finish higher in the table if they had no coach at all.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

PST Extra: Analyzing transfer deadline day