Skip to content

PST’s Major League Soccer Power Rankings – The faith-destroying edition

Sep 2, 2014, 8:48 PM EST

Omar Gonzalez

Last week’s list sent a small tremor through our pecking order, with two teams who’ve been overlooked for much of the Power Rankings season claiming the PRs’ top two spots. Rewarding our faith, both Dallas and D.C. United lost their next games, affirming the truism beneath each of these posts: Power Rankings just don’t matter.

They do, however, provide insight into how one person sees the league, making the term “faith” even more meaningful. Last week, my faith went to a Dallas team who had just beaten RSL. This week, FCD lost at four-win Chicago.

Last week, I practically apologized to D.C. United for overlooking them the entire season. Ben Olsen proceeded to rotate his squad for a mid-week visit to StubHub, losing 4-1 to the Galaxy in Carson.

That means, for the second week in a row, there’s a shake up at the top, but with Real Salt Lake, Seattle, and (especially) Sporting Kansas City failing to flash a front runner’s form, the decision at the top was an easy one.

First stop on this week’s rankings, Los Angeles:

MORE: Last Week’s Power Rankings | Methodology

RANKING
Up/Down

source:

1 UP 2 LA Galaxy: The Galaxy have outscored their opponents 12-1 over their last 315 minutes. Following lopsided wins over D.C. United and Chivas USA, there’s little doubt: LA deserves this spot. With the league’s best attack and defense, Bruce Arena’s team has to be favored to claim a third Cup in four seasons.   (13-5-7)
source:  2 DOWN 1 FC Dallas: Another week, the loss at Chicago would have sent FCD crashing, but with few others in last week’s top six impressing, the bigger picture wins out. Amid Saturday’s slip in Bridgeview, Dallas is still a team that’s lost one of its last 11, and while falling to one of the league’s worst teams hints that form is waning, we’ll wait for more evidence before casting Dallas back to mid-chart. (12-8-6)
source:  3 DOWN 1 D.C. United: The Black and Red’s mid-week loss was bad, but given Ben Olsen’s decision to rotate his squad, the 4-1 defeat deserves a caveat. Besides, there may be no team in MLS better equipped to pick apart D.C.’s defense than Los Angeles. Instead of being too harsh on United, we’ll give the Galaxy credit. D.C. only gets a small rebuke. (14-8-4)

4 - Real Salt Lake: Getting a point on the road would normally recommend a team for a rise, but given the level of competition (a decent San Jose) and the nature of the draw (no open play goals, a fortunate first half penalty whistle), there’s actually reason to drop RSL. Ultimately, nobody did enough to pass Jeff Cassar’s squad.(11-5-10)
source:  5 - Seattle Sounders:  Seattle took care of business in its 1-0 win over Colorado, but given its opponent has now lost six in a row, the win amounts to holding serve. That may not be the most flattering description of a team’s form, but when that team is at the top of the standings, there are far worse things than meeting expectations. (15-7-3)
source:  6 UP 1 Columbus Crew:  Early feedback from follower @hyptotheticaloutrage asks “how can a team possibly move up when they lost at Montreal?!?!?!” It’s a great if over-punctuated question. Ultimately, these rankings are relative. A team’s absolute result may have been poor, but their form compared to the league may justify the bump. On Saturday, Columbus took what looked like an embarrassing fall in Montréal, but against an Impact team that played beyond its record, it was an understandable result. It certainly did little to sway what we think about the Crew’s chances going forward. (8-9-9)
source:  7 UP 1 Philadelphia Union: With a week on the sidelines, Philadelphia benefits from one of our favorites’ slides. The Union return to the field this week with a home-and-home against Toronto. (7-9-9)
source:  8 UP 4 Portland Timbers:  The Timbers’ big jump is less a result of their impressive 3-0 at Vancouver than the solutions they found on the field. For the first time this year, Portland kept a clean sheet against a team that’s not owned by the league, and with Rodney Wallace conjuring his 2013 impact, Caleb Porter may have a wide option that can balance his attack. If either of those qualities can stick, Portland should return to the postseason. (8-8-10)
source:  9 DOWN 4 Sporting Kansas City:  Kansas City hasn’t kept a clean sheet since June 27, a fact that would be mere trivia if the back five hadn’t been outright terrible over its last 180 minutes. Six goals allowed at home to D.C. and Houston is either an inexplicable phase or a real problem. Even if it’s only a phase, Sporting’s a mid-rankings club until it’s over. (12-8-6)
source:  10 DOWN 1 New York Red Bulls:  A 2-0 loss at D.C. United was par for the course, considering the form the teams carried into the week. The question is whether the Red Bulls have room for improvement. Is last year’s Supporters’ Shield-winning form lurking in there, somewhere, or is this team more of a mid-table, borderline prospect? The talent on the roster says this is where they belong, but last year’s success fosters lingering hope. (7-8-10)
source:  11 UP 2 New England Revolution: Were it not for the debacle that is Toronto, New England would have risen more, but it’s difficult to look at Saturday’s performance and conclude anything but ‘TFC’s really bad, right now.’ In that light, the Revs get the wait-and-see treatment, even amid their improving results. (10-12-3)
source:  12 UP 3 Houston Dynamo: Like New England, Houston would have vaulted higher it is wasn’t for the opposition. Although winning at Sporting can never be taken for granted, KC’s performance against D.C. showed the defending champions are struggling. Credit to the Dynamo: They took advantage of that lull. (8-13-4)
source:  13 UP 1 San Jose Earthquakes:  As has been the case most of the season, San Jose is better than most people acknowledge. And as has been the case most of the season, that performance produced a middling result. One point against Real Salt Lake shows the Earthquakes can compete with anybody at home, but lodged near the bottom of the Western Conference, San Jose needed a better result. (6-10-8)
source:  14 DOWN 4 Vancouver Whitecaps: Let me drag out this dead horse to remind people why Vancouver may be struggling to score goals … Darren Mattocks or Erik Hurtado? Who knows. Sebastian Fernandez or Kekuta Manneh? Again, who knows. Mauro Rosales: Starter or sub? Who. Even. Knows. Twenty-five games into the season, Carl Robinson has only made one concrete decision in attack. At some point, he has to decide who’s going to complement Pedro Morales. (7-6-12)
source:  15 UP 3 Chicago Fire: A deserved win against our ranking’s former number one gave Chicago reason to look beyond Jermaine Jones. With Robert Earnshaw providing goals off the bench, the team may have a way to turn a plague of close games into an occasional victory. This team’s still only four points out. (5-6-14)
source:  16 UP 3 Montréal Impact:  Frank Klopas’s decision to install Andrés Romero, Dilly Duka and Ignacio Piatti in attacking midfield (moving Felipe Martins to a deeper role) has made Montréal into a totally different team. In contrast to most of the season, they’re actually dangerous, capable of creating chances that don’t rely on Marco Di Vaio. If this team continues to improve, it could be a spoiler, going forward. Plus, there’s always CONCACAF Champions League. (5-15-5)
source:  17 DOWN 6 Toronto FC: In the wake of Sunday’s decision to fire Ryan Nelsen, the TFC meltdown has been well documented. Perhaps not discussed enough: Ryan Nelsen was holding the team back. Though it’s risky to replace a coach at this point of the season, Saturday’s result left Tim Bezbatchenko few options. Keeping Nelsen would have hoisted a white flag over what was supposed to be a breakthrough season. (9-9-6)

source:

18 DOWN 1 Colorado Rapids: Pablo Mastroeni touted the positives in Saturday’s performance, but it still wasn’t good. Though a 1-0 loss at Seattle hints the defense was improved, the Sounders could have scored more in the second half. Once the West’s leaders woke up, Colorado looked like the team that’s accumulated six straight losses. (8-12-6)
source:  19 DOWN 3 Chivas USA:  For the last few weeks, we’ve been giving Chivas the benefit of the doubt, with the Goats’ 0-0 draw with Vancouver used us reason to slow their fall. After Vancouver’s collapse to Portland and Chivas’s lopsided loss to the Galaxy, there are no more excuses. Wilmer Cabrera’s is the worst team in Major League Soccer. (6-13-6)

  1. mlsconvert88888 - Sep 3, 2014 at 1:13 PM

    Thanks for the MLS-centric article Richard, and I just want to say I think Power Rankings do matter (if only because it gives us something to read an marinate on while we await more games).

    And I just gotta ask; is the miniature TFC logo a metaphor for the shrinking expectations of the club at this point?

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

Man United thrash Liverpool