Aug 19, 2014, 4:40 PM EDT
Fabián Castillo gave one of the more dominant performances we’ve seen in weeks, leading FC Dallas to a 5-0 win Saturday in Santa Clara, Calif. With a hand in each of his team’s first four goals, the 22-year-old Colombian left a San Jose team short on speed with no answers against one of the league’s fastest players. The result was two goals, one assist, and a highlight reel performance for FCD’s emerging star.
Somehow, that wasn’t enough for win the league’s Player of the Week honor. In fact, in one of the clearest indications that the award has become about box scores more than actual performance, Castillo teammate Tesho Akindele took the honor. Though Castillo was clearly the game’s best player — the focal point of a Dallas team that gave one of its best performances of the season — Akindele had three goals, none of which would have happened if Jon Busch had a better day. The San Jose keeper was slow to react to Akindele’s first, while rebounds spilled in front of goal paved the way for the rookie’s second and third.
Akindele deserves kudos from being in the right place at the right time, but as Saturday’s game at Buck Shaw unfolded, there was little doubt who was the game’s dominant player. In the 30th minute, Castillo burst from his place in attacking midfield to terrorize Jason Hernandez on a ball deflected behind the San Jose defense. The Earthquakes defender, beaten, tried to pull Castillo down, but the attacker’s strength allowed him to maintain his feet before going in alone on goal.
In the 74th minute, Castillo again did most of the work himself, victimizing Hernandez for a second time after being sprung on a counter. In the middle of the penalty area, Castillo used a quick cut onto his right foot to send Hernandez to ground and give himself an opening inside the right post.
Between an assist on the second and playing the shot that set up the third, the late tally was the fourth straight goal to which Castillo had contributed, capping one of the most impressive individual performances of the season.
Unfortunately, that wasn’t enough to claim the league’s Player of the Week honor. Despite the league’s beat reporter naming Castillo as man of the match (and MLSSoccer.com feeling the need to follow up on Castillo’s remarkable night), Akindele got that magic third goal. If you didn’t actually watch the match, you could convince yourself Tesho outplayed Fabián.
Did the 10:30 p.m. ET kickoff leave people voting based on box scores? Or was the league’s vote the result of an honest assessment, that Akindele’s three goals, two of which came on short-range rebounds, outweighs Castillo’s two goals in a performance that defined Saturday’s match? Given the track record of this honor, it seems like the former. Much like last week, when two goals from Chris Schuler got him the nod of Matt Hedges (who took our award), goals the main consideration. While that makes sense, we’re at the point where no other criteria matter.
Regardless, for the second time this season, Fabián Castillo wins PST’s honor. For those that did vote off the box score: You missed a hell of a performance.
- Copa America Final preview: Argentina looks for first title since 1993 against hosts Chile 0
- Transfer Rumor Roundup: KPB to Orlando City, Liverpool in for Brazilian teen 0
- Klinsmann on USMNT’s win over Guatemala: “I’m not happy with that performance” 1
- 2011 Women’s World Cup final loss still burns in Abby Wambach’s memory 1
- USMNT player ratings: How Klinsmann’s men fared against Guatemala 3
- USA 4-0 Guatemala: USMNT cruises into Gold Cup with win in Nashville 0