Skip to content

Gonzalez, Keane, Marshall out, Boswell, Edu, Franklin in for MLS All-Stars

Aug 2, 2014, 4:12 PM EDT

Omar Gonzalez

Major League Soccer’s squad for Wednesday’s All-Star Game underwent a minor makeover on Saturday, with the withdrawal of three players forcing Caleb Porter to call in reinforcements. In place of Omar Gonzalez, Robbie Keane, and Chad Marshall, the Portland head coach, who will lead MLS’s stars against Bayern Munich this week, has called on Bobby Boswell, Maurice Edu, and Sean Franklin.

Though Galaxy teammate Landon Donovan is still scheduled to take part in Wednesday’s game, Gonzalez and Keane have been excluded, with Los Angeles scheduled to host the San Jose Earthquakes on Friday. Marshall, who missed Monday’s game against LA after a car accident, has also been withdrawn from the squad.

“Given the limited minutes that Omar and Robbie would need to play due to having a game on Friday and the injury to Chad, I felt we needed to bring in Sean, Bobby and Maurice to provide us with more cover in the back,” Porter said in a statement released by Major League Soccer. “This will also allow us to manage the other players’ time so everyone is ready for their matches on the weekend.”

In their first years with United, Boswell and Franklin have solidified a defense that’s helped D.C. to second in the Eastern Conference. Edu, in his first year back in MLS, has split time between defensive midfield and center back with the Philadelphia Union.

The Marshall injury couldn’t be helped, but with Gonzalez and Keane excluded because of scheduling, it’s worth asking if there were alternatives. Could MLS had done a better job of scheduling the All-Star Game? In a World Cup year, probably not. The league already pushed back the mid-season event because of Brazil 2014. With European seasons quickly approaching, this date was one of the last opportunities to play the game.

The better question is whether Porter’s replacements are the best available, but at this point, I don’t have much patience for the discussion. Boswell wasn’t the best center back missing from the roster, but who knows if players like Drew Moor, Chris Schuler, and Giancarlo Gonzalez made plans after being excluded from the initial squad. Franklin’s had a good year, but picking a left back (Justin Morrow) would have been nice. And whether Edu is being brought in as a midfielder or defender, he’s a justifiable choice, even if you don’t think he’s ideal.

I would have been fine if they named Frank Lampard. Or tried to get David Villa or Kaká to make an appearance. It’s an exhibition, it’s a showcase, and after the initial roster is named (and the non-dressed All-Stars are picked), might as well play to the spectacle.

At this point, though, bring on the game. Need to fill some spots? Let’s see who can show up. Sure, try to be fair about it, but hell, Michael Farfan was an All-Star two years ago. Boswell, Edu, and Franklin are certainly worthwhile picks, given the circumstances.

  1. tariencole - Aug 2, 2014 at 4:57 PM

    Wow. What did Dom Dwyer ever do to Caleb Porter? Robbie Keane drops out, and he STILL can’t bring in the 2nd leading goalscorer in the league?

    What. A. Joke.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

PST Extra: Will Man United miss Rooney?