Skip to content

A devil’s advocate defense of All-Star Liam Ridgewell

Aug 5, 2014, 8:08 PM EDT

MLS Rapids Timbers Soccer AP

Portland has always been high on Liam Ridgewell, but few predicted this level of success so quickly. The former West Bromwich Albion defender, out of contract just over a month ago, will be in uniform when Major League Soccer’s best face Bayern Munich on Wednesday, the Timbers defender named to replace the injured Kyle Beckerman in the league’s All-Star squad.

Don’t take that sentiment too seriously. With only three games played in MLS, Ridgewell isn’t deserving of this place, but when a player pulls out of the game less than two days before kickoff, it’s not a matter of finding the next name on the list. Can the player get there in time? Has he made other plans? Does the player even want to go?

The restrictions basically limit Porter to West Coast and Rocky Mountain call ups, but the Galaxy’s players are out, since the team plays on Friday. Same goes for San Jose, and given the state of Chivas USA’s roster, there are no obvious candidates with the Goats. Chad Marshall’s injured and Jay DeMerit’s retired, leaving the defensive best options in the Rockies, but whatever reasons kept Drew Moor and (to a lesser extent) Nat Borchers out of the team may have been a factor here, too.

The other factor: Caleb Porter may have wanted somebody who can play left back. Granted, naming a player like Toronto’s Justin Morrow to the squad would have done that, but obviously Porter didn’t see him as an All-Star. With Michael Parkhurst the only apparent option at left back, Porter may have decided to bring in some backup.

But why not Michael Harrington, who is Portland’s regular left back? Or Jack Jewsbury, a player who recently played his 300th MLS game, one capable of manning the position? Or why not Diego Chara, who would have been a like-for-like replacement for Beckerman?

I’m not going to pretend those aren’t great questions, nor am I going to pretend those players were necessarily available. Though it’s unlikely those players have major plans (given the Timbers practiced both Monday and Tuesday), they may not have been able to play. It wouldn’t be the first time somebody was unwilling to break plans to accept an emergency call up.

At some point, however, these possibilities seem thin, and once you add scenario on top of scenario that’s needed to get Ridgewell into the squad, another explanation can’t be avoided: Porter just wanted him in. As a Designated Player playing in front of home fans, one who has experience against high-level players, Ridgewell could certainly help the squad. Perhaps Porter’s competitive side got the best of him on this one.

Because ultimately, Ridgewell hasn’t proven he’s an All-Star, though, at this point of the process, how much does that matter? One day before the game, this may have been the best of limited options. If the choice came down to one of Jewsbury, Harrington, or Ridgewell — all players who’d be out-of-place in this year’s All-Star squad — is it really so wrong to take Ridgewell?

Featured video

PST Extra: Can United beat Chelsea?