Skip to content

Brad Guzan or Nick Rimando – Who will replace Tim Howard for USA?

Sep 4, 2014, 1:09 PM EDT

After Brad Guzan and Nick Rimando play 45 minutes each for the USA against the Czech Republic on Wednesday, it seems as though the battle to replace Tim Howard over the next 12 months isn’t as straightforward as we thought.

Guzan was, and probably still is, the favorite to replace Howard long-term, but Rimando’s second half display against the Czechs was nothing short of sensational and reminded us all of his sublime, if unconventional, talent.

[RELATED: Player ratings, USA vs. Czech Rep.]

Howard’s year-long sabbatical has thrust this discussion into the limelight, as fans of U.S. soccer have long been clambering for Guzan to get more of a chance in goal. How many times have you heard “too bad for Guzan, he has Timmy Howard ahead of him” when dsicussing the USA’s squad? The answer: a lot.

However, Rimando was never in that discussion. Until now.

The Real Salt Lake ‘keeper has suffered from being labelled ‘too short’ and ‘too small to be a goalkeeper’ by many out there. But the man who won the Gold Cup with the USA in 2013, and has been pretty much ever present in Klinsmann’s squad since he took over as boss, is now proving just how good he is. A stunning stat was also pulled out by Paul Carr from ESPN, as Rimando has never lost when playing for the U.S. The Californian ‘keeper has a 13-0-2 record in his 15 caps for the Stars and Stripes. So, he’s a bit of a lucky charm, too, if you believe in superstition.

[RELATED: USA beat Czech Republic 1-0 in Prague]

One of the biggest travesties in Major League Soccer is that Rimando has never won the Goalkeeper of the Year award during his 14-year stint in the league. For Miami Fusion, D.C. United and RSL, he has always been reliable and pulls out highlight-reel saves on a weekly basis. Just ask the locals who watch him at the Rio Tinto. They will not have been surprised by the three stunning stops Rimando made late in the game as the Czechs piled on the  pressure. Rimando made two sprawling saves (watch the highlight video above to see how good they were) with his feet and a few more crucial blocks to keep the home side at bay and persevere the USA’s 1-0 lead. Rimando seems to be grasping this fight for the starters spot and is eager to push Guzan all the way for it.

source: AP

Rimando or Guzan, who you got?

[RELATED: Howard’s sabbatical provides chance for Guzan, Johnson, Hamid]

As for Guzan, his rise in the Premier League with Aston Villa has been a sensational story as the former Chivas USA stopper was released by the Villans in 2012. Without a club, Guzan was quickly signed back up by new Villa manager Paul Lambert and has been the number one ever since. He was Villa’s Player of the Year last season and has already recorded two clean sheets from three matches this campaign.

Guzan didn’t have much to do in his first half display against the Czech Republic on Wednesday, but we know his capabilities. He is still the favorite to replace Howard and many believe that at the age of 29, Guzan should be the preferred choice in goal for the U.S. when the 2018 World Cup rolls around. Rimando will be 39 during the World Cup in four years time, so perhaps that gives Guzan the edge too.

Between now and next year when Howard returns, Guzan has a real battle on his hands just to win the starting spot ahead of Rimando. We all know the U.S. is traditionally a powerhouse in producing goalkeepers, but the strength of it’s second and three string ‘keepers is something else when you consider MLSers Bill Hamid and Sean Johnson are also lined up behind Guzan and Rimando.

Whoever gets the nod to replace Howard permanently over the next 12 months, the U.S. won’t have to worry about the goalkeeping position for quite some time.

That’s a huge plus, even if it provides Klisnmann with one heck of a headache.

  1. bloope - Sep 4, 2014 at 1:37 PM

    I think you go with Guzan. Rimando made a couple of decent reaction saves yesterday but I think overall Guzan is the better keeper. He has solid technique and is still athletic and is used to the game at a higher level having to constantly play world class players in the EPL.

  2. dfstell - Sep 4, 2014 at 1:41 PM

    The point you made at the end was the really good one: We’re blessed for choices. I mean, we took three really good keepers to Brazil and I’m sure we’ll take three really good keepers to Russia in 2018.

    The one thing I’d add is that judging keepers by highlight reel saves is really not a good practice. I mean, there are certainly plays where the defense breaks down or an attacker makes a spectacular individual play and the keeper just has to be an athlete and make the save. But, I think all of our keepers are capable of making a play in those dire circumstances.

    Also, sometimes a keeper “not having much to do” is a result of good communication and teamwork between the keeper and the defenders. It could be that part of the reason that Rimando had more to do in the second half was just worse communication about runners getting in behind or worse communication about closing down players who are about to shoot. It’s really impossible to judge that from TV, but when the defenders don’t change and the keeper does, I tend to suspect that the communication changed for the worse.

  3. rafibomb10 - Sep 4, 2014 at 1:42 PM

    I like Nicky, he is a quality goal keeper, with a great personality. I remember meeting him when I was very young while he was in DC. I just have a hard time believing that Jurgen will continue to carry goalkeepers that are in their mid thirties.

    Think about the next world cup if Howard were to return…Howard-39, Rimando-35, Guzan-33.
    That’s just not going to happen

    What is more likely to happen is Howard will not return from his sabbatacle. Rimando continues for a few more years competing with Guzan, but will eventually lose out on that number one spot and then call it a career internationally.

    Personally, I’d like to see Bill Hamid, and Cody Cropper continue to be moved on to the scene because both of them will be in the conversation in the very near future. Hamid is just too athletic to not, and Cropper is slowly digesting the English game. Both are great talents.

    • Ian's Rushtache - Sep 4, 2014 at 2:33 PM

      I concur in regards to bringing younger guys into the mix. Hamid and Cropper both have a shot at being the next great Murican keeper.

  4. Ian's Rushtache - Sep 4, 2014 at 2:25 PM

    Jorge Campos hates when goalies are judged by height.

  5. goal141 - Sep 4, 2014 at 5:33 PM

    To a previous poster, Howard and rimando are both 35 so they will both be 39 in 2018.

    Guzan will be number 1. When was the last time our number 1 GK had hair?

    • rafibomb10 - Sep 5, 2014 at 10:23 AM

      My aoplogies! You are correct. Math was never my strong point. It does strengthen my argument though. 😉

  6. pensfan603 - Sep 5, 2014 at 6:39 AM

    Bill Hamid, he most likely will be going to epl this coming offseason, and could easily impress.

Leave Comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Not a member? Register now!

Featured video

Premier League, Week 3 review